3 ms·
Perhaps someone with more self-driving car knowledge can help enlighten me, but from everything I've read it seems like the biggest problems are from unexpected
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
Perhaps someone with more self-driving car knowledge can help enlighten me, but from everything I've read it seems like the biggest problems are from unexpected behaviors in urban environments (e.g. cyclists going the wrong way, stopped delivery vehicles that folks behind must scoot out into the oncoming traffic lane to drive around, police officer directions, etc.) and I just don't see how those problems can be solved without artificial general intelligence, which is a long ways off.
For restricted access roads (i.e. highways), though, the technology seems ready to go. I know there is a lot of concern about the "hand-off problem", but that doesn't really seem like an insurmountable issue. If say 35 mins of a 45 min commute is on a highway, and only the last 10 mins are in a city, that seems like it would be a huge noon to tons of people if the car could take over, completely, on the highway. Are manufacturers likely to take this middle step first?
- eclipxe 7y agoYes, see Tesla Autopilot...
- justapassenger 7y agoAutopilot works but only in a very clean cases highway environment. It cannot with a lot of unexpected situations, like lane closures, stopped cars, and many many others. It’s good assistant, as those situations happen rarely, but they do happen and autopilot will crash if human won’t supervise and takeover
- JustSomeNobody 7y ago... run right into the side of an 18 wheeler.
- notatoad 7y agoonce. they still crash less often than human drivers crash their cars on the highway. I don't want to say Autopilot is good, but everything else is also terrible.
- foobiekr 7y agoSince Tesla has never released the data for that claim, taking it at face value seems pretty iffy given other claims by the company.
- JustSomeNobody 7y ago> once. At least twice.
- FireBeyond 7y agoIn conditions suitable for Autopilot in the first place. Autopilot is most often turned off when things get 'messy', a luxury humans don't have, and that Tesla often "neglects" to mention when they're preening over this sound bite.
- rainyMammoth 7y agothose are bullshit stats. They compare overall crashes in all kind of normal highway environment and all kind of drivers and vehicles with the very selective places where the Tesla users decided to enable autopilot. Tesla users are also more educated and have better vehicles which has been shown to reduce the comparative crash rate by a lot. We don't have data to compare but if I had to take a wild guess on crash rates I am pretty convinced that Tesla crashes more than the equivalent driver on the same stretch of highway as of today.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI didn't ask about advanced cruise control. Autopilot still requires your attention and your hands on the wheel. "Self driving", to really add value, means I need to be able to do something else (read a book, watch a movie) safely.
- nradov 7y agoYes controlled access highways will be first. GM Super Cruise is already in use on some freeways.