3 ms·
I think you're ignoring the difference between a simulation (or model) and an emulation. A bottom-up approach produces an emulation. AFAIK, nobody has ever cla
by derefr 7y ago
I think you're ignoring the difference between a simulation (or model) and an emulation. A bottom-up approach produces an emulation.
AFAIK, nobody has ever claimed to be trying to produce a human whole-brain emulation in the style of https://neurokernel.github.io/ https://neurokernel.github.io/. It's a problem that is obviously intractible right now.
- wuliwong 7y agoI don't think what you are saying is correct. Isn't an emulator something that takes the same inputs and produces the same outputs? I don't think "bottom-up" has anything to do with it.
- krastanov 7y agoI doubt most people reading the phrase "simulating a human brain" will make the distinction between simulating and emulating. The distinction is very technical and simply does not exist in the everyday use of the word "simulate".
- RandomTisk 7y agoAs a layman, I imagine the simulation would have to account for any one of the thousands of different compounds and chemicals in the brain where emulating it might be easier but a lot less useful, like testing drugs on mice versus humans, never knowing what real difference will make an important one.
- marmaduke 7y agoAnd yet the distinction is important as we are discussing a project on the very topic. I don't think anyone playing SimCity thinks there's a whole real city running on their CPU. And certainly no one has a heart attack if you say SimCity is a simulation of a whole city.
- Dylan16807 7y agoIf any model counts, then I can "simulate a human brain" as a sphere on a stick figure given five minutes in a physics sim. We need to have some standard, and I would say the bare minimum is modeling each neuron in an ultra-simple way along with the connections between them.
- Retric 7y agoDepending on what your doing modeling individual nerve cells may be pointless. For example, a stroke simulation may care a lot more about blood flow than communication between nerves.
- Dylan16807 7y agoIt's certainly a useful project but don't call your blood flow simulation or vague activity map "simulating a human brain".
- dTal 7y agoWhat if it turned out that neurons are highly redundant, and you can very effectively model network activity at a statistical level well above that of the individual neuron?
- slavik81 7y agoI've spent a few years studying biological modelling and simulation (of plants) but I've never heard of this distinction. Is it specific to neuroscience? What exactly is the "bottom" in a bottom-up approach?
- marmaduke 7y agoIt's a distinction that physicists have brought into the field, the bottom refers to the lowest level of detail, usually cellular but sometimes molecular.
- phs318u 7y ago> What exactly is the "bottom" in a bottom-up approach? Great question (to which I have no idea what the answer is). It seems to me that the various attempts are trying to simulate sets of emergent behaviours at different levels of the brain's "stack". I guess, one way of determining the success of a "lower level" simulation/emulation, is the emergence of known "higher level" behaviours?