10 ms·
Step one in solving problems is identify the problem. Especially in the political sphere people love to skip over this step for a variety of reasons I hardly ha
by jerf 16y ago
Step one in solving problems is identify the problem. Especially in the political sphere people love to skip over this step for a variety of reasons I hardly have to spell out.
If in fact our schooling policies are basically OK and the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation.
My personal biases lead me to believe that if anything there's problems in both places, so my main point isn't that this person is necessarily right or wrong, my main point is Step One: Identify The Problem. It's often harder than you might think and often requires biases to be discarded.
- Alex3917 16y ago"[If] the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation." Except that we already know how much of the problem stems from the home from the decades worth of research that has already been done. The PISA numbers don't contribute anything to our understanding of the problem, they're just a red herring designed to get people asking the wrong questions.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoSince we already know the answer, I guess I'll just expose my ignorance: what % of test score variance is explained by the home environment? And while we are on the topic, what % of variance is caused by: IQ, non-IQ ethnic factors, school quality, teacher quality, non-home environment, etc? I.e., what are the principal components of educational outcomes? Also, what are the "wrong questions" this article is "designed" to get people to ask?
- Alex3917 16y ago"what % of test score variance is explained by the home environment?" C.f. my comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2046264 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2046264 Both of the sources I linked to are a good place to start in terms of understanding the numbers. Another good source is the Coleman Report, which is probably the most important education study ever done: http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/ICPSR/studies/06389 http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/ICPSR/studies/06389 The data was later reanalyzed using more modern statistical techniques, so I'm not sure if the link has the new analysis or the original analysis. Both come to basically the same conclusions though. The most famous finding of the study was probably that within-school effects are much greater than between-school effects, meaning that what track your kid is placed into inside the school has a much greater impact on their education than if they go to a 'good' or 'bad' school. The interesting thing is that this study was commissioned in order to find evidence that black schools were performing much worse than white schools in order to justify integration, but the study actually found the opposite so the government essentially tried to bury it. But it was actually the largest study ever conducted at the time, and I think it's still one of the top five largest to this day.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoForgive me, but I lack a copy of the expensive proprietary software necessary to open your second link. Could you just tell us what % of variance is explained by home environment? (I'm also having a hard time finding it in your 1969 paper, but I admit I only skimmed the first 15 pages or so.)
- acqq 16y ago> expensive proprietary software There are enough free PDF readers, what are you talking about? http://www.pdfreaders.org/ http://www.pdfreaders.org/ All the files behind the second link are here: http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/ICPSR/studies/06389/documentation http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/ICPSR/studies/06389/docu...
- tedunangst 16y agoI think the point was to get an actual number. Pointing at a mountain of evidence and saying to go find the number yourself doesn't advance the conversation.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThat's just documentation for a SAS file.
- Alex3917 16y agoThe percent variance is different depending on what you want to know the variance of. It's higher for reading than for math, because kids in high-SES families spend much more time reading at home than they spend doing math at home. And even for literacy it depends on what you're measuring, e.g. it's different for vocabulary knowledge than for reading comprehension. The reason I linked to the 1969 paper is that it was the first of its kind, so the easiest way to find the more recent research is to look for papers that cite it. A quick glance at their research shows that upwards of 80% of the variance in their reading metrics was due to differences in how students spent the four summer vacations. This isn't taking into account either the initial gap (100% from home differences) or the fact that home differences effect progress made during the year. Basically the amount of variance due to home differences is definitely over 90%, but there isn't enough information from this study to put an exact number on it. Basically the only two things that have changed since 1969 are that A) poor people are much poorer and B) schools for poor people are worse. I don't know offhand how these two factors balance each other out, but I'd guess that overall the numbers are pretty similar.
- dkarl 16y agoExcept that we already know how much of the problem stems from the home from the decades worth of research that has already been done. Yet we consistently ignore what we know when discussing policy. We infer bad schools from bad student outcomes. If it's true, then what's wrong with saying it? If it's known, why does our national debate not reflect it?
- kenjackson 16y agoBecause its in the best interest of those who know, not do anything. Year-round schools would be one of the best tools to close the education gap. But if you know this, and your child benefits from the fact that they effectively get year-round schooling, while 30% of the population doesn't, you might be motivated to do nothing. While not everyone is "evil" you do have to remember that when policy reform is being done by those who have the most to "lose", be skeptical.
