5 ms·
Renters may get access to rogue landlord database
- hirundo 7y agoHow about making it symmetrical and also give landlords access to a rogue renter database?
- nerdponx 7y agoAs far as I know, in some cities they do already keep a tenant blacklist.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 7y agoIn the USA they essentially already have this in the form of forcing prospective tenants to submit to a background check and being able to pull rental/eviction history. I would think that this is just correcting the information/power imbalance.
- mancerayder 7y agoThey recently (June) made this illegal in NYC. Whether it's enforced is a different matter. Problem is with the laws generally favoring tenants here, there are litigious bad apples and no one wants a tenant who can game the system and get 6-12 months of free lodging because they know how. After 30 days, you have squatter rights which means the court system needs to evict you if you're naughty, and that can take a long time. On the flip side, if you as a tenant ended up in housing court and won (i.e. it wasn't your fault), you were in that database.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 7y agoInteresting, although I will note for other readers that NYC and other large left-leaning cities are exceptions rather than the norm regarding tenant protections. Texas, where I live, for example, has much more landlord-friendly laws.
- danso 7y agoRenters are routinely backgrounded as a part of the process. FTA: > "Renters have to provide references from employers and previous landlords before a landlord hands over the keys to a new flat. So it is only fair that renters get the opportunity to check that a prospective landlord doesn't have a criminal record," said Dan Wilson Craw, director of Generation Rent, which campaigns on behalf of tenants.
- tompccs 7y agoLeaving aside the fact that rental markets already have a highly asymmetric power dynamic, landlords in the UK already do have a de-facto mechanism for assessing tenants in the form of landlord references. They can also perform various financial checks, such as employer references, or asking for a guarantor. On the other hand, I rent in London and do not even know the name of our landlord. He/she operates through various limited companies and an agent. I can infer it through Companies House but that option wouldn't have been available before we put down our holding deposit.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Leaving aside the fact that rental markets already have a highly asymmetric power dynamic, landlords in the UK already do have a de-facto mechanism for assessing tenants in the form of landlord references. They can also perform various financial checks, such as employer references, or asking for a guarantor. These are just things they ask for though - there's no special legal power they have to ask for them - you could also ask for the same things from your prospective landlord if you wanted to, and you'd have the same information. They'd probably decline to provide them and refuse to rent to you, in the same way as you can decline to provide them and refuse to rent from them.
- jogjayr 7y ago> They'd probably decline to provide them, in the same way as you can decline to provide them. The consequences of declining are very different for both parties. The landlord moves on to literally any other prospect because everyone else will provide that information. The tenant can move on to only slumlords, who will not insist on a credit/criminal background/reference check. Or they can be homeless.
- mlurp 7y agoI think that's really more a function of what slant the market is currently in, ie, renter's or landlord's market. If there were a glut of apartments compared to renters, the desperateness would be reversed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jogjayr 7y agoCredit checks, criminal background check, employment history check, previous landlord reference are standard parts of a rental application. My landlord has tons of visibility into my finances and history with previous landlords. I know nothing about their books and only online reviews to tell me about their dealings with previous tenants.
- morrbo 7y agoYou kind of get this already to be fair. Doing a credit check or lookup of any CCJs etc on potentisl tenants is standard procedure. It doesn't tell you if they're loud or will damage the property, but neither would this I guess.
- ajross 7y agoI don't know UK law, but eviction history is a public record in almost all of the US. Likewise the credit checks that are nearly universally required are a proxy for this sort of thing too. Basically: landlords already have this, in redundancy even. They aren't the aggrieved party here.
- everybodyknows 7y agoHere in California, counties maintain publicly accessible property records, indexed by street address. Corporate owners must register with the state, and the various state enforcement agencies present records indexed by name of violator on their own websites. Working through all the above steps manually is of course impractical for most renters. There may be a startup opportunity here -- a "badpads.com".
- lleolin 7y agoIsn't that just when they run my credit and check for past evictions. How much of a rogue renter can one be, and get away with it?
- glenda 7y agoLandlords will often perform a credit/background check on potential renters, so it seems like this exists to fix an existing information asymmetry.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vkou 7y agoThe rogue renter database already exists, it's called a credit check, and a list of landlord references for your last three addresses, that you include in your application.
- danso 7y agoNYC has a few resources on checking out bad landlords: The public advocate puts out an annual list of the 100 worst landlords: https://landlordwatchlist.com/ https://landlordwatchlist.com/ There's also various sites that attempt to connect property ownership data with other city databases, such as inspection violations: https://whoownswhat.justfix.nyc https://whoownswhat.justfix.nyc
- dbattaglia 7y agoMy wife and I had an apartment in Brooklyn a few years ago that we broke the lease after two months. It was a total horror show, complete w/ bedbugs and broken everything. Glad to see that landlord on the landlordwatch.com private landlords list, thanks for posting.
- nextos 7y agoThat's great. The UK really needs some regulations against scammy landlords and agents. The market is a total Wild West now. During the last 5 years, I have rented many different properties in the Oxbridge area. All brand new houses (I really was the first person living there), from well-known estate agents and with high rental prices. In all cases except one, I have ended up really dissatisfied. Most properties never attempted to renew my contract after 6/12 months, or asked for an unreasonable rental increase in order to actually kick me out. I suspect this was done to put the property back into the market and generate more fees for the agent. Often, the property would be vacant for a month or two after I left, which makes even less sense. Twice, my deposit has not been returned and no explanation has been provided. Naturally, I took both cases to the Ombudsman and won. But it is a huge waste of time. Twice, I had massive floods due to piping issues but received no compensation despite their promises and legal obligation to do so. I have rented many other properties abroad, including US & Scandinavia. And never had an issue. Here, it is crazy bad. And as a tenant you can't do much, because you need references in order to rent the next flat.
