4 ms·
Generic arguments about bad methodology don't invalidate specific arguments about IQ. If he used bad statistical arguments himself in this case, we are in impas
by nabla9 7y ago
Generic arguments about bad methodology don't invalidate specific arguments about IQ. If he used bad statistical arguments himself in this case, we are in impasse.
Of course Taleb understand statistics if he wants to, but he is just pushing his rants and loses his bearings in Twitter. Even his old friends are lamenting his online personality and bitterness.
- iQuercus 7y agoWhat does his personality have to do with what he is arguing? Is he using “bad statistical” arguments or not?
- ilikehurdles 7y ago> Of course Taleb understand statistics if he wants to, but he is just pushing his rants and loses his bearings in Twitter. Even his old friends are lamenting his online personality and bitterness. Generic arguments about personality and character don't invalidate specific arguments about IQ. If I indulge your "argument", from what I see on twitter is threads full of very openly nordic-/white- supremacist keyboard warriors and zerohedge trolls. Of all the people to call out in these threads, Taleb seems the most level-headed.
- reasonaway 7y agobut all his specific arguments are completely false - see the linked blog post!
- cljs-js-eval 7y agoI really, really wish people took bad methodology criticisms more seriously. I have a degree in the social sciences, and if there is one thing that completely defines the field right now it is that you can't use their findings for absolutely anything. A good portion of studies don't replicate, including fundamental ones (in particular see the failed replication here [1] on one on Rand et al, a study on the effects of priming). Priming is a huge topic in social psychology. He understands statistics. I'm not sure his opponents properly understand that when you complain about methodology, the implications are not just "add a section in the paper acknowledging the potential for error", it's "your whole study might be fatally flawed in a way that invalidates all your conclusions". [1]: https://authors.library.caltech.edu/91063/2/41562_2018_399_MOESM1_ESM.pdf https://authors.library.caltech.edu/91063/2/41562_2018_399_M...
- heavenlyblue 7y agoYou could simply conclude that all papers could be true or not. Yet we wrote one, which is also true or not.
- api 7y agoAnother observation: as with any slushy area of science, peoples' willingness to apply skepticism and what they are willing to question tends to be determined by their politics and other biases. Liberals are happy to question IQ and especially race/IQ work while conservatives are happy to question stuff like those gender blinded recruitment studies or those academic trolling studies that try to link conservative opinions with mental illness. The reality is that all of it is very questionable because the entire field is riddled with shaky methodology and down right bad science. From what I've seen of the replication issues the whole field is worse than nutritional science, and that's bad. The degree to which a scientific field is politically weaponized is usually inversely proportional to its "hardness." You don't see the same thing in math or physics. Liberals and conservatives oddly never disagree on the value of Pi or the formula for the Carnot efficiency of a heat engine. The closest things to hard science that you find massive political disagreements on are climate change and evolution, and I've noticed that more serious conservative thinkers are coming around on those topics because the evidence is overwhelming.
- papln 7y ago> Liberals and conservatives oddly never disagree on the value of Pi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill > The Indiana Pi Bill is the popular name for bill #246 of the 1897 sitting of the Indiana General Assembly, one of the most notorious attempts to establish mathematical truth by legislative fiat. Despite its name, the main result claimed by the bill is a method to square the circle, rather than to establish a certain value for the mathematical constant π, the ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter. The bill, written by the crank Edward J. Goodwin, does imply various incorrect values of π, such as 3.2.[1] The bill never became law [...]
- deleted 7y ago