5 ms·
PSA: Most suicides occur while the person is alone. Company can be a strong deterrent to attempting suicide. Thanks in part to an incurable medical condition,
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
PSA: Most suicides occur while the person is alone. Company can be a strong deterrent to attempting suicide.
Thanks in part to an incurable medical condition, I'm sometimes suddenly suicidal and basically deranged. At such times, my adult sons don't leave me alone.
They mostly try to avoid discussing it with me. They don't try to make me feel better or act like unpaid therapists because it not only doesn't work, it's actively counterproductive.
Their policy is to take care of me physically (food, drink, warmth), keep me company and "do not engage Teh Crazeh."
In other words, trying to argue with me at such times about how irrational I am amounts to adding fuel to the fire. It just makes me more upset.
I've lived with this a long time, so I'm often able to just tell them "I'm not right and can't be trusted to be alone right now."
As my health improves, such incidents have become fewer, farther between and shorter in duration. It happened a lot while homeless. It's been much less common since getting back into housing.
- malms 7y ago> incurable medical condition which is ? seriously wondering
- neonate 7y agoReally glad to hear that your sons are there for you. Even gladder to hear that such incidents are fewer and farther between! I can only imagine how much harder it must've been without housing.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoHaving fought depressions myself, I recognize the pattern of "depressives talking bullshit". In depressive episodes your mind believes strongly in how hopeless your situation is. When people challenge that conviction, you'll only come up with more reasons, no matter how hare-brained or even psychotic at times. It's just the way it works...
- belorn 7y agoParent did not mention the word depression, so I do not want to comment on their story, but I want to comment that major depression does have well documented symptoms of transient mental state where delusions and hallucinations feeds into depression. If I remember right from Robert Sapolsky, the mind is creating a plausible explanation for its current state, which is a thing the mind actually does for everyone, but with major depression it becomes quite extreme. It is not something a person can "snapp out" of or be talked into to see things rational. Robert Sapolsky see depression as mostly a biological condition with biological causes, and a common quote from his is that we don't tell people with diabetes to just get over it and start producing insulin.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoWell, if she is supervised for a few days in order to avoid suicide, and tries to convince everybody how bad her situation is, "depression" of one form or another is a pretty good bet. I don't think there even is an alternative explanation for recurring episodes like that.
- DanBC 7y ago> Most suicides occur while the person is alone. Company can be a strong deterrent to attempting suicide. This is a lot more complicated than you're making it out. plenty of people kill themselves in front of their family. Others kill themselves when their family are in the home. Others kill themselves in public. Others kill themselves in hospital wards when they're on 15 minute observations. These are not a tiny fraction of the total number of people who kill themselves. EDIT: I'm glad you've found something that works _for you_, but it's really important to recognise that your experience is not usual, and that many people would find it invalidating. EDIT: Page 33. https://documents.manchester.ac.uk/display.aspx?DocID=38469 https://documents.manchester.ac.uk/display.aspx?DocID=38469 > Living alone -- Women: 45% Men 50% This shows that living alone is a risk factor, but it also shows that most people who die by suicide do not live alone. Page 55 suggests that it's external support that helps, not support by the family: > 149. In 834 (43%) the patient lived alone. They were less likely to receive additional social support from outside the home (e.g. from a relative, friend or neighbour) as part of their care plan compared to those who did not live alone (138, 44% excluding unknowns vs. 270, 71%
- krageon 7y agoYou are correct, if you really want to do it then you are always going to do it. If you just want to do it a lot, sometimes a little company helps! It can't hurt to try, at worst you'll only live a little longer.
- DanBC 7y agoThat's definitely not what I'm saying. Some people don't have a strong intention to die but use a method with high lethality and do die. > It can't hurt to try, at worst you'll only live a little longer. Some people have abusive families that increase risk.
- krageon 7y ago> Some people don't have a strong intention to die but use a method with high lethality and do die. I don't understand what you're saying here. Are you implying a significant enough fraction of people that it bears discussing tries to commit suicide but doesn't really want to die? And even if this is the case, how is that relevant to what we were discussing? > Some people have abusive families that increase risk. I never said it had to be family did I? And even if this is true, why does the fact that this is true for some people mean that the average person should not try it at all? Edit: Not even the original comment was saying it had to be family. They were talking about having company. I don't understand why you are suddenly making this about one specific set of people.