6 ms·
Economic Optimism? Yes, I’ll Take That Bet
- jswinghammer 16y agoI agreed with John Tierney's bet when I read about it at the time but for different reasons. I believed that cheap money was bidding up the prices of oil and other commodities. I believe this is true again now that China and India have huge levels of credit expansion. Eventually these bubbles will burst and we'll see a correction again. Assuming that the Federal Reserve doesn't do its' part to keep it going.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoI like the idea of economists betting on future prices etc - it makes hypotheses much more testable. That said, I'm not entirely convinced that pretending that the oil supply is infinite is wise.
- jswinghammer 16y agoAlmost no one goes back and checks the predictions of economists. When they do it's a bad scene.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoYes, isn't that exactly my point?
- Charuru 16y agoWhoa, that's a pretty fundamental misunderstanding. While oil supply is not infinite, it's unlikely for it to be unaffordable, because before that point, people would have implemented measures to reduce their use, lower demand, and drive down prices.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoI understand that your/the author's point is more subtle than "oil is infinite", but the end result is much the same (e.g. opposing energy taxes.) You may be right: e.g. abundant nuclear power and advances in chemical engineering may render oil unnecessary before it runs out. But suppose that we really will need to continue using oil for, say, the next ten generations (e.g. for fertilizer). Do you really believe that "the market", including American politics, Saudis and several bigcos, will ensure that there will be sufficient oil for the tenth generation?
- Charuru 16y agoScare quotes are uncool man. Anyway you can't just look at the supply side and oil in isolation. It doesn't matter what you're talking about, plastics nor energy, there are alternatives to oil. Oil can increase in price until it reaches the price of the cheapest alternative, and that's a hard ceiling. And since the price of alternatives are falling all the time, I think we'll be in good shape by the 10th gen. It is literally impossible for a bigco or the saudis to overcharge for a commodity, Oil is worth thinking about in terms of short term economic wellfare, but I am confident that there will never be a Malthusian oil crisis. FYI: Oil is not used in fertilizer.
- Lagged2Death 16y agoI think one issue is the length of the bets. Ten years is a very long time for a human bet, but it's not very long in terms of history, in terms of heavy industrial technology, or in terms of Hubbert's ideas about resource peaks. It was obvious that oil was a finite resource from the start, but it took the better part of 100 years of exploitation for US oil production to peak. Five or ten years doesn't seem long enough to reliably spot a trend on that scale. I'm surprised Simmons expected such high prices. As the shock in 2008 illustrated, above a certain price, oil users cut back as much as they can, which lowers the price again. A sustained price of 200 2005-era dollars per barrel is a really high; that price would surely kill a lot of demand, which would probably prevent it from being sustained. Eventually, we may see $200/bbl, but it will probably be quite a while. I know hindsight is 20/20, but still, I would have thought a better bet would be something about the average price of oil over (say) a five year period always being higher than the average price over the previous five year period. Then again, maybe Tierney wouldn't have taken that bet.
- kbutler 16y agoThe effect of increased prices is twofold - the obvious decrease in consumption (and thus demand, exerting a downward pressure on price) and also an increase in the incentive to innovate - to find alternatives, and to make better use of the valuable resource. The "cornucopian" belief is that the effect of innovation is greater than the effect of finite resources. That is, because we innovate, real prices decrease (with prices best measured in amount of human labor to obtain a benefit). Sometimes the price of a specific commodity increases (e.g., hours of labor to receive one liter of oil), but the cost of the benefit decreases (e.g., hours of labor to travel 100 miles). I'd be very interested to see counterexamples, where the human cost of a benefit increases. kb
- roc 16y agoIt sounds to me like this Cornucopian belief is just the same 'let the market handle it' position with better branding. So the counter-argument also remains the same: 'the market' moves in fits and starts, and there is very real and severe socio-economic cost to disruptions between the start of price shocks and the emergence of alternatives. It's not unlike advocating a central bank to (theoretically) smooth out natural business cycles, not because the market would implode without it, but because you believe you can fill in a bit of the extreme troughs at the cost of taking a commensurate amount off the extreme peaks.
- tocomment 16y agoIs there really an abundance of natural gas? Why is that?
- laut 16y agoYes. Recently new drilling techniques, which make it economical to drill for shale gas, have been found.
- StrawberryFrog 16y agoThat's the kind of bet that you can win repeatedly ... until the time comes that you don't, and break the bank. Like betting on prices rising in a bubble.
- jessriedel 16y agoThis wasn't a bet with long odds. It was 50:50.
- StrawberryFrog 16y agoThe two people agreed to 50:50 odds. That does not mean that the underlying phenomena are anything like that.
- pvdm 16y ago"...new oil sands projects in Canada now supply more oil to the United States than Saudi Arabia does." Is this true ? That statement triggered some doubts in my mind.
- known 16y agoBreaking big corporations into smaller companies will create numerous jobs.