4 ms·
Why do we have clearly divided zoned areas for work and residential again? What era did that start? I understand if it was a pig slaughterhouse or night club o
by dmix 7y ago
Why do we have clearly divided zoned areas for work and residential again? What era did that start?
I understand if it was a pig slaughterhouse or night club or something like that. But even the early 1900s had office buildings, law offices, various small shops, and other quiet firms.
Seems like a heavy-handed approach in retrospect. If anything the laws should be related to the type of business or externalities (noise, smell, etc) it produces rather than on strict residential/work/industrial lines.
- Symmetry 7y agoProbably 1916 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Zoning_Resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Zoning_Resolution
- rhacker 7y agoWe should set it up so that it is based on air, water, noise pollution zoning: Law offices next to (or inside a single family house should be OK). However, if the law office attracts 50 cars per day, then obviously they are going to break noise/air pollution requirements. Similarly there's no way for a quiet old couple that wants a quiet neighborhood to stay quiet unless the zoning allows for it. A lot of people would consider a Q1 zone anti-familyist but the REASON such a zone would be desireable is that's what rich people pay for - they only want to hear their own noise - so they end up buying 7 lots around their mansion. We shouldn't make the need to want absolute peace and quiet a price but instead just let that group of people that want the same thing live next door to each other. Instead we encourage people to buy rural properties in a forest. Sorry for that aside but zones for quiet level, air and water pollution levels - but traffic induced by business should be considered as part of the zoning, and then get rid of the residential / commercial separation - just focus on the pollutions.
- saltminer 7y agoI think the big problems are parking minimums and a lack of mixed-use zoning in many areas. Walkable areas encourage density, which helps reduce noise and air pollution.
- dylan604 7y agoBecause in the West, people were tired of living on top of each other and wanted their space.
- imtringued 7y agoThat didn't stop them from working on top of each other.
- jseliger 7y agoWhy do we have clearly divided zoned areas for work and residential again? What era did that start? If you really, really want to know: https://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulation/dp/155844288X?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 https://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulatio...
- dmix 7y agoI want to know everything, it’s just a matter of prioritization.