4 ms·
Database of police who shoot citizens reveals who’s most likely to shoot
- tinus_hn 7y agoIt looks like a lot of data and some poor statistics.
- gillesjacobs 7y agoThe blog post does not include the original analysis. You can find the full study here: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1903856116 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1903856116 PNAS is a highly regarded and high impact journal with stringent peer review. Scepticism is always a must in sociology. However, it is poor form to outright dismiss the findings as "poor statistics" without argument or reference to the source.
- vikramkr 7y agoI've seen some pretty iffy articles on molecular biology/micro biology etc published in nature (not scientific reports) science cell. They were studies that were technically OK, but made some excessively bad claims and questionable methodological choices (eg left out performing a validation step that's cheap and the next step in the research, curiously resigning that step for anyone who would try and replicate the study). Prestige of the paper only says standards are higher, not that any given paper is great, and especially not that the conclusions are great.
- gillesjacobs 7y agoHere is the original paper: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1903856116 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1903856116 They use multinomial regression analysis with several county-level socioeconomic factors. It looks like a solid study that shows no statisticly valid correlation between victim and shooter ethnicity can be established.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoProfiling stability of both the police and the potential victims should be able to predicatively show who is danger of being shot. Making that into a public health survey could be beneficial.
- ultrarunner 7y agoIf use county-level data how do they account for more granular neighborhood demographics? Maricopa County encompasses all of Phoenix, Glendale, Mesa, etc. Cook County has a huge amount of the Chicago metro area. I expect this effect plays out throughout the US.
- pssflops 7y agoPerhaps from crime reporting aggregation like how heyjackass[0] does it. [0]: https://heyjackass.com/ https://heyjackass.com/
- alfromspace 7y agoSo it sounds like the entire national narrative about racism and law enforcement we've been having for years now is built on sand.
- colanderman 7y agoNo, because that narrative has focused on systemic racism, which has nothing to do with the race of the individual officers, but rather with policing policies. e.g. "Black Lives Matter (BLM) […] campaigns against violence and systemic racism towards black people." From [1]; emphasis mine. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter
- alfromspace 7y agoStatistical disparities aren't evidence of racism. And let's not pretend we haven't been talking about a supposed epidemic of white cops shooting innocent black people for no reason for years and years now.
- colanderman 7y agoI don't understand the point of this comment. It does not bolster your comment I replied to, nor does it argue against my own. Are you starting a new, different argument, and now claiming that systemic racism doesn't exist, and that large bodies of research about it are unfounded, and supporting your claim with a single pithy statement about statistics? If so, sorry, I don't feel like being dragged into an off-topic argument about whether the concept of systemic racism is valid.
- alfromspace 7y agoAbsolutely I am. The "bodies of research" about it do little more than point out things like prison population statistics and sentencing disparities that have almost nothing to do with racism, and everything to do with crime rates and priors. I equally don't feel like being dragged into pseudo-scientific political formulations that cast unequal distributions of resources and outcomes in life as forms of systemic discrimination.