5 ms·
Seems like it comes down to some investors preferring safety so much that they will pay for the privilege? One possible arbitrage here might be for the governm
by skybrian 7y ago
Seems like it comes down to some investors preferring safety so much that they will pay for the privilege?
One possible arbitrage here might be for the governments themselves to issue more debt and invest it? (Essentially, this is a government bank.)
But, the market seems to be saying that there are too few good investment opportunities. Maybe consumption should be higher? A UBI scheme might do it.
- UncleEntity 7y ago> But, the market seems to be saying that there are too few good investment opportunities. Maybe consumption should be higher? The market has very little say in the matter when the central banks force interest rates to near (or equal to) zero -- somewhat ironically to increase consumption by de-incentivising saving.
- skybrian 7y agoCentral banks control the supply of some very safe investments and usually that determines the price. But, someone still needs to own government debt and that depends on demand. There are plenty of other choices for investors, like the stock market or real estate. So, you could either spend the money or choose a riskier investment.
- roenxi 7y agoPossible but highly unlikely; they could literally keep money in a sack under their bed and get better returns. Not much difference between a sack under the bed and a bank account if you don't tell anyone about the sack. I'm guessing it probably either speculators buying bonds assuming that they can be onsold to a central bank, or people who are forced to buy for whatever reason (eg, maybe some savings schemes are forced to put x% into government bonds). I've bought bonds exactly once on the assumption that I could on-sell them for a profit when government lowered interest rates. People like me don't have any impact on the market, but if the incentives make sense at the small level maybe it works out the same on the large.
- your-nanny 7y agoActually, large amount of cash instruments are pretty unweildy things. And you still have to pay to secure it in the meanwhile.
- adventured 7y ago> Not much difference between a sack under the bed and a bank account if you don't tell anyone about the sack. They could hardly be any more different. If one person beyond yourself knows about it, then you're in trouble. One fire or disaster and it's all gone. If it's a smaller sum, you're FDIC insured against loss in a bank account, which again makes the point about just how different the scenarios are. If I feel like it I can safely protect $1 million via four distinct accounts under the FDIC at no cost. The Fed will go back to zero rates at some point to stimulate the US economy. Even when that happens, I'm essentially paying a small insurance fee (inflation vs zero rates) per year to guarantee the safety of the $1 million. That is ultimately far safer than managing it under my mattress. And cheaper, if I need any guaranteed security for the mattress. It's also easier to move at low concern (whether that's to shift it into an investment account or move it to another bank). If it's under your mattress, every move is a high risk for exposure; every person you let deep into your life creates some risk of theft (eg non-malicious gossip).
- demosito666 7y agoWhy not just put it into a bank deposit then? This has positive rate and won't burn as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Finnucane 7y agoLiteral cash under a mattress is not a good option for a pension fund.
- diminoten 7y ago
- igravious 7y agoDo you blame a certain class of investor for being extremely risk-averse? Imagine if you're managing people's retirement money. How would you invest it? People's nest eggs. To put it into computer-nerd context; remember the saying, "nobody ever got fired for buying IBM". Isn't this the same kind of thinking? By the way, what do you think about the idea some are proposing that crypto-currencies are more solid than a gold standard? Instead of transitioning from this central bank backed fiat currency malarkey (which in theory ought to work just fine but doesn't because of greed, collusion, corruption, hubris – i.e., human weakness) back to the gold standard, some say we should move to crypto-currrency standards. I'm not at all versed enough in the tech and theory to know if this is a good idea or not.
- skybrian 7y agoI'm not blaming anyone for wanting very safe, secure investments. What I'm saying is that, if people want safety, maybe the government should provide it? Cryptocurrency is high risk, with both dramatic changes in price and insecure exchanges, so I'm not sure why you bring that up in this context?
- rolltiide 7y agoCentral banks are trying to tell investors to go throw their money at random unproven CEOs Investors are saying they’ll pay for the privilege not to, and some also started buying tiny amounts of bitcoin. Economics consistently fails to predict actual human behavior.