9 ms·
There was a reply here, now dead, that I wanted to discuss: "Hey man, I'm just trying to feed my family. I have kids so that means I can behave however I want
by wpietri 7y ago
There was a reply here, now dead, that I wanted to discuss:
"Hey man, I'm just trying to feed my family. I have kids so that means I can behave however I want so long as it benefits my kids. And rather than trust some reviews on a platform anyone can sign up for, how about you do some reading on the app developer and their ToS and Privacy Policy."
I'm adamantly opposed to spam, and back in the early days of the web (say, 1996 or so) I'd call up spammers and politely ask them to stop. Quite a number of people were just confused or oblivious; they would often take my suggestions to heart. But a lot of them were in some sort of scarcity panic like this guy is. They had bills to pay, mouths to feed! If what they did harmed other people, well, they weren't going to think too hard about that.
One of the real tragedies of this is how circular it is, how self-sustaining. Why is this person so desperate? Often it's because a) other desperate people are doing shitty things to them, or b) entirely non-desperate people have rigged things so that there are enough desperate people harnessed to make sure those on top get and stay rich.
We can divide all economic activity into value creation and wealth extraction. Things like click farming do extract wealth, but they increase systemic waste, meaning less value can be produced. That in turn increases the amount of desperation, making people more likely to join them in doing something exploitative just to survive.
It all seems so pathological. I wish we were better at breaking these cycles.
- marak830 7y agoJust before my son was born, I was struggling to find a stable job. So I worked on online web dev jobs for some seriously shady characters. I made between 10 and 15 sites that they would buy databases and mass mail users in various industries to try and get them to sign up for really shitty programs. (One for example was a roofing company promising 100's of clients). The amount of work I did on the back end to track everything about the users, fingerprint them and send a report about where in the multipage process they were up to and what they had filled in (but not submitted!) was crazy. My point being, I hated every single moment of that. But I needed to get money for my family. If I had it had a good offer that required spamming forums and bypassing bot catchers, I would have done that too. Sometimes you are in a position where you have to weigh your family's needs vs the general good. One last point, or reiteration. I hated every. Single. Moment. And I am ashamed that I was in that position by my own fault (not picking a more secure job). I won't blame anyone else for it and I agree I did a bad thing. But if I was in that situtation again, I would do it again.
- trevyn 7y agoI'm curious, how deeply did you investigate social services (food banks, shelters, etc.) available in your area? This is not an accusation — I don't claim to know your individual situation. Yet I suspect that in many cases where people say "I'm doing this to feed my family", there is actually a larger component of preserving pride and reluctance to ask for help. The irony is that this is part of what dehumanizes the system and perpetuates the cycle.
- distant_hat 7y agoIf you are not in the first world, those services are nonexistent.
- marak830 7y agoI'm in a country where I'm not a citizen due to my wife's country of birth. I would have had to leave her pregnant here to return to my country of birth.
- belorn 7y agoIt is understandable to be willing to do anything for ones family. I also think it is equally understandable if society put people in jail who do cross the line. If you had ended up being charged for spamming, hacking into bot catchers, breaking data protection laws (like GDPR if you live in EU), would you accept that as a acceptable consequence and still have done it to get money for the family? Or would you think that is unfair? This crossroad is for me the line where social support networks should exist. If people find crime to be the only solution in a situation and the legal repercussions to be a fair trade then it is cheaper and more humane to fix the original situation. Your wife's country of birth should support her while she is unable to work because of the pregnancy, and the child should be supported similarly as long they are a child.
- marak830 7y ago"If you had ended up being charged for spamming, hacking into bot catchers". I would have setup a way not to be caught. It would be criminal, (this was pre-gdpr it definitely would be now), but I would have done it still. She was supported to an extent, but we knew once she had our son, we wouldn't be able to keep up with necessities. We needed to start buying things then and there.
- kindawindar 7y agoThe 3rd verse in this song articulates your perception of what a spammer is: http://ytcracker.com/music/spamtec%20-%20what%20is%20spam.mp3 http://ytcracker.com/music/spamtec%20-%20what%20is%20spam.mp...
- AFascistWorld 7y agoThen you haven't heard of the scammer logic: I made money coz I'm capable/I made it by my ability, you have an issue with it/are jealous? Go make your own then. It doesn't matter how, it matters whether you made it.
