5 ms·
This is very unfortunate. Apple being totally hands off, other than running the iTunes podcast directory, is one of the best things that’s ever happened for pod
by MBCook 7y ago
This is very unfortunate. Apple being totally hands off, other than running the iTunes podcast directory, is one of the best things that’s ever happened for podcasts.
I like my 3rd party app (Overcast). I don’t want to have to use 3 podcast apps to listen to all my podcasts.
I think I agree with some of the podcast app developers: if it’s not available in any app it shouldn’t be called a ‘podcast’.
- jfengel 7y agoKind of ironic, since the name "podcast" comes from the Apple iPod. If anybody would have first dibs on the name "podcast", it's them.
- saipenguin 7y agoSure, but their opportunity to claim those dibs passed years ago.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoPerhaps, but Podcasts began outside of Apple. It was several years before Apple decided to officially support them in iTunes.
- scarface74 7y agoPodcasts first came out in 2004. Apple included podcast support in iTunes in 2005.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoThat in and of itself is kind of ironic since the iPod has been all but relegated to the annals of history.
- theturtletalks 7y agoApple, as it is now, was built off the cash cow that was the iPod. Then they cannibalized it with the iPhone.
- jfengel 7y ago"No wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame." It's gone now that everybody has a pocket supercomputer, but it's stunning just how far it went in completely changing the way we relate to music, and audio in general.
- root_axis 7y agoI don't think it changed the way I relate to music at all, it was just one more step in the ladder. I had a walkman before I had CD player before I had a MiniDisk Player before I had an iPod before I had Spotify.
- colechristensen 7y agoTo me the iPod and iTunes around 2006 were there peak of my interaction with music. Before or after everything has been worse. I've seriously considered building my own music hardware company just to recapture a few features and UX experiences which for me at least made music a much bigger part of my life.
- paulcole 7y agoI think the comment you’re replying to meant “we” as in society not as in specifically-you.
- ihuman 7y agoApple didn't create the term podcast, though. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p038m811 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p038m811
- duncans 7y ago“podcast” I think you meant.
- ihuman 7y agoYou're right. I've fixed my comment.
- m463 7y agoThere's also quite a name collision with this company's product that has remained surprisingly civil with apple https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_6_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_6_(company)
- microdrum 7y agoAlthough I personally don’t like Overcast because of the ad injection (which I consider immoral) and the hypocrisy of its author being anti-ads in general (not to mention having built Tumblr, which turned out to be a porn obfuscation service), I agree that this is a bad move by Apple. Doesn’t matter: podcasts are going to go the way of TV, radio, and movies anyway.
- Jgrubb 7y agoDid you purchase the $10 in app option to turn ads off?
- microdrum 7y agoDo you purchase subscriptions to news websites, or do you follow the archive.is links on HN? Of course I didn't purchase Overcast. There are better free alternatives.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoYes, I do purchase subscriptions to news web sites occasionally, because I don't consider writers being paid to be intrinsically immoral. Given the choice to pay them with ads and pay them directly, I'll take the latter. I suppose "rely on other people seeing ads and/or paying for content to subsidize me" is also an option.
- lukebitts 7y agoWhat is a "porn obfuscation service"?
