10 ms·
In Minnesota for example, all one needs is another registered voter to vouch for them. My thoughts on this are old school. Like 1700's old school. A person's
by reaperducer 7y ago
In Minnesota for example, all one needs is another registered voter to vouch for them.
My thoughts on this are old school. Like 1700's old school.
A person's right to vote exists with or without documentation. A piece of paper, an entry in a ledger, or a row in a database has no bearing on whether that right exists, or should be exercised.
In many of the states where I've lived (13 so far), all that was needed to vote in the absence of identification was to sign an affidavit stating that I am who I say I am. The people at the polling station could ask for ID, but they couldn't require it. It's up to the people who handle the vote (often the county clerk or county board of elections) to decide later if my vote was valid or not.
A lot of that is changing these days as the concept of being constantly tracked, monitored, and tabulated becomes normalized in America.
Just a generation ago we made fun of the Soviet Union and various totalitarian regimes for having police stop people for no reason and demanding, "papers, please." Now there are people who think it's perfectly OK to require domestic passports ("Real ID" and similar) just to walk down the street.
I wonder if two generations from now people will think we're old and crazy because we don't think it's OK for the government to require a chip be implanted in our brains so our thoughts can be monitored by bureaucratic minders.
It's sounds like tinfoil hat sci-fi slippery slopism, but so would today's facial recognition in airports to people just 50 years ago.
- waffle_ss 7y agoUmm the 1700's in America were the era of needing to have land ownership to vote (more than half of white men couldn't vote), poll taxes, exclusion of blacks, native Americans, and women, religious tests, and so on. The 15th Amendment that changed some of that wasn't even passed until 1870. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_rights_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_rights_in_the_United_St...
- ColanR 7y agoHowever, that's orthogonal to the issue; documentation of your right to vote is not one of the requirements of possessing that right. (as parent said, "A person's right to vote exists with or without documentation.") It is a dramatic improvement that the people with the right to vote has been expanded since the 1700s, but what you said doesn't actually speak against the basic idea that documentation is not relevant to the exercise of ones rights. As an aside: once documentation is required, we enter a position where we do not have our rights until proven otherwise.
- dymk 7y agoHow do you prevent fraudulent voting without being able to tie a vote back to a real, documented person?
- paulddraper 7y agoHow is it irrelevant to their point? Property deeds and literacy tests are documentation, yes?
- mieseratte 7y ago> However, that's orthogonal to the issue; documentation of your right to vote is not one of the requirements of possessing that right. According to whom exactly? As others have pointed out in this discussion, that's not how the US system was designed. There is no inalienable right to vote.
- reaperducer 7y agoAccording to whom exactly? The 14th and 15th amendments to the Constitution.
- Spooky23 7y agoAmendments to the constitution have establish the right. As a society, we decided that tenants, people of non-white races, women, and 18-20 year olds should be allowed to vote. We also eliminated odious standards like counting then-slaves as 60% human.
- paulddraper 7y agoYeah, "old school" was very much for extensive voter qualifications like assets and literacy tests. In fact, that's the whole purpose of the now-awkward electoral college: state legislatures choosing knowledgeable electors to vote for president/VP. --- This an unpopular opinion, but I honestly think there's something to that. My state political party operates on a caucus system, where I don't directly vote for local, state, or federal candidates in the primary (ironically, president is the exception to this); rather I elect a district representative to attend the convention, speak with the candidates, and vote the best one. I don't have time/choose not to have time to do this same level of diligence, and like in many other areas, I am happy to delegate it to one of my known, trusted neighbors. I believe it produces a better, more intelligent, less hysterical media outcome. This is also why I'm not necessarily against non-pathological obstacles in voting. In 2018, my county did a (inexpensive) mail-only election. I wouldn't be surprised is the deadlines, etc. proved to be an obstacle. But....is it really that bad to have that small hoop for people to participate? I don't think so. --- P.S. You know poll taxes aren't taxes at polling stations, right? It just means "flat (non-proportional) tax".
- Spooky23 7y agoPoll tax in context of this topic refers to one of the barriers in the Jim Crow south used to prevent black people from voting.
- eatbitseveryday 7y ago> My thoughts on this are old school. Like 1700's old school. A person's right to vote exists with or without documentation. A piece of paper, an entry in a ledger, or a row in a database has no bearing on whether that right exists, or should be exercised. How do we ensure non-citizens aren’t voting? We accept many visitors - refugees, H1B, tourists, F1/I-20, etc. None are granted voting rights.
