6 ms·
Interesting, Apple could do some interesting things with this. The qualcomm situation has resulted in a lot of stagnation in our industry. Companies like Apple
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
Interesting, Apple could do some interesting things with this. The qualcomm situation has resulted in a lot of stagnation in our industry. Companies like Apple are forced to work with them. But given their track record as being aggressive on the IP front (both sides), they have to spend a lot of effort engineering around this stuff. Companies like Intel, Qualcomm, Nokia own a lot of these patents and Apple has been paying them off for as long as the iPhone has been around.
To this day there's not a single Apple laptop that ships with built in 4G modems even though that would make sense from a functional point of view. I suspect the reason is not technical but related to IP and pushback from other players in the ecosystem (e.g. operators). As soon as you add 4G/5G to the mix, there are suddenly a lot of sneaky patents that come into play.
At least you can't tell me that nobody in Apple pondered the question "hmm I wonder which of our Mac Book Air customers would not like to be connected anywhere on this planet". The reason this is not a feature is that it would add a lot of cost related to patents and IP licensing. This deal might fix that partially. Software sims have been similarly difficult for the same reasons and another thing Apple has been pushing on lately.
Apple doing this stuff in house means they can push harder on this front.
- tpetry 7y agoTheres really no great need in 4g for macbooks? I mean you can activate your wifis hotspot with handoff directly from your macbook without ever touching your iphone.
- ilogik 7y agoassuming you have an iphone, and it has plenty of battery...at one point after using the hotspot for a while my iphone showed a temperature warning, and I had to wait for it to cool off before I could use it again. Having the laptop battery and cooling would be much better
- toxik 7y agoAnd internet sharing makes a lot more sense FROM a computer to a handheld than vice versa
- samdoidge 7y agoYou need the modem within a mobile phone, but now you're adding it to a laptop in addition. It isn't clear it makes more sense to me.
- londons_explore 7y agoYou could argue that perhaps the computer shouldn't have built in WiFi either - after all, it could tether to a phone (via a cable or Bluetooth) to use wi-fi. Except WiFi modems are cheap because there is lots of competition and most of the patents are easy to license, so everything has WiFi now.
- samdoidge 7y agoFor me to have 4G access, I need to connect to a network, and for that I need to pay. I currently do this through my phone which I need to be connected when there is no wifi more than my laptop. Is the price of 4G access low enough to have this on my laptop in addition to my phone? Not currently.
- scarejunba 7y agoOn Google Fi it’s no additional charge.
- ubermonkey 7y agoMan, I use the hotspot function of my iPhone all the time and never have heat issues. I wonder why?
- tw04 7y agoProbably a combination of what surface you have it sitting on and which case you use (if any).
- freehunter 7y agoAnd ambient temperature and air movement. Anything that impacts heat dissipation. I was in Phoenix AZ last week when it was 115F and my phone’s hotspot shut down because the phone got too hot.
- ubermonkey 7y agoYou were outside? I mean...
- freehunter 7y agoNot exactly outside, but in a building without air conditioning yes. Yes it was awful.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoProbably because you're close to whatever tower it's connecting to and the radio bits are not having to spend a bunch of energy screaming at the top of their lungs to be heard by the tower. Even plastic clad android phones will get hot if you try and make a long phone call from BFE.
- ce4 7y agoalso the Mac may detect it as a metered mobile connection and defer/throttle background usage (updates, etc).
- pier25 7y ago> assuming you have an iphone Any phone can do that, not only iPhones. How often are you on the move without a phone? Also the battery argument is not so definitive since a laptop on 4G/5G would also consume battery. If you can connect your laptop to a wall outlet you can connect your phone too.
- drbojingle 7y agoAssumes you have wifi hotspots in range and an iphone that's configured correctly with adequate battery.
- pbalau 7y agothe phone would be a wifi hotspot, sharing it's 4g connection with the laptop, via wifi.
- ninkendo 7y agoOr if you don't have much battery, you can kill two birds with one stone by plugging the phone into the laptop and tethering over USB while charging it.
- drbojingle 7y agoor you could buy a laptop with 4g :P
- georgespencer 7y agoApple has investigated this over the years, even getting as far as building a red board prototype 3G MacBook Pro in 2007: https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-wants-its-3g-macbook-prototype-back/ https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-wants-its-3g-macbook-prototy... (Green and blue boards tend to be for production-ready prototypes, red is fairly hacked together.) I believe the objections are 50:50 software-related and battery. How do you set suitable data usage thresholds on a Mac which is running over a 3/4/5G LTE network? The thermal performance of MacBook Pro is already weak at the high end and battery life suffers. I would be surprised if, when Apple switches to its own power efficient chipset in its portable Mac line, they don't offer a BTO option which includes cellular capabilities through a built-in SIM.