- smartscience 7y ago> Most properties never attempted to renew my contract Martin & Co by any chance? They tried this, but they must have forgotten that the property was an annex next to the landlady's main house, and we spoke every day. The estate agent served me an eviction notice, so I just signed a new rolling contract with the landlady directly. Other evidence of their genius comes from the fact I specifically told them I was wanting to rent a place for my new job in the area, and them then writing to my old employer in Manchester to confirm my future income.
- dlphn___xyz 7y agohopefully this trend will carry over into employment too - run a background check on a prospective employer before you decide to do business with them
- IshKebab 7y agoThere's already Glassdoor (although it has become quite spammy - like LinkedIn before Microsoft bought it).
- simple_phrases 7y agoGlassdoor, Yelp etc are all games by reputation management companies and HR departments. It's also in the best interest of Glassdoor and Yelp to allow businesses to remove unsatisfactory reviews, which Yelp already does.
- mancerayder 7y agoDo you have evidence? I've written a number of unsatisfactory reviews on Yelp and they seem like they're still there.
- hartator 7y agoThey play on the positions: https://thenextweb.com/insider/2009/02/20/yelp-remove-bad-reviewsfor-price/ https://thenextweb.com/insider/2009/02/20/yelp-remove-bad-re...
- mancerayder 7y ago2009?
- pkaye 7y agoI know of some HR people who faked some reviews on Glassdoor. They were mostly trying to remedy lack of reviews or counteract a few bad reviews. Both said they would remove the fake reviews when the situation improved by itself.
- povertyworld 7y agoThe reason this is not going to be useful is that every story I've read or personal anecdote I've been told about landlords involves the person's building being sold to a new owner. Usually the rogue landlord buys a rent controlled building that is barely worth owning so the current owner wants out, and the rogue landlord then proceeds to make the place as unlivable as possible for the current tenants in order to convert the units to market rate when they move out. I don't think many landlords are trying to trick people to move into their buildings just to harass them and throw them out.
- IshKebab 7y agoThis is England. Rent control isn't a thing.
- povertyworld 7y agoInteresting. So why isn't an activist outfit like Generation Rent (the group pushing for this law) working on getting rent control? In the US everyone on the left takes it as a given that rent control is a good thing.
- danso 7y agoWhy aren't you able to first Google whether they are or not, rather than automatically assume they aren't because an article about something different doesn't mention their entire political advocacy work? https://www.generationrent.org/sadiq_khan_publishes_vision_for_london_s_rental_market https://www.generationrent.org/sadiq_khan_publishes_vision_f...
- eertami 7y agoFew reasons, mostly because home ownership is fetishised in the UK to an absurdity and doing so could quite possibly curb property values. Previous conservative governments bribed practically an entire social class by giving away social housing at way below market value. There is a massive amount of people in that generation who are wealthy simply because of that policy combined with large rise in house prices. This selection of people + regular homeowners no matter the party line, will always vote against any policy that a) has the possibility to curb increasing house prices or b) fairly taxing those profits. We don't have anything like property taxes in the UK, and the closest thing we do have is council tax which (laughably) is the tenants responsibility. It's a situation that no party has a realistic chance of being able to solve. Even if there were MPs brave enough, it's a difficult problem to navigate because there's millions of people with 0 savings (retirement or otherwise) but now own 500,000gbp+ houses. If you tax that appreciation in value or your policies reduce these prices to sustainable levels then you suddenly have to now provide social security for millions of people who now will need a lot of extra assistance via state pension.
- flowersjeff 7y agoWhy exactly is this story on HN? Read the article, and was like - so?... I guess there's a DB mentioned, although containing 10 entries sounds like a joke. So trying to find the "tech" angle and all.
- Fargren 7y agoI recommend that you read the site guidelines at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Specifically "On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity." and "Please don't complain that a submission is inappropriate. If a story is spam or off-topic, flag it." In general, if a story is in the front page it means that hackers found it interesting, so it can hardly be off-topic. But if you still think it's inappropriate for this forum, flag it rather than commenting. I can speculate that this story is found interesting because many people in tech live in areas like San Francisco where rent prices are a hot topic. Therefore stories about how these kinds of places deal with the problem are relevant.
- dubliner2077 7y agoAnd yet still, be unable to do anything about it. Because there is less limited supply.
- hdhdhd 7y agoGod bless the UK civil servicr and their retarded c# agile programmers, I'd love to know how much this stupid project cost
- TomMckenny 7y agoLandlords already have access to a database compiled from court records of tenants who have ever sued a landlord whether they won or not. At least in the US
- TomMckenny 7y agoPost seems unpopular for some reason so here's some proof: https://www.povertylaw.org/clearinghouse/article/blacklisting https://www.povertylaw.org/clearinghouse/article/blacklistin... https://www.brickunderground.com/blog/2014/05/tenant_blacklist https://www.brickunderground.com/blog/2014/05/tenant_blackli... https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/14/new-law-protects-california-tenants-from-blacklists/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/14/new-law-protects-cali... https://www.apartmentguide.com/blog/do-property-managers-blacklist-bad-tenants/ https://www.apartmentguide.com/blog/do-property-managers-bla...
- Silhouette 7y agoIt would be nice if they could incorporate some indication of respect for deposits as well. From personal experience, the current deposit protection schemes might be legally regulated and they aren't quite as unhelpful and sometimes shady as the private car parking enforcement firms, but they seem to be cut from the same cloth.