4 ms·
What he is talking about is not Ad Hominem but Conflict of Interest. For example, a judge is required to recuse him or herself from a case in which he or she h
by jimbokun 16y ago
What he is talking about is not Ad Hominem but Conflict of Interest. For example, a judge is required to recuse him or herself from a case in which he or she has a personal interest, such as a business relationship with the plaintiff or defendant.
This is probably why Zed has the words "Conflict Of Interest" as a section heading in a very large font.
- mcantelon 16y agoThat section is rambling and contradictory. For example: "I will go on record right now saying Wikileaks rocks. ... if anyone from Wikileaks tries to work with me or on any project I'm on you bet your ass I'm not trusting them one bit. Never trust a traitor, no matter how noble their intentions." So Wikileaks "rocks", yet anyone involved in Wikileaks is a traitor and shouldn't be trusted? That seems contradictory. Taking this logic further, are journalists who cite Wikileaks' work also traitors that shouldn't be trusted? As a fan of Zed's and someone that isn't completely sold on Tor, I'd love to see a sober critique of the project's vulnerbilities from Zed, but this post isn't it.
- tptacek 16y agoA COI argument is a form of ad hom argument. In ritualized debate, what should matter is the intrinsic value of the evidence each side brings to bear, not the identity, influences, or motivations of the sides themselves.