- swiley 7y agoIt’s not hard to write something that kills an interface shortly after the transmitted data crosses a threshold (I’ve done it multiple times for myself.) I’m still surprised apple has refused to add this to any of their OSes.
- pbalau 7y ago> The reason this is not a feature is that it would add a lot of cost related to patents and IP licensing. Looking at the numbers here(1), this is not right. They sold ~46 millions iPhones, ~9 millions iPads for a rounded total of ~50 millions devices with a GSM modem. Meanwhile, they "only" sold ~5 millions Macs, which include all the laptops and desktop offerings. Therefore, adding a GSM device to all their mobile offerings would only mean ~10% increase in number of modems (assuming all of those 5 millions macs are actually laptops). I would "blame" the lack of such an offering on the same reason they don't offer many different ports, like headphones, non usbc usb, hdmi etc. 1. https://www.macworld.co.uk/news/apple/apple-financial-results-3581769/ https://www.macworld.co.uk/news/apple/apple-financial-result...
- jillesvangurp 7y agoI think you under-appreciate how stupendously expensive it is to settle patent disputes. There's no question that 4G would have been useful in laptops and given that Apple sells them at a premium, even small increases in market share are very lucrative. The reason they didn't was cost and mitigating risks infringing on relevant patents. For a phone this is essential and not optional, for a laptop this isn't the case.
- pbalau 7y ago> I think you under-appreciate how stupendously expensive it is to settle patent disputes. I'm arguing that they already solved this issue, since they are selling so many devices with GSM modems. Unless you can provide documentation demonstrating otherwise, I am not going to believe their agreement is to use GSM modems only on iPhones and these particular models of iPads, but is to use GSM modems on whatever devices they see fit. I don't think Apple are that stupid to limit themselves like that.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoIt's very unlike Apple to deliberately ignore an opportunity to sell a bit of convenience as a premium. Lots of ipad owners own iphones and yet buy the ipad with a 4G modem that they technically don't need. An always on Mac Book Air that "just works" is such an obvious thing to do given the target demographic of people using this on the go, that there must be another reason than "we already sell iphones/ipads". I don't buy the "users don't need this argument" since, I see way too many people thethering their macs with separate access points that are definitely not their phone for this not to be a thing at least.
- philg_jr 7y agoI don't understand why it could drastically increase the price of a Macbook. I can buy a ThinkPad or a Dell Latitude/Precision with a Sierra Wireless 4G M.2 card for only an extra $2-300, basically the price of the card if you were to buy it separately. Older generations of ThinkPads could also have a 4G M.2 card easily added after purchase because the antennas were built-in from the factory (did this with my X260). I suppose (guessing) if this was a SoC and there were no standard M.2 slots, then I guess I could see why Qualcomm would want some extra royalties in that case.
- Spooky23 7y agoEven with Apple margins, the cellular radio adds like $150 to an iPad. The technical issues are accommodating it with the design decisions made. Personally, I think it’s a smarter decision to make the iPhone/iPad pairing model low friction, as Apple has. This is also a small/minority use case. LTE laptops are a very small product category — nobody wants to add a cellular plan. This feature will only matter if carriers start killing cable with millimeter wave 5G.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThe only reason it adds $150 is the ridiculousness surrounding Qualcomm licensing.
- rhymer 7y agoIf I remember correctly the royalty was $7.5 per iPhone. Not sure how that alone contributes to the $150 price hike.
- ksec 7y agoThere is at least $40 worth of BOM cost from additional Antenna, baseband Modem and other RF Related Component. And it is not only Qualcomm which collect royalty on LTE, Ericsson, Nokia, ZTE and many others all collect royalty. I do remember the royalty fees for Non-Smartphone ( Or Devices with only Data line ) were cheaper. But together it would still easily be $30+.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoHow are carriers going to kill cable with 5G? Won't they still want to charge $10/Gb? If that's the case, 4G is already faster than a lot of people's current connection at $50. If you use more than 5 Gb per month, it wouldn't make sense to go full mobile. For example, 30 minutes of TV every other day is already pushing 8 Gb...
- Spooky23 7y agoWhen there are competitive spirits at work, prices magically drop. I pay Spectrum $69 for 100/5 service in my city, which has no other options. My brother pays $45 for 300/30 service 4 miles away in a suburb where Verizon has chosen to compete as there are fewer poor people. Right now there's a 5G land-grab going on, with hundreds of millimeter-band 5G poles being dumped everywhere. I assume that's for a wireless fixed ISP service, as it doesn't add value for normal mobile service.