- baddox 7y agoIf you’re physically in a jurisdiction, you are subject to its laws. Isn’t the supposed point of democracy to give people a voice in the government that rules over them?
- deogeo 7y agoDemocracy is also an expression of self-determination of a people. Meaning they don't have to let anyone who visits their country sway their decisions.
- baddox 7y agoWho decides what “a people” is? You have a bunch of people in a geographic region, and some of those people get to decide that they are “the people” and that only they get to vote? Sounds pretty blatantly undemocratic.
- deogeo 7y ago> a bunch of people in a geographic region You make it sound as if they just happened to wind up there at random, and have nothing else in common. Geographic proximity is incidental to belonging to a group. The land they live on is merely one of their possessions. Allowing visitors does not mean they must share their sovereignty with them. To answer your question, in democracies, each person can vote to influence their own nation - their demos, even while abroad. You think demos should be decided purely on current location, but most countries disagree - they use mostly jus sanguinis, with the exception of jus soli in the Americas.
- dev_dull 7y agoI like your thought framework but only as it exists within the electorate system. Without that system, a single city in a single state can jeopardize the entire system.
- zdragnar 7y ago> A person's right to vote exists with or without documentation. All rights exist independent on the government, because the government doea not grant rights. The government infringes on rights for the purpose of governing, and the limits to what it is allowed are the US constitution. None of that means that there isn't a legitimate interest, of the government and public at large, in ensuring that elections are conducted fairly.
- User23 7y agoParent is a factual statement about how the Anglo-American legal system works. Other systems may work differently.
- jdoliner 7y agoDo you think voting should be limited to citizens of the country? Or that each person should only get 1 vote? If so that seems impossible to implement without requiring identification, if not that seems tantamount to infringing on people's right to vote, if someone can vote twice against me while I only get 1 vote because I'm following the rules then that means my vote effectively wasn't counted.
- cowsandmilk 7y ago> Do you think voting should be limited to citizens of the country? Oddly, I’m not aware of any state that requires you to prove citizenship to register to vote.
- hirundo 7y agoThe voter ID requirements gather enough info so that a person can be identified, putting them at risk of fines, prison and deportation if their citizenship is challenged later on. That's not perfect but it creates an incentive to not vote fraudulently.
- zucker42 7y agoInstead of just assuming that requiring ID leads to better representation, shouldn't we objectively analyze what choices lead to the best representation? Requiring ID has the obvious tradeoff that it prevents some people who should be allowed to vote from voting. Furthermore, it can potentially lead to a system where people's votes are unfairly discounted because of administrative "errors" (e.g. interstate cross-check). From the evidence I've seen those problems are more significant than double voters or non-citizen voting.
- Alex3917 7y ago> Or that each person should only get 1 vote? What’s wrong with just dipping someone’s finger in ink?
- sokoloff 7y agoMany districts vote over multiple weeks and/or offer absentee voting by mail.
- rpiguy 7y agoYour thoughts are not old school at all. The Constitution initially left it up to the states to determine who was eligible to vote and most states restricted voting to white, male, property owners - thus requiring a deed of property to register. NJ was pretty progressive allowing women to vote if they had property. Identification and Soviet papers are two completely different things. In the Soviet Union and in China until very recently even your travel was restricted by your papers. They weren't just identification, they literally defined where you could go. There is no comparison with a simple, national ID system like the one used in India. Our voting system was largely based on community to enforce voting rights. Meaning you live a small town, everyone knows who you are, and if you aren't supposed to vote you won't get away with it because everyone knows everyone. Today even in small towns many people have no idea who their neighbors are. Your notion on voting rights runs contrary to the concept of citizenship in general, is quite recent, and radical. There is nothing old school about it. I believe the minimum criteria to vote is citizenship. To ensure that only citizens are voting, some paper, ledger, or row in a database must exist somewhere and a means to check that criteria must exist. Oh and letting politicians decide after the fact whose votes count is recipe for disaster.
- selestify 7y agoWhat changed such that nobody knows anybody anymore, even in small towns?
- marcosdumay 7y agoThere are way more people nowadays than there used to be. To make things harder, people can easily move from one place to other very far ones in a short notice, nearly instantly, and with no quarantine period when they will be distrusted by everyone.
- objectivetruth 7y agoSpeed of transportation and speed of communication - when ideas and capital move at light speed instead of horse speed, society changes in correspondingly massive ways.
