4 ms·
So it turns out that being in favor of allowing multiple points of view to coexist puts you in conflict with people who only want to allow one point of view to
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
So it turns out that being in favor of allowing multiple points of view to coexist puts you in conflict with people who only want to allow one point of view to be heard. That's... rather unsurprising.
It is my perception that the left is doing better at shutting down opposing speech than the right, and has been since the 90s. If you're going to address the problem that it's happening at all, you have to address the side that's doing it more and better.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BryantD 7y agoSo how do you personally test that perception?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWith statistical validity? To p = 0.05? I don't. But picking one form of "silencing" (people whose invitations to speak on university campuses were withdrawn, blocked, or cancelled due to threats of violence), and measuring it by how much I read about it in the press, it appears that the right is blocked more than the left. And the press is not currently disposed present things in a way that makes the right look more sympathetic.
- neaden 7y agoHonest question, do you think liberal speakers are getting invited to places like Liberty University in the first place?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoProbably not. Honest question back: Why do you think Liberty University is the yardstick, rather than public universities?
- neaden 7y agoBecause the dis-invitations that get press happen at very liberal universities, either private or well known public liberal universities like Berkely. Academia as a whole leans left, so this is unsurprising. I'm unaware of any right leaning public universities to name check but I assume they exist in some areas.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI also am unaware of any right leaning public universities to check. But that kind of makes my point. The left controls the public universities in a way that the right doesn't, and uses them (in at least some cases) to block speech by the right. The right may be just as willing to block speech as the left, but they don't have the opportunity to do so right now. Ergo, if you want to address the problem, right now you need to address the left. I hold public universities to a higher standard than private ones in this regard. It's more acceptable in my view for a private university to have a bias (either left or right), and to enforce it, than it is for a public university.
- komali2 7y ago> The left controls the public universities But, this is prejudice - there is no authority structure in "the left," it's a totally amorphous set of political / ethical ideals that's honestly terribly defined. So there's two issues I take with this statement: 1. What is "the left?" Can we actually draw a border around it in a way that lets us make the statement, "the left controls the public universities?" I'll hazard that you'll find, within public university administrations, people pro- and anti-choice, people pro- and anti- gun control, supporters of total Israeli sovereignty alongside protesters of Israeli's government, fiscal conservatives alongside socialists... I'm not trying to dispute that public university staff "lean left," but I just don't agree that there's some secret cabal of "leftists" who all agree with eachother. 2. Left-leaning staff are not card-carrying members of an organization (I mean, outside the Democrat party or something) that directs their actions. The definition "the left" arises from a shared set of political beliefs, not the other way around, like a political party. I.e., the democrat party (kinda) represents a certain set of ethics, and you join it if your ethics are aligned. But "the left" is not something you join, it is a description of the majority amalgamation of your beliefs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- neaden 7y agoDo you think all view points should be heard? Should Jewish and gay students have to debate Nazi's about whether or not they should be murdered? Should black and women students have to debate if they should count as property?
- ralfd 7y agoThat insinuates Nazis or Slavers are in a position of power. The hierarchy is switched though: Nazis have to debate students how hard they can be punched.
- dashundchen 7y agoThis doesn't make any sense. Where do students hold a position of real power, especially a position where they are inflicting violence on Nazis? Where is this debate happening?
- Fins 7y agoIf we look at all the college administrations that quickly crumble after students protest that they might have to pass past a building in which, had they gone inside, they could have heard something they would not like, this dismissal rings quite hollow. And once we look at riots in Berkeley, the guy who went a-shooting congressmen, or fine folks who had beaten up a gay POC journalist (a Quillette journalist, but still), well, not all of them are students, but they are doing just fine inflicting violence on whoever they designate as "Nazis", or "Fascists" or whatever the scare word is today.
- dashundchen 7y agoOK, one instance of students (who were clashing with far-right protesters who were armed) and the rest which aren't students, so a complete non-sequitor. In that case I bring out all the right wing terrorists of the past decade. Christchurch shooter, Charleston church shooter, Charlottesville car attacker, Bundy ranch hostages, pro-Trump agitators in the Berkley protest you list, Pittsburgh synagogue shooting, Colorado planned parenthood shooting, Layfayette trainwreck shooting, Norwegian Brevik mass shooting, Comet Pizza and many Q-Anon related murders, it goes on and on. It appears the right wing is increasingly violent and radical, which has many people worried. Fascism starts with violence, anyone who recognizes the threat posed by right-wing terrorism understandably would want to stop it before it goes further. The world has seen where that ideology has taken us before, unfortunately it seems to be fading from collective memory.
- tdb7893 7y agoNot all speech is useful speech and some speech should be shut down depending on the context. On Discord I've had people complain about me trying to stop people calling other people "fags" or "retards" and I have been called a SJW for stopping people just saying lies about trans people (which they always try to defend as if it's some sort of legitimate political opinion). Edit: It's generally kids saying these things and I get it that they often just don't know better but it's really night and day how much better things are if there are some boundaries.
- komali2 7y agoThis is a big part of the discussion, I think, based on conversations with my conservative friends. They often complain about how they "can't say" certain words anymore. They'll make comments about how people are "too soft" these days. "Who feels pain from a word?" In your discord, they'd be the ones throwing around such words with reckless abandon. I can sympathize, because I've yet to find a word that causes me pain by any stretch of the word "pain." There's no phrase, sentence, or utterance that has bothered me. I've been called all manner of racial epithets, gender epithets, and even sexual orientation epithets. I just can't bring myself to give a shit - nobody trying to hurt me is worth my time and so I ignore them / move on / mock them / laugh in their face. I genuinely cannot put myself in the shoes of people who, for example, would feel a form of pain/offense at hearing the "n" word, for example. From my perspective, that would be just a great indication that whoever is using that word is not worth a millisecond of my time. HOWEVER, I'm a straight white male that makes 140,000$/year and have no diseases whatsoever. So when my black friends tell me that certain words cause them pain, I believe them, because everyone's different. I feel fear on rollercoasters to the point where I simply will not ride them. Some friends love rollercoasters. Objectively, I should not feel fear on rollercoasters. They are safer than hopping on my motorcycle for my 10 minute, 2 mile commute home. But, I do. So, I can take that experience and say "situations exist where I feel different emotions than other people do, for said situation." While I can't imagine what it feels like to hear a word and feel pain / offense, I can believe people when they tell me that a certain word makes them feel those negative emotions. I'm not sure how to convince other friends that it's worth the effort to apply this baseline level of mutual respect. I wish I knew why I'm willing to respect others' feelings around words so I could share this learning. I guess, to me, it's logical? If someone wants to be referred to as male despite "appearing" female, don't throw a fucking hissy fit, just do it, who gives a shit? If people are saying "it's not cool to call people retards anymore," just... don't... do it... what are you actually losing? The ability to be an asshole to people in a certain specific way?