7 ms·
Before I worked in healthcare, it all seemed so easy. The doctors were the good guys, and the insurance and drug companies were the bad guys. Now I see it dif
by reaperducer 7y ago
Before I worked in healthcare, it all seemed so easy. The doctors were the good guys, and the insurance and drug companies were the bad guys. Now I see it differently.
Healthcare companies are massive bureaucracies because there are people at every end trying to scam them. All that redundant paperwork is for a reason.
You wouldn't believe some of the things that people try to get away with. Plastic surgeons billing tummy tucks as emergency C-sections. People pretending they were the hospital so they can get the insurance company to reimburse them for the IV "hangover cures" they got every morning while partying in Vegas. People walking into office buildings and play-collapsing in the lobby so they can get an ambulance ride to the hospital across town, then once they arrive they run out of the hospital and down the street because all they were really looking for is a free ride. People who have six or seven dependent children from multiple partners on their insurance, then yell at us because the partner they're living with didn't know about all those other children from all those other spouses until they opened some piece of mail from us.
I'm not saying that insurance companies are all good. IME, most are not. But if people were just honest and decent, a large part of the healthcare system dysfunction wouldn't exist.
- gruez 7y ago>Healthcare companies are massive bureaucracies because there are people at every end trying to scam them. All that redundant paperwork is for a reason. And what about other countries with way lower healthcare expenditures (by % of GDP)? Are people scamming the healthcare system an American problem?
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Are people scamming the healthcare system an American problem? Definitely not. In Poland we have public healthcare, and the stories I hear from my doctor acquaintance still reveal ridiculous levels of fraud, mostly the usual scams against large bureaucracies. Public healthcare may be more efficient, but is still full of bureaucratic scars.
- Retric 7y agoOne of the major savings is single payers have more data on each provider. This means they can randomly audit a lower percentage of cases and become just as likely to spot fraud.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoNot necessarily, the amount of data that is collected in France vs the US for example is much much lower.
- yardie 7y agoMaybe, maybe not. In France all my information is in EMR in my Carte Vitale. The US I have to fill in a paper questionnaire every fucking time. They may have more data, most likely it's redundant.
- com2kid 7y agoIn the US, link to survey is sent by text, or through automated voice prompt.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- saint_fiasco 7y agoFeedback loop. The more expensive healthcare gets, the more money you can get by scamming insurance companies, which in turn increases costs even more.
- rb808 7y agoNHS and other nationalized healthcare providers, doctors and nurses working in hospitals get salaries, so they could scam some overtime but that's about it. I think local primary physicians get paid per visit, but most are way overworked anyway so kinda hard to fake extra visits.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoI suspect the extensive part privatization might be opening new and exciting opportunities for scammers..
- DanBC 7y agoThere's still fraud in the NHS. People who suspect fraud can report it to the NHS Counter Fraud authority. They have a fraud awareness toolkit here: https://cfa.nhs.uk/fraud-prevention/fraud-awareness-toolkit https://cfa.nhs.uk/fraud-prevention/fraud-awareness-toolkit
- todipa 7y agoI have an anecdote: I had a small fat cyst near my eyelid and the doctor removed in less than 45 seconds. I later got the bill for multiple cyst removals in both eyes, granted it was only $75, it still was wrong. I contacted the office and said that this is simply not true and if they don't remove this from the bill, I would contact the insurance company. They argued with me saying that they had in fact removed many of them in both eyes. If you look at it from the Doctor's POV, he is lying because there is a low risk of getting caught. The penalty for getting caught is probably not high enough.
- elliekelly 7y agoThis happened to me as well but with a dentist. When I first moved to Boston I had never had any cavities but my new dentist kept remarking about how great my dental insurance was - I was in the insurance sweet spot of under 26 so I was covered by my mom's policy as primary and had secondary coverage through my dad's policy and my school's policy. Well wouldn't you know, I averaged two cavities a year during law school even though my brushing & flossing habits were unchanged. When I finally graduated and switched to a dentist closer to my office I insisted to my new dentist that I had had six cavities filled and he insisted that I most definitely hadn't. There wasn't a single filling to be seen on my x-rays. Dentist #1 had been scheduling me to have a cavity drilled after every regular visit. Apparently he was just giving me a shot of lidocaine and pretending to drill in my mouth for an hour so he could bill my "great" insurance.
- sjg007 7y agoYou should report your previous dentist. I’ve found dentists that are trying to make money start pushing deep cleaning despite never needing it ever.
