4 ms·
Girls’ advantage in reading can largely explain the gender gap in STEM
- tyingq 7y agoI wonder how this theory squares with the relatively high percentage of women that are accountants, tax advisors, investment professionals, actuaries, etc.
- dragonwriter 7y agoObviously, those (as well as, say, the biological sciences) are not “math intensive fields”, despite appearances to the contrary, whereas churning out CRUD apps is math intensive... EDIT: Or, to be fair to the authors, other factors besides relative reading ability, as well as as accounting for the other 20% of the gender gap in math-intensive fields in general, also explain the gender distribution between particular math-intensive fields.
- rowanG077 7y agoThey aren't “math intensive fields”, they are "calculation intensive fields".
- norswap 7y agoI was puzzled by "churning out CRUD apps is math intensive" - could you explain? I do agree that the aforementioned fields are not necessarily math-intensive — except investment professional in certain cases.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 7y agodragonwriter is being facetious. An accountant or tax adviser needs reasonable applied math skills, but isn't likely to need to know the difference between a cardinality and a cartesian product. Likewise, most working programmers don't need to know the difference in their day-to-day work - although they might need to in order to pass a CS degree as a gateway to getting hired.
- tyingq 7y agoThe premise of the article, though, doesn't seem to hinge on higher level or complex math.
- Retric 7y agoI don’t know about gender differences. The classes are at least initially perceived as easy for most people, but while some find them fun other find it horribly boring. So, my guess it’s less about aptitude than liking the kind of work involved.
- darkwater 7y agoIs this suggesting that girls do not choose STEM faculties because they can read better so they like more humanistic faculties, where there are more texts (as in literature books) to read? Or my text comprehension is that bad?
- huntertwo 7y agoThat’s how I understood it but I feel the same way as you do about my text comprehensions skills.
- FabHK 7y ago> so they like more humanistic faculties Either that ("like more", ie preference), or they ask themselves what they're good at ("intraindividual comparisons of achievement"), and conclude that a career with words rather than numbers is better suited for them.
- 0xcafecafe 7y ago>> Or my text comprehension is that bad? That depends. Are you a woman or a man? /s
- 0815test 7y agoIt may be that the advantage in reading simply correlates with stronger interest in people/'social' stuff and weaker interest in STEM - this would then be the actual causative factor. One could guess that being interested in people/stories/'social' things would incent girls to read more and get better and better at reading.
- tickerticker 7y agoMy hunch about the reading skills gap is that little boys like physical movement marginally more than little girls, thus boys struggle to sit still and read.
- orwin 7y agoNot exactly. From what i understood, this article is telling that if someone feel he is better at reading/comprehension than he is at math, he is more likely to not go into math-related field, regardless of his math performance compared to the average. To dumb it up, most of the time, you don't go into a math-related field because you compare your math skills with other, but because you compare your math skills with your own reading skills (at least when you're young). It feels right, it was a really tough choice between math and philosophy for me and only peer pressure sent me to STEMs (and i sometime regret it). I'm gonna wait until replication is done until i define an opinion.
- throwaway925 7y agoGirls are victims. They need help to be free of the oppressor. If they don't respond to the market price signals, is not that they don't care, but an invisible oppressor hand is holding them back.
- Bostonian 7y agoI see vastly more attention given to areas where girls are under-represented, with the belief that such disparities are inequities to be fixed, than I do to areas where males perform worse. It seems that male deficits are largely accepted. Could the male disadvantage in reading be reduced by different instructional methods (more phonics) or with reading material that appeals to boys?
- DanBC 7y ago> than I do to areas where males perform worse. This is only because you're not looking.
- darklion 7y agoCan you point to fields where male under-representation is given the same weight as fields with male over-representation? This isn't a troll--I'm genuinely interested in seeing which fields and areas are trying to promote more balanced gender representation.
- michaelt 7y agoThere are campaigns for things like nursing [1] “Through these campaigns [...] to challenge the stereotypical image of nursing as a female career so the increase of 9% among male applicants (19% among 18 year olds) is particularly excellent news. Also for things like teaching [2]. And for things like professional-level ballet schools recruit 50% male and 50% female, despite many more female applicants, due to the practical needs of teaching partnering. [1] https://www.england.nhs.uk/2019/02/young-male-nursing-applicants-surge-after-we-are-the-nhs-recruitment-campaign/ https://www.england.nhs.uk/2019/02/young-male-nursing-applic... [2] https://www.tes.com/news/so-you-want-get-more-men-primary-teaching https://www.tes.com/news/so-you-want-get-more-men-primary-te...