- mc32 7y agoIt’s not unusual among modern democracies for voters to provide proof of identity. We’re (and the UK?) the outliers in that, so no, I think it’s unrelated to authoritarianism. It’s got more to do with ensuring integrity of votes. India, Mexico, Argentina, Germany, Taiwan, Brazil, Iceland, Costa Rica, etc, require it. Among Americans all major demographics show majority support for voter ID reqs.
- flgb 7y agoAustralia doesn’t require voter ID either. Voter ID is a vehicle for voter suppression (and generally called for by the politically conservative).
- mc32 7y agoYou’re right. I forgot Australia and NZ. Never the less even left leaning or liberal countries out there require ID to vote: Brazil (was left), Sweden, Spain, Greece (Syriza), but then you have truly poor countries with truly poor people who still pull it off, like The Gambia, Ukraine, Libya, etc. Ukraine and The Gambia are made up of many ethnicities and they manage to do it. None the less, we're down the list at no. 26 when it comes to voter integrity[1]. This is from 2014, so it's not encumbered by today's politics. Ahead of us: Norway, Germany, Netherlands, Iceland, Czech Republic, Austria, South Korea, Slovenia, Israel, Cyprus, Lithuania, Australia, Rwanda, Japan, Chile, Italy, Grenada, Malta, Argentina, Georgia and Mongolia. All except Australia req. Voter ID. I (and everyone else) needs to present ID for cold medicine. I don't see this being burdensome. [1]https://www.minnpost.com/eric-black-ink/2014/11/study-ranks-united-states-26th-world-integrity-its-elections/ https://www.minnpost.com/eric-black-ink/2014/11/study-ranks-...
- thatcat 7y agoVoter id is not required because by requiring it you shift voter demographics away from poor/minority/elderly people who don't have an id. The cost for an id should be zero if it is required to vote.
- manigandham 7y agoWalking down the street and voting are not the same thing. ID's are common, the vast majority already have a passport or driver license. You need this much to even be employed so bringing it with you for an election is not an onerous requirement, it's actually completely reasonable. EDIT: It seems HN has rate-limiting for comments now.
- xbmcuser 7y agoIn most countries where an id is a requirement for voting they have systems in place where you can easily get a national id card. In the US Republicans make it as hard as possible for poor people to get an id then are asking to make it mandatory as they are aware most poor people don't vote for them. If they want to enforce id checking for voting then they need to make sure people can easily get an id.
- reaperducer 7y agoIn the US Republicans make it as hard as possible for poor people to get an id then are asking to make it mandatory as they are aware most poor people don't vote for them. While the Republicans take heat for it on the national level, when you examine the issue at state and local levels there's plenty of it on both sides. What disappoints me is that the Democrats rarely push back on these proposals, and when they do it's half-hearted. Republicans used to be the party of freedom as in pioneer guy with a cabin and a mule. Democrats used to be the party of freedom as in ACLU. These days neither is willing to stick their necks out in any tangible way for freedom.
- manigandham 7y agoDifficulty should not overrule importance when it comes to federal elections. > " need to make sure people can easily get an id" I agree. I don't think it's as simple or generic as a single political party preventing it though. Is there a clear example of what is stopping people from obtaining these IDs?
- xbmcuser 7y ago
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoHopefully we get self driving cars you don't need a license for ASAP, so the expectation of every adult constantly carrying around an ID decreases.
- mcny 7y ago> Hopefully we get self driving cars you don't need a license for ASAP, so the expectation of every adult constantly carrying around an ID decreases. I'm sorry but how would I get into a self-driving car? I'd probably not own one. I'd ride in a Waymo, Uber, or some other provider's self-driving car which would mean they'd need to be authenticate who I am and check to see if I am authorized to get in the car...
- thekyle 7y ago> authorized to get in the car I don't know what you mean. In the U.S. you don't need a drivers license to ride in a car. Uber does not currently require any state issued ID for riders and I'm not sure why they would in the future. You might need the Uber app but that isn't tied to any government ID.
- mc32 7y agoNot if you want to buy cold medicine, get a library card, get some beers, buy some legal pot, air b&b, zip car, U-Haul , getting a job, etc. So, you will still need to carry it --unless you want to risk having to go back home in order to do any of the above.
- reaperducer 7y agoNot if you want to buy cold medicine, get a library card, get some beers, buy some legal pot, air b&b, zip car, U-Haul , getting a job, etc. So, you will still need to carry it --unless you want to risk having to go back home in order to do any of the above. You need to have it for those things. You don't need to "carry" it for those things. Nobody does all of those things all the time every day. Going to buy some beer? Bring your ID. Going to walk the dog? Feck off, cop. I'm a citizen minding my own business.