- elliekelly 7y agoI did actually but I never heard anything back, though the dentist retired about a year later. I always wondered if it was related to my complaint or just a coincidence.
- komali2 7y ago> But if people were just honest and decent I feel you. A lot of anger in the world comes from this, I think, and I want to push back because it can lead to dangerous conclusions. I'm not arguing you would use it as such, but others do. I.e. see xenophobia, religious persecution, violence against LGBTs, etc. How much of what you say is due to a lack of honesty and decency on behalf of the rich and powerful? How many people have "abandoned their decency" because the system is just fucking impossible to overcome? It's not how I reacted, but some friends did - faced with the often impassible barrier between poverty and the lower-middle-class, they threw their hands up in the air and turned to crime, or vagrancy, or just general dickishness towards the rich ("civil disobedience" they'd call it, as they spraypainted a dick onto the rich neighborhood's entrance sign"). If people were just honest and decent, we wouldn't need jails, because nobody would commit crimes. But if people were just honest and decent, people wouldn't be going to jail because a rotten cop planted drugs on them (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UANRvFNc0hw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UANRvFNc0hw) or because they smoked a plant in the privacy of their own home. People wouldn't get shot for being black. If people were just honest and decent, other people wouldn't feel the need to squeeze every drop of support out of a system beleaguered by a warring two party system to fund and defund it at the same time. "Hell yes I'm going to abuse food stamps, republicans just got a majority, they might take it away next month!" If people were just honest and decent, we wouldn't have a rapidly escalating war between tolerance and intolerance. Antifa vs fascists. Nazis vs liberals. Friends in Texas wanting to ban transgenders from public restrooms while LGBT friends arguing "it has gotten to the point where punching nazis in the face is acceptable dialogue." The "if people were just honest and decent" argument keeps cropping up over the centuries, and I think we should work around it. Moral superiority, it doesn't work. Catholics trying for 1000 years to get people to stop getting pregnant before marriage - a multigenerational failure to understand that that strategy just doesn't fucking work. It takes a bit more creativity. So, I sympathize with your urge to throw your hands up and say "can we just stop being fucking assholes and taking advantage of eachother?" I agree. I try not to be an asshole. But there are tons of assholes in the world, and some of them, when I sit down to think about it, are kinda justified in their assholeness, because they're in shitty situations that would really stress my ability to not be an asshole. Long story short, it's not a helpful attitude - creativity is needed, alongside sympathy. Acknowledge that helping people will come with shortcomings (free riders), abandon pride, and accept that it's better than the alternative (a war of assholes undercutting eachother at every opportunity).
- pascalxus 7y agousing the ambulance for a free ride is a huge risk: you'd have to be insane to try this. If they get your name, you'll be out 4000$!!!!
- tastygreenapple 7y agoPeople with $4000 in easily seized assets / concern for their credit score probably aren't the ones treating ambulances as a taxi.
- SilasX 7y agoTrue, but most other industries have effective, scalable mechanisms to clamp down on such blatant fraud and dishonesty; health care in the US just isn't using the appropriate mechanisms, it seems. Like a basic one I see lacking is, checking the patient him/herself. I have never gotten contacted for any kind of follow up about "did you actually receive this health care", which would eliminate fraud related to the tummy tuck/C-section you mention. Or why aren't they keeping track of that person that's constantly calling the ambulance? Furthermore, where is the crushing power of the state to recover from such people? If you find systemic fraud, why aren't the regulators able to recover a big chunk of the money?
- programmertote 7y agoSecond this! My gf used to do part-time work (before she started her residency) for a couple of doctors doing mostly data entry works (to eClinicalWorks and whatnot). She would always tell me how these doctors instructed her to add more diagnosis codes so that they can get paid more (esp. from medicaid/medicare patients). My host family father is a doctor in the US. He said to me once something like, "Be prepared to be scammed by people whether it is a brain surgeon or a carpenter. Never ever trust the original price they quote on you and be critical of their output." Have you seen how pharma reps treat doctors? I have. Hundreds of dollars worth of dinners/lunches (one of the dinners my gf and I were invited to, it served unlimited Wagyu beef for bbq; of course, we had to sign in before the dinner). I am disgusted by how cozy the relationship between pharma companies and docs are. The more I talk to and observe doctors, pharma and healthcare industry in general, the more I lose respect to the parties involved (of course, there are a few respectable professionals, but they are a minority because of the sheer amount of money to be made in that industry).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thatfrenchguy 7y ago> Have you seen how pharma reps treat doctors? I have. Hundreds of dollars worth of dinners/lunches (one of the dinners my gf and I were invited to, it served unlimited Wagyu beef for bbq; of course, we had to sign in before the dinner). I am disgusted by how cozy the relationship between pharma companies and docs are. In France (and California), there's a website where you can see how much your doctor got from pharma.