- nradov 7y agoMost of those people are just lying about their circumstances to elicit sympathy. They're no different than any other con artist.
- kingkawn 7y agoMost people are suffering needlessly and asking for help. What comes if we critique the artfulness of their ask and do not help?
- abraae 7y agoWhat comes if we help those who ask (artfully or not) rather than those most in need?
- chaosite 7y agoHow do we find out who is most in need, by subjecting them to invasive tests and forcing them to jump through increasingly complicated hoops just to prove they are truly in need?
- everybodyknows 7y agoBy looking around us -- making the effort to understand the lives of ordinary acquaintances. People worse off than ourselves are never hard to find.
- firethief 7y agoLying about having bills to pay?
- dmix 7y agoYou had me until the part you suggested there was some subset of the upper class conspiring to keep an underclass of poor people... in order to make/keep themselves rich?Wouldn't rich people get much richer if there was more economically healthy middle class people buying their products and real estate or w/e they are making money off of? What could they possibly gain from ruining the economy and keeping others poor. This seems to be based on a very poor understanding of how economics works, or the idea that there are secret nation-wide power systems plotting evil things like a rich villain in a Disney movie.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe extremely rich do in fact conspire to keep wages low and economic security precarious, for both political and economic reasons. There's plenty of historical evidence for this. For example: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2007/aug/28/comment.businesscomment https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2007/aug/28/commen... The counterargument is that the massive increases in wealth inequality since the 50s - a time when the average single wage earner could afford a relatively secure lifestyle - "just happened", which is obviously rather implausible.
- arethuza 7y ago"There's class warfare, all right, but it's my class, the rich class, that's making war, and we're winning." Warren Buffet
- 1PlayerOne 7y agomake total sense, I mean who has the time and money to organize for a class war. What is surprising is that a lot of the stupid poor are fighting on side of the rich people who are keeping them poor. Sad!
- tomp 7y ago> The counterargument is that the massive increases in wealth inequality since the 50s - a time when the average single wage earner could afford a relatively secure lifestyle - "just happened", which is obviously rather implausible. It's not that implausible. It's the effect of technology - not just automation / computers (only since 90s or something) but also before, we had information technology - ever since the telegraph was invented. In simple terms, it enables ever-increasing scale of human cooperation, bigger countries, bigger companies etc. so the "winners" (smartest, most experienced, most educated, most corrupt, most sociopathic, most networked, or simply those with a better starting point) win ever more, at a bigger scale.
- drevil-v2 7y agoI could not disagree with you more. You have extrapolated a lack of morality in well off human beings in such black and white totality. What a fking trite and naive generalization you have made. There are bad shitty people and bad intentions across all populations. Rich or poor. Men or Women. Old or Young.
- wpietri 7y agoI'm definitely not suggesting something black and white. Maybe don't take a short paragraph as indicative of my entire thought on a topic. I agree that there are bad people everywhere. But practicing many kinds of badness requires power over others. So it's entirely unsurprising that people who like those kinds of badness will disproportionately seek power. And I'm hardly the first to observe this. As Douglas Adams wrote: "It is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it..."
- nitwit005 7y agoIf you can afford buying a thousand used iPhones to start such a business, you aren't exactly living in poverty. Spam operations back in the day probably cost even more given what hardware and bandwidth used to cost. Even if they weren't trying to BS you, people committing crimes often come up with some sort of story to justify the whole thing. People like to be the hero of their story.
- onion2k 7y agoIf you can afford buying a thousand used iPhones to start such a business, you aren't exactly living in poverty. Or you start small and grow. Or you borrow money to start. Or you find an angel investor who is rich. Etc. Kind of like any other start up really.
- nitwit005 7y agoThere's a minimum scale below which no one would bother to hire you. No one is going to hire someone with 4 phones set up. If you can get business loans and financing, that's just another version of not exactlty being poor.
- pharke 7y agoThere are grey and black market equivalents of those that someone on this end of the scale is more likely to use. No one's walking into a bank to ask for a loan to start a click farm.
- Hitton 7y agoThere is no minimum scale, because those who start are working for companies which organize it. Try searching on youtube: beermoney phone farm They run 3rd party apps on their phones which automate whole process and they get some percent of profit. I imagine that when they grow they can start working for themselves.