- xienze 7y ago> In many of the states where I've lived (13 so far), all that was needed to vote in the absence of identification was to sign an affidavit stating that I am who I say I am. The people at the polling station could ask for ID, but they couldn't require it. It's up to the people who handle the vote (often the county clerk or county board of elections) to decide later if my vote was valid or not. And this is precisely the problem I have with people who jump up and down screaming that it’s “impossible” for non-citizens to vote because “they have to register.” Clearly there is potential to exploit the system — it’s just the plain old honor system, after all. Maybe it’s just the software developer in me, but I would never ship software that I knew had a critical vulnerability but then rationalize away that it’s so unlikely that anyone would ever exploit it. And yeah, states could follow up on invalid voter registrations, but will they really? One state in particular prides itself on being a “sanctuary state”, yeah I’m sure they’re right on top of making sure illegal aliens aren’t slipping through the cracks and voting after the DMV automatically registered them to vote upon issuing them a license. I also find it funny how the same people that rationalize things the US “should” do because “every other country does it” conveniently ignore that “everyone else” requires ID to vote, but for some reason we’re a special case that can’t possibly accomodate that.
- mehrdadn 7y ago> It's up to the people who handle the vote (often the county clerk or county board of elections) to decide later if my vote was valid or not. You'd really rather have your vote nullified behind your back rather than just be told you can't vote? That sounds like a recipe for a lot of abuse doesn't it?
- reaperducer 7y agoIf votes weren't anonymous, maybe. But they are.
- mehrdadn 7y agoWait, you're assuming anonymity and the ability to "decide later if my vote was valid or not"? How would that work?
- slg 7y agoThe process will vary by jurisdiction, but one approach is to identify if a voter has questionable eligibility when they arrive to the polling place, allow them to fill out a ballot, have them seal it in an envelope, and then label the envelope with the voter's information. You can then take the time to verify the votes validity before the envelope is reopened and the ballot is counted with the other votes. And just like with traditional ballots you can have the process observed by representatives of multiple candidates/political parties to ensure both transparency and that no vote is maliciously discarded.
- mehrdadn 7y agoOh I see. That makes sense if you can get the government to use paper ballots everywhere (best of luck in the US). It does make me wonder how well it would work out in practice though. If verification happens at the same time as the vote, then you can try to correct any issues that come up right then. (Maybe bring additional documentation right then? I don't know.) Whereas if you introduce a delay in between... how many people are actually going to go through the hassle of dealing with it later (especially imagine having to take days off work) to work through the legal bureaucracy and have their votes counted? I feel in the US it seems a little bit too optimistic that it would work out fine, but maybe I'm just pessimistic...
- dymk 7y agoIf you're voting on matters of public policy, you should be in a position where the outcome of that policy affects you as if you are part of that community. Part of that is being... part of that community. Having an ID is a pretty good proxy for that.
- reaperducer 7y agoHaving an ID is a pretty good proxy for that. Having an ID doesn't show someone is part of a community. All it does is provide a way for systems to exclude people.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThen communities should be able to decide who's eligible to vote rather than having that decided at the top and promulgated downwards.
- turk73 7y agoTo me, you are incorrectly conflating a couple of important details. First off, NOBODY wants the "papers please" bs. The whole point of voting is for citizens to elect their leadership, who supposedly represent them. If non-citizens vote, it destroys the entire purpose of all of it. We live in an age of unprecedented illegal immigration because it is "compassionate" or because virtue signaling is fashionable and profitable. No other civilization in human history has undergone what we are attempting. I personally don't think it leads anywhere positive, but I have little say in what happens there. Right or wrong, for tax paying citizens to just be okay with anyone showing up and demanding voting rights, access to welfare and services, and whatever else is a big problem. The system can only withstand so many free riders and poorly informed voters before it fails. Enter voter ID. I don't like the idea, but I realize it is necessary given how the Liberals and Establishment GOP are treating citizens. It's like we don't matter as long we keep paying for all of it. But any reasonably intelligent person can see that they're being taken advantage of here. All to cement power in one uni-party system. Worst of all, the disadvantaged people they are moving here en masse are mere pawns in a game--they don't care what happens to them anymore than they care what happens to us as they move in millions more and spread them around the nation in order to modify voting patterns. It's sickening.