- jcater 7y agoThat’s not California-specific: https://www.cms.gov/openpayments/ https://www.cms.gov/openpayments/
- pickle-wizard 7y agoI checked my doctors on that a few months back. I found out that one of my doctors received $200K for the last reporting year from the manufacturer of my medication. The medication is $600/month. Granted the medication does work for me and insurance picks up most of it, but it still seems like a massive conflict of interest. I honestly have half a mind to switch doctors.
- golemiprague 7y agoThere are two ways to deal with it, either universal healthcare which is a proven and working system in most of the western world or free market where every procedure has a price tag attached to it and people pay knowing what they pay in advance and for what exactly they pay, like a normal shop in a free market. The weird hybrid system in the US is like communism, it doesn't work, we can see it doesn't work, it costs more than any other place on earth, both for the government and the people. The US should just scrape it and choose some working system. Until then leave us alone every second week with your horror stories, it is not interesting anymore.
- appleshore 7y agoI worked out an out of network surgery center which targeted high reimbursing insurance companies. The standard tact is to lie to patients, telling them not to worry about high deductibles because the surgery center won’t collect on them. I seen an endoscopy be reimbursed $28,000 from a major county’s government employee insurance program in CA. At a hospital, it would cost around $2,000. I heard established surgeons say that some surgeons would purposely perform shoddy hernia surgeries to require further surgeries. Or add more procedures etc to inflate the charges. They’ll bill as much as possible, using billing codes in the most strategic ways. Insurance companies would then reimburse 15-20% on average. The entire system is flawed and opaque so it’s hard to know who is exploiting who.
- rb808 7y ago>The entire system is flawed and opaque so it’s hard to know who is exploiting who. Doctors are by far the highest paid career in the USA. Surgeons are paid enormous salaries. Its pretty clear who is winning. I know there is a complaint that medical school is very expensive. If we offered free medical school for cutting salaries in half, I'm pretty sure doctors would prefer to keep as it is.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoEspecially surgeons can easily make >500k. they can pay off their debt in a heartbeat and then the dough keeps rolling in.
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoLove when people that are not in healthcare have an opinion about how healthcare pays
- bradleyjg 7y ago> Doctors are by far the highest paid career in the USA. Surgeons are paid enormous salaries. Its pretty clear who is winning. Right. People talk about drug company executives. There are a few hundred at most. We have hundreds of thousands of specialist doctors making hundreds of thousands of more dollars a year than their counterparts in other countries.
- jliptzin 7y agoI'm still trying to figure out why my health insurance company paid $600 for a dermatologist to spray liquid nitrogen on a wart for 10 seconds.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoBecause they can’t find a dermatologist to do it for less.
- koolba 7y agoBecause they got a hell of a deal. He originally billed $1200 but they reduced it 50%!
- dd36 7y agoBut Medicare handles the same issues for a lot cheaper.
- analog31 7y agoIn my view, a broader observation is that every group claims to be protecting us while accusing every other group of gouging us. This leads me to suspect that they are all gouging us. The system is so labyrinthine that literally nobody can figure out where the money is going. And many of these groups have ownership stakes in the other groups. For instance, doctors are prominent owners and investors in clinics, providers, and even malpractice insurance companies. It's attributed to Abe Lincoln, that in order to get down to the truth, you have to get all of the liars in the room together. In my imagination, a potential benefit of a government health care system is that it could eliminate this rat's nest of business entities by paying directly for the things that are needed. And we'd know who is getting paid how much by just publishing the government's checkbook register. Doctors can attend medical school for free, and then work for the government, for a good professional salary. They don't have to engage in all sorts of monkey business with LLC's and insider investments to earn a living.
- AtomicOrbital 7y agoBlock chain should be used to provide a legit health history on a per person basis ... It's all about trust ... Similarly insurance and healthcare businesses must also be on a transparent block chain ... As is it's only benefitting lawyers
- ladberg 7y agoAnd make everyone's health history public? Why couldn't the government do something similar but with more privacy?
- zootam 7y ago>Similarly insurance and healthcare businesses must also be on a transparent block chain How is blockchain the answer to this at all?
- GauntletWizard 7y agoHe might just mean "Merkle tree with digital signatures", which most people intimately familiar with block chain won't distinguish from block chain, despite the former being in general use in the software industry and the latter in general use by Ponzi schemes.