- puranjay 7y agoI'm a marketer and spam is a massive problem in the internet marketing space. The people who are good at spam - the folks topping Google search results for lucrative phrases or spamming social media on an industrial scale - all tend to have a lot of money. A business built on spam (or illegal tactics) is, by nature, unstable. You're one bust away from losing all your income. So the people who enter this space either tend to have so much money that they don't mind losing an income source. Or they have so little money that they spam in desperation
- VvR-Ox 7y agoTLDR; This is how our system works Good analysis - it's all just about money (which means existence). Too bad many people don't want to see that and still believe in "the american dream" and other fairy tales so they can keep up serving for these few parasites until they die. That's why I totally understand a lot of criminals (doing stuff that doesn't really harm others like shoplifting or selling drugs that aren't killing people) - they just try to survive.
- wruza 7y ago“I wish we were better at breaking these cycles.” It could be better if... Or maybe that is the way we are, those who extract, those who survive, and those who complain about living in a first-world experiencing a little inconvenience in apple app store. Or maybe free creation of value is unlocked only after enough wealth is extracted by some big group somewhere else and injected into the market. If these cycles exist, to break them “we” need to open much better possibilities than subj for everyone. But borders are closed, and when one opens them, they hear yet another complaint.
- cageface 7y agoParasites show up in just about every complex ecosystem. Often they eventually establish some kind of symbiosis with their host. Life is chaotic and messy and that is often hard thing for us to accept. Ecosystems that endure find a way to balance these competing forces.
- wpietri 7y agoThat can be a useful analogy, but it's important to realize that this is only metaphorically an ecosystem. Human society is created by conscious agents with specific intent. It's a designed system. Talking about parasites can explain what is happening, and point us in the direction of solutions. But is must never be used to justify.
- cageface 7y agoThere will always be people willing to break the rules. As much as we’d like to design systems around more optimistic expectations of human behavior reality is always more complex. It’s pragmatism, not justification.
- wpietri 7y agoI'm saying the opposite of "we’d like to design systems around more optimistic expectations". Given that people are what they are, I want us to get better at breaking these cycles. But very often, statements like "there will always be people willing to break the rules" are used to act as if things like the number of people willing to break the rules and the amount of harm done when rules are broken are beyond our control.
- cageface 7y agoWhat mechanisms would you propose to control bad faith actors?
- la_barba 7y agoWhy are the powerless people the parasites? Google (and also others) is not a morally neutral entity here. They created this problem. They could stem the flow of malvertising or click-farming or spamming by hiring more and more review staff as their company has scaled, but its simply not in their DNA. I mean literally they are the richest of the richest of companies in the richest country and their owners are amongst the richest people on earth.. and the tired out cliche is still "it doesn't scale". Yeah..I'm pretty sure you can hire a few more folks to your team.. :-)
- skunkpocalypse 7y ago> I have kids so that means I can behave however I want so long as it benefits my kids. This is so full of awesome I am at a loss for words to describe it.
- trilila 7y agoI live in a certain east European country, where the excuse for petty and serious crime is always: "Hey man, I'm just trying to feed my family.". People doing this, and those tolerating it, don't realise that this type of behaviour leads to a bad reputation for that country, and in turn to loss of business. Believing that poverty is a valid justification for continuous shady / criminal work is a fallacy. Specifically, in the same country, fake reviews are a real issue. I ended up in way too many shady restaurants and dealt with way too many dodgy businesses with 5 star reviews thanks to click / review farms to know that this type of business is actually criminal. I am now at a stage where I simply don't trust reviews anymore.
- rightbyte 7y agoIf you speak a small language reviews might still be valuable for everything but restaurants. I have not noticed any systematic spam reviews in neither swedish nor danish. The problem with restaurants, being an overall shady business, is probably that way too many customers are too easy to please or hard to please, so the reviews doesn't say much.
- noragami 7y agoI don't speak any languages with less than a couple hundred million speakers, so I find salvation in some of the smaller, more niche communities, preferably with invite-only registration process, or simply less well known. Increasing popularity never made anything better.
- Merrill 7y agoIt's the Game of Life. People play it according to whatever rules and penalties they perceive to be in place using whatever strategies and tactics they think will succeed.
- rightbyte 7y agoAnd they have the wrong tactic and strategy? That they do it becouse they think it benefits them is obvoius. These schemes to make money without doing ordinary boring dull work are ofent a waste of time if you compare your hourly wage to whatever you would get carrying bags of seed up the hill to the sawmill. A programmer that is competent enough to write spamscripts is competent enough to work as a programmer.