- 2arrs2ells 16y ago"If in fact our schooling policies are basically OK and the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation." Even if we accept your premise, I'm not sure we need to accept your conclusion. Just because the cause of the problem is a difference in home life, doesn't mean that the easiest solution to the problem is to "fix" the home life (i.e. end poverty). There are a number of schools (usually charters) who teach low-income students and structure themselves to compensate for any disadvantages students may have coming in (with strategies like longer school days/years). Some of these schools (KIPP, Uncommon Schools, Harlem Children's Zone) have had incredible success. It might seem strange to "overcompensate" for differences at home in schools - but it's a lot easier to change schools than it is to change people's home life.
- tedunangst 16y agoAt least in the case of Harlem Children's Zone, it's a lot more than a school. So the conclusion that throwing money at schools won't work is correct. We should instead throw "school" money at things like HCZ. I think you're actually in agreement with jerf, but are using different definitions of "school".
- nitrogen 16y agoUnless by "poverty" you mean the sum culture, attitude, and circumstances that lead to continued poverty, I don't think "poverty" (i.e. a simple lack of money) is the cause of the home life problem. I think that cultural (not to be misread as racial!) attitudes and parenting strategies (or lack thereof) are far more problematic than the actual economics.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>Just because the cause of the problem is a difference in home life, doesn't mean that the easiest solution to the problem is to "fix" the home life (i.e. end poverty). Just adding my voice to the sibling posts - by our governments figures we're below the poverty line, we were substantially below it but we're clawing our way up slowly. We do literacy and numeracy educational activities, general knowledge, problem solving, etc. with our kids at home. The eldest is now at school so his rate of learning has fallen back a bit but I think we're probably doing as much as anyone above the poverty line. Where we falter is affording things like sports equipment, foreign trips, arts (theatre) and music events. IMO the whole schooling system probably needs working over; the assumption appears to be that school+parents are failing if kids aren't academic. Not everyone is, nor should be, particularly academic. We don't seem to decry standards in education when people leave school and can't do basic vehicle maintenance or simple DIY tasks. Education is not solely intellectual pursuit. How do you propose to "overcompensate" at school for a lack of motivation brought about by low parental engagement. Unless you're getting the parents into school to have co-learning experiences or something I don't really buy the idea that tightening your belt will stop your shoes falling off.
- kenjackson 16y agoIf in fact our schooling policies are basically OK and the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation. I would love to see this country actually try real wealth redistribution. Not 90% tax on the top 2%... but 90% tax on the top 60%. If throwing money at schools doesn't work... does throwing money at people?
- charlesju 16y agoIf you give a man a fish he can eat for a day, if you teach a man to fish he can live forever. Simply put, throwing money at poor people solves no problems. If anything it further entrenches the mentality of entitlement and dependency. I would actually argue it's the social services that are forcing minorities to be oppressed and under achieve in society. We need to stop blindly helping those that ask and teach them to help themselves. You can see trends of this everywhere. 1. Black Students from the eyes of a teacher. It's disheartening in a lot of places -- but his conclusion is similarly that we have given too much. http://martynemko.blogspot.com/2009/06/white-teacher-speaks-out-what-is-it.html http://martynemko.blogspot.com/2009/06/white-teacher-speaks-... 2. Africa has a huge dependency issue. And a lot of very smart African thinkers are suggesting less aid or directing the aid towards more sustainable endeavors is the long-term solution. http://www.nme.com/news/bono/32704 http://www.nme.com/news/bono/32704 http://store.whatarewedoinghere.net/What-Are-We-Doing-Here-Feature/M/B002TNXD50.htm http://store.whatarewedoinghere.net/What-Are-We-Doing-Here-F...
- kenjackson 16y agoWhile the quote is catchy, it's not applicable as stated. In our society, money is the fishing pole and boat. You can teach a man to fish with his bare hands in the middle of Death Valley, but that will do him little good. He'll die just as fast, if not faster. Wealth redistribution isn't an either-or question. It's really giving the man fish today, because learning to fish takes a while. And learning to fish decently requires that you have a good constition. Our biggest entitlement programs go towards largely benefiting white people (everything from freeways to police departments to the courts to the military). The Marty link was a funny one. I used to do tutoring at a "black" school. I met teachers like him, who told me the students were worthless. Two of the "worthless" students I tutored, I was able to help them get 800s on their math SATs (one went to a military academy and the other Berkeley). The problem isn't that we've given too much, but the school system is filled with Marty's who never really gave at all.