4 ms·
I have the feeling this has much more to do with our self inflicted lifestyle than genetic factors. Maybe no other animal is just that stupid.
by raxxorrax 7y ago
I have the feeling this has much more to do with our self inflicted lifestyle than genetic factors.
Maybe no other animal is just that stupid.
- klodolph 7y ago> Maybe no other animal is just that stupid. Have you ever owned a cat or dog? My experience is that a percentage of them will overeat unless constantly monitored, eat things that are outright dangerous, etc. What is it that makes humans the stupid ones, here?
- chosenbreed37 7y agoI wonder whether or not we should distinguish between domesticated animals and wild ones
- masklinn 7y agoIt would be an interesting (if difficult) experiment but from what I know wild animals will absolutely gorge themselves if they can. The difference is that in the wild, this is tends to be quickly followed by a resource crash from a normal cycle (e.g. winter crash after summer glut) and / or population explosion. I don't know that any organism has had evolutionary-scale periods over which to psychologically integrate an access to essentially unlimited (in time and quantity both) resources.
- humanrebar 7y agoI have seen wild geese eat too much seed from bird feeders and practically lose the ability to fly. I suspect the correcting mechanism for that is generally predation.
- Retra 7y agoLabradors usually have a genetic disorder that causes them to gorge themselves, so they are highly prone to obesity. They are also very popular breeds in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labrador_Retriever#Inherited_disorders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labrador_Retriever#Inherited_d...
- ci5er 7y agoThis is interesting. Growing up, we had chickens, sheep, goats, cows, horses, dogs, cats and rabbits. And an unfortunate sampling of salamanders, frogs, horny toads, chipmunks, gophers, wild-rabbits, foxes, coyotes, hawks (various types), eagles (a few types), skunks, deer, antelope, raccoons and badgers. (I'm probably missing a few - and I've certainly left out small birds, which require their own reading as do snakes) Left to their own devices (they weren't each individually heavily supervised - especially when on the range), of the domesticated ones, the only ones that would gorge themselves to death were the horses (when they thought they were getting away with something), with the minor exception of the dogs (who might eat the other animal's grain-based food out of jealousy, and explode their gut because they ate the wrong food because of stupidity) I did not find that, unmonitored, most animals would eat too much of the wrong type of food for too long (loco-weed for cows might be an exception - but that didn't kill them).
- cpp4life 7y agoOr no other animal is smart enough to be able to produce an abundance of food for the scale of population that we can. And also no other animal has capitalism which motivates actors to make the food supply as addictive as possible.
- masklinn 7y ago> Or no other animal is smart enough to be able to produce an abundance of food It's not just the abundance of food, it's the sustained abundance. Many species follow a feast / famine cycle which puts pressure on stocking up as fast as possible during feast in order to survive the inevitable famine. This is the evolved instinctual mechanism which gets shot to piece by the "endless feast" available to many individuals in advanced economies (or wealthy enough individuals in pre-industrial economies), even more so combined with the physical "leisure" (limited requirements of extensive physical activity in day to day life).
- humanrebar 7y agoMost of the other animals get eaten when they stop being athletic. But some seem fine with layers of blubber. It's a feature, not a bug sometimes.
- raverbashing 7y agoOther animals usually have a lifespan shorter than the time needed for atherosclerosis to be an issue And the title is a bit incorrect, other animals do suffer with heart issues/"heart attacks" (usually congenital, but due to old age as well)
- masklinn 7y ago> Maybe no other animal is just that stupid. They very much are, many pets will way overfeed themselves if given the opportunity. Though it might also be human-inflicted, I don't know if wild animals will do so if provided with effortless unlimited amounts of food. I would expect so though, most evolutionary environments simply don't set up organisms for an unlimited glut of free energy-dense food, when there's a glut of resources it's usually followed by some sort of crash, so organisms stock up as fast as they can in order to out-compete their peers once resources crash. If the glut doesn't end (which is essentially what modern advanced economies arrived at), neither does the tendency to stock up, because there's probably never been an evolutionary context (sustained for a long enough period) where that was an issue and thus allowed some organisms to outlive others.
- Ensorceled 7y agoThere are quite a few instances where wild animals have almost unlimited food and reduced predators, in every instance I’ve heard of, they just breed like crazy.
- masklinn 7y agoYes, even if the crash is not an environmental cycle, a crash will generally occur because the glut of resources allows a population explosion which eventually consumes the available resource.
- Ensorceled 7y agoThis is one of the hardest systems effects to explain to people every time there is a deer cull; the population doesn't stabilize, it grows until the food runs out and then crashes with vast numbers of deer starving to death. That a fair number of people still believe that it's more "natural", and thus better, for the bulk of the herd to starve to death rather than a percentage of the herd being hunted is one of the more curious animal rights positions.
- masklinn 7y ago
- Clor 7y agoFrom the introduction: "There are many known risk factors, including blood cholesterol, physical inactivity, age, hypertension, obesity and smoking, but in roughly 15 percent of first-time cardiovascular disease events (CVD) due to atherosclerosis, none of these factors apply."