4 ms·
So how does BitCoin Cash distribution get handled in USA? Is it like a dividend? A stock split? A spin-off? What about all of these airdropped tokens? Are the
by Scoundreller 7y ago
So how does BitCoin Cash distribution get handled in USA?
Is it like a dividend? A stock split? A spin-off?
What about all of these airdropped tokens? Are they dividends, with tax payable even if you didn’t “collect” them in some way? Or splits?
Can you deduct the Day1 value of the new token from the capital gain on the first token? Or do you assume the cost of the new token was $0 and any sale is a total capital gain?
- bb88 7y agoMy understanding is they're still investment property. So probably more like a stock split. IOW, there wasn't a sale and a re-buy. You had 1000 shares of bitcoin and now you have 2000 shares, some of which are in bitcoin-A and some of with are in bitcoin-B. As to the cost you would probably assume the Day-1 value after the split for the new coins. The price of the split of the old coins should have been reflected in the price.
- Scoundreller 7y agoAh, the other word I was looking for was “spin-off”, but usually paperwork needs to be filed with the government for it to be considered a tax-free distribution, instead of a dividend. Like HP becoming 2 separate companies. With coins, there’s no central issuing authority filing this kind of paperwork, so I always wondered if these spinoffs were taxable distributions.
- pilingual 7y agoI'm not sure the burden is on the individual unless they recognize receipt of the cryptocurrency. If someone mails you $100 and you discard it I don't think you owe taxes on it. Same for air drops and forks like Bitcoin gold. Bitcoin cash, if you acknowledged receipt of it, is exactly like earning $266 and must be reported, at least that's what tax experts noted at the time: https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2017/08/04/how-to-report-bitcoin-cash-and-avoid-irs-trouble/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2017/08/04/ho...
- Scoundreller 7y agoThe $100 for nothing, I agree. But if something that you owned mailed you $100 because you owned them, that sounds taxable in some way.
- modeless 7y agoYeah the IRS has a lot of explaining to do before people can be expected to pay accurate taxes on cryptocurrency. I've been handling forks/airdrops as ordinary income at the time of the airdrop, at least for the ones I know about and can collect. That's the most conservative way to do it, and I suspect that the IRS will require it even though it's a stupid way to tax airdrops. The right tax treatment would be the same as stock splits but unfortunately when I looked at the rules for stock splits they were narrowly written to apply only to stock. IANAL, this is not tax advice, etc.
- heed 7y agoForks are a unique economic situation. I think a slightly more accurate metaphor is if someone printed money and mailed it to you. A cost basis of 0 on a sale is the most "fair" way to account for forks/drops/etc. imo. Otherwise there's too much burden on the individual to keep track of all the many forks that occur.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Forks are a unique economic situation Companies pay stock dividends, in themselves or in a subsidiary they're spinning out to shareholders, all the time. Using a reasonable materiality threshold (which would allow for ignoring novelty forks) this isn't a challenging accounting problem.
- Scoundreller 7y agoBut the paying Corp needs to declare dividends. If it’s not declared properly, it’s usually treated as highly taxed income. Source: warning from an accountant on self-owned corporations
- lawn 7y agoIn Sweden the value of the coin in a fork (like Bitcoin Cash) should be zero.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThis definitely makes the math easy for determining acquisition cost.
- defen 7y agoNot a tax professional, and you should get professional advice if you're in this situation; but the way I handled it was by treating it as regular income (since the IRS defines "gross income" as "all income from whatever source derived"). So pay regular income tax on it, using the initial trading price to determine how much. Thenceforth it's a regular capital asset with a cost basis of whatever you used as the initial price. Essentially, it's like you found X dollars and used all of it to purchase the newly forked coin. You have to pay income tax on the found money.
- josu 7y agohttps://www.coindesk.com/got-free-crypto-fork-heres-tell-irs https://www.coindesk.com/got-free-crypto-fork-heres-tell-irs
- Scoundreller 7y agoSummary of article: nobody knows. You could be conservative and be either paying the right amount or overpaying. Or you could be aggressive, and be either paying the right amount or underpaying. Nobody seems to know what the right way to treat these common situations, but the IRS wants you to figure it out and they’ll decide if you were right or wrong. I did like the story’s example of buying a pregnant cow though.