- sgift 7y ago> A programmer that is competent enough to write spamscripts is competent enough to work as a programmer. Only if competence were the only measure you'd need to get a job. In reality, there are various other factors like: Where one lives, how good one is at interviewing and so on.
- wpietri 7y agoSure, I'm not really faulting the individuals here. But we collectively set the rules for the game of life. Maybe we should pick ones with better outcomes for both individuals and society as a whole.
- dillonmckay 7y agoWell, how would you classify streaming audio or video services of pre-recorded content? That is quite wasteful and only exists to solve a legal, not technological problem.
- mpalmer 7y ago> Moloch is introduced as the answer to a question [...] - what does it? Earth could be fair, and all men glad and wise. Instead we have prisons, smokestacks, asylums. What sphinx of cement and aluminum breaks open their skulls and eats up their imagination? > And Ginsberg answers: Moloch does it. > There’s a passage in the Principia Discordia where Malaclypse complains to the Goddess about the evils of human society. “Everyone is hurting each other, the planet is rampant with injustices, whole societies plunder groups of their own people, mothers imprison sons, children perish while brothers war.” > The Goddess answers: “What is the matter with that, if it’s what you want to do?” > Malaclypse: “But nobody wants it! Everybody hates it!” > Goddess: “Oh. Well, then stop.” > The implicit question is – if everyone hates the current system, who perpetuates it? And Ginsberg answers: “Moloch”. It’s powerful not because it’s correct – nobody literally thinks an ancient Carthaginian demon causes everything – but because thinking of the system as an agent throws into relief the degree to which the system isn’t an agent. From the slatestarcodex classic: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
- lazyjones 7y ago> Things like click farming do extract wealth, but they increase systemic waste, meaning less value can be produced. That in turn increases the amount of desperation, making people more likely to join them in doing something exploitative just to survive. Perhaps these click farms are just an evolving reaction to the PITA that is online advertising. It's the advertising industry that gets harmed by it and not some other poor people and it should eventually lead to more transparency for their customers, who would like to compare their traffic with what the adtech provider logged and isolate the fraudulent clicks.
- close04 7y agoPeople (advertisers) are surprised that the internet is beginning (continuing?) to be reshaped around their business and a whole ecosystem emerged to take advantage of this, no matter how unfairly.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoAdvertisers pass their costs onto their customers. Everyone is hurt by fraud.
- lazyjones 7y ago> Everyone is hurt by fraud. No, the users aren't. The advertisers are, they evaluate the performance of their advertising and find it less worthwhile as fraud increases.
- 1asterisk 7y agoI can remember asking my mail delivery person if they could stop delivering all the junk mail as it was truly unwanted. They looked at me like I had lost my mind and told me that was what paid their salary. I asked if they could return the junk mail to the sender they said not possible. You'd think they would gladly send it back because it paid their salary twice in that instance!
- rb808 7y agoI like the article of the Swedish lady who went to Nigeria to help her 419 scammer. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-37632259 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-37632259
- la_barba 7y agoTo your (b) - Its nerds like us that enable those companies. To blame the "companies" also means to blame the individuals who work at those companies. Its easy to blame Google, but we celebrate their engineers at tech conferences when they talk about technically challenging stuff. Sure, thats cool, but then they go back from the conference and check in some code to mine someones inbox or track their online activity. The buck stops everywhere on the way to the top. Like.. these are the richest of the richest companies in the richest country by far whose owners are also amongst the richest people on earth, and they won't hire people to do real reviews or checks of inventory or speak to customers or review advertising campaigns for shady or misleading ads, and tons of other things that people complain about. "It doesn't scale" == "I'll take the hit when someone eventually games the system".
- dang 7y ago> There was a reply here, now dead, that I wanted to discuss If there's a comment that's [dead] that shouldn't be, you should vouch for it by clicking on its timestamp and then clicking 'vouch' at the top of its page. When enough users vouch for a comment, it is restored to visibility. That's why the comment you're talking about is now visible (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20495142 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20495142), albeit also downvoted.
- wpietri 7y agoNoted, thanks! I thought maybe it was dead for some other reason, but in the future I'll just try to resurrect it.
- dang 7y agoUsers have more power to do that than they think they do! It's really a feature for community moderation, and probably the single most salutary thing we've added to the site in the last five years.