4 ms·
I would hope that my doctor uses mainstream technology (internet, iPad) and could differentiate between what is "common" and what is possible. If one isn't abl
by mistermann 16y ago
I would hope that my doctor uses mainstream technology (internet, iPad) and could differentiate between what is "common" and what is possible.
If one isn't able to do that, I would seriously question their ability to properly diagnose complex ailments.
- sethg 16y ago“Enterprise” software, as a rule, has horrible user interfaces. The people who buy this kind of stuff are three layers of management removed from the people who actually use it, the software is often customized, and quality of user experience is not a critical factor in the purchasing decision. From the perspective of a non-geek who works in a medium-to-large company, bad “enterprise” software is just an irritation that goes with the job, like bad coffee. You may complain about it but you don’t seriously expect it to be fixed.
- dkarl 16y agoIf you pick up a book on best practices in development of enterprise software, it is basically a catalog of obviously beneficial things that people fantasize about in the pages of a book because they are never allowed to do them in real life. For instance, talking to prospective users. The importance of this has been stressed over and over again and is no longer disputed. In fact, when an in-house team started designing changes to an accounting app my friend had to use, there was an official user expert designated to work with the developers. The user "expert" was her manager, who had never used the application that was being changed, had never used a similar application, and had never even done a job similar to the one done by the users. What's more, she forbade the developers to speak to the users because she didn't want the development effort to affect their productivity. Oh, it did affect their productivity eventually, believe me it did. (It's an exaggeration to say it's uniformly terrible; I had a good experience with the one enterprise app I built, but it was for a network operations team, so they understood a lot about software and about the need to be generous with time and access.)
- dkarl 16y agoPrivacy laws and regulations restrict what doctors can do with technology. I'm mostly happy about that obstruction, just because I know who has the greatest interest and ability to influence medical IT (the insurance companies) and what their motivations are (sell private information, deny claims, only cover healthy people.) A guy in the oil business once told me a story about why Bangladesh's gas fields have not been thoroughly exploited yet. Basically it was a big tangle of political crap -- and according to him, Bangladeshis are very happy not to have the gas fields exploited, because they assume that both the current leadership and the opposition party are so corrupt that all the money would be stolen anyway, so it's better if the gas is not exploited until the far future when some of the money might go to the people. I have no idea if that's true or not, but it captures why I'm mostly glad that the use of technology in medicine is stuck in the dark ages. Until there is some stakeholder involved who gives a crap about patient rights and privacy (the doctors care about effective treatment, but not rights or privacy) it's best if nothing changes at all.
- joe_the_user 16y agoBut the thing is, biological systems are incredibly complex and poorly understood. So in a biological system, you can't say "we can do X so it should be an easy step to do Y". If one was reasoning about a computer in the way you have to reason about a biological system, there wouldn't be any reason to think that since you can create with a browser unlimited character field it, you can create a medical transcription system with an unlimited character field.