4 ms·
I've been in the cloud space for a relatively long time, worked at AWS 2008-2014, and have followed all three big cloud providers since inception. My personal
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
I've been in the cloud space for a relatively long time, worked at AWS 2008-2014, and have followed all three big cloud providers since inception.
My personal view is that both Azure and GCP boost their "cloud" revenues by 50-60% - e.g. GSuite is included in GCP, some various Office and Enterprise software products by Microsoft are included in Azure.
They do this primarily to convince corporate customers that they've closed the gap with AWS, and their service is now comparable.
From a technical standpoint, and still IMHO, Google has fewer products, but several of the ones already available are usually quite superior to AWS. AWS has of course the broadest set of services. Azure is still quite a mess, but that doesn't prevent a thriving ecosystem, an easier integration, etc, to convince many customers to use Azure.
It's going to be a long battle, for a huge and growing market. And unfortunately for their customers, it means that lock-in, FUD, and other nefarious practices will be common.
- lumost 7y agoYou could flip that and say that AWS under-performs in straight SaaS like github, gsuite etc.
- panpanna 7y agoEven if your numbers are correct, it is still most relevant to customers that azure can scale up to <some big number>. That part of that big number is used internally is not an issue, dogfooding is a good thing and further demonstrates that cloud is a real priority for Microsoft.
- yyyk 7y agoSo what? Had gsuite/office been made by a 3rd party company, you would have counted them in, right? And had Google/MS not have a cloud presence so these products would have been hosted in a different cloud, they would have been counted in your estimation as well, right? This case is technically no different than the others. It is a fact Office/GSuite are rather reliable and fast. It's a credit to their respective clouds, and obviously propels them forwards in their competition with AWS. The respective companies are right to include these in total revenue/marketshare, and it is good to see that they eat their own dogfood. We could have flipped that around and ask why Amazon doesn't trust AWS, but I recall that Amazon does have a few things there too...
- leereeves 7y agoIs the cost of GCP/Azure also deducted from GSuite/Office profits?
- yyyk 7y agoI suspect it is, though I haven't delved in their financials to prove it. Giving a different internal pricing to their own product could be constructed as an anti-competitive action, and someone would have sued them for that. If they merely didn't report it [that is, didn't count it in Office/GSuite costs], it would sound like hosting for free which again could be considered anti-competitive, so that sounds unlikely to me. My original comment was just saying that there's no good reason not to count GSuite/Office in respective GCP/Azure marketshare. Obviously these cloud-products could have been hosted in different clouds, but they aren't.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI disagree with you. If you want to tell me how big your public cloud is, in terms of revenues, you are not going to count revenues that come from software than runs on top of it. By that account, AWS could say: 30B, plus 200B more, taking into account the revenues of Salesforce, Elastic, etc. It makes no sense to conflate these two very different categories.
- yyyk 7y ago*"revenues that come from software than runs on top of it" I am not sure I understand you here. Do you mean "what the software is paying to run on the cloud" (even if the payment is 'merely' internal accounting) or "what customers are paying for the software that runs on the cloud"? I meant the former, and that's the way I read your original comment. But your latest comment seems to refer to the latter? I agree these would be different categories (IaaS/PasS vs SaaS). I was saying that MS/Google should be able to count Office/GSuite hosting expense on their cloud - it would be no different if it were some 3rd party product - not that they could count what customers are paying for these products.