- 0815test 7y ago> more phonics This paper is about high-school students, where the difference between "phonics" and (largely discredited) "real language" approaches to basic literacy skills is simply not relevant. The gap in "reading skills" is not really measuring literacy, it's more about all sorts of other stuff that the authors don't really get into. (We can assume that what's being tested is "text comprehension" of a sort, but better text-comprehension skills are hardly an obstacle for STEM!)
- throwaway55554 7y agoThe reason there's a gap is because STEM is filled with men who are assholes to women. It's not freaking hard to figure that out.
- johnrbent 7y agoI don't know much about this field (and I did not purchase the full article), but it seems like quite a leap to assume this is a source of the gender-gap. First of all, you're talking about 80% of one standard deviation difference in reading-to-math scores between males and females - that doesn't seem like enough to study it as the cause of anything. And how does being better at reading steer people away from STEM? There is just as much reading going on in STEM as out, and arguably more intensive reading in. It seems like the score difference is probably related to the gender-gap somehow, but I doubt it is a cause. I would be interested in reading the article if it was freely available.
- FabHK 7y ago> that doesn't seem like enough to study it as the cause of anything Unless I'm mistaken, their measure is basically Cohen's d, and 0.8 is indeed considered a large effect in the social sciences (look at the table in [1]). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effect_size#Cohen's_d https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effect_size#Cohen's_d
- michaelt 7y agoAnd how does being better at reading steer people away from STEM? By steering them towards non-STEM.
- hackeraccount 7y agoThe funny version I heard was basically that girls are like super humans compared to boys. They're good at Math but they're also good at non-Math too. The boys on the other hand are bad at Math compared to the girls. They're also bad at non-Math but they're not equally bad. They're really really bad at non-Math and merely bad at Math. What to do? For the boys the choice is easy - go with what you're best at. For the girls on the other hand it's harder - what do you do if you're good at everything? The answer is to do whatever you enjoy the most. So all the boys go into STEM and the girls spread their talents all over the map. It's probably not a true deception of reality but it's certainly a funny one.
- jbob2000 7y ago
- mac_was 7y agoMaybe just most women aren’t interested in STEM, like most men aren’t interested in hairdressing? Those who are, both men and women, can get jobs as I see women being very good programmers and men being very good hair dressers
- peatmoss 7y agoWe tend to see differences and fit an explanation. - For some, the differences are explainable by completely benign reasons (“girls just aren’t interested / girls have a comparative advantage in non-STEM fields”), - others see a conspiracy of intention (“men are trying to keep women out”), - others see a malevolent but unconscious system (“thoughtless behaviors drive women away”), - others see a relatively benign but unconscious system (“girls are given dolls where boys are given computers”) I am old enough to remember being bullied in school for being into computers. I remember one or two girls along the way that hung out with the rest of us nerds in the computer labs. Nobody much cared about the gender breakdown as far as I could tell—most of the adult men and women I knew expressed something between distaste and hostility to the notion that a youngster would waste so much time on these stupid toys. I think once computers established their bonafides as an economic ladder, people started to take note. But by that time, those of us relegated to hiding from bullies in the computer labs came to be the face of the computer industry. I suspect that probably exerts subtle pressure on the younger generation to conform (“these people don’t look like me, listen to my music, understand my culture, share my gender—I guess this just isn’t what my people do.” I suspect people encounter some degree of all of these things. This kind of research study is interesting in trying to suss our relative contribution.
- flipcoder 7y ago> I am old enough to remember being bullied in school for being into computers. Yep, when I was young, even some of my teachers and other adults tried to dissuade me from computers and programming. I remember being mocked and ridiculed by other kids, and no one was incentivizing it when I was in school. If anything, people were avoiding it because it was uncool. I always thought it was the social stigma present in their own peer groups that were keeping them away from it, and not gatekeeping, at least from what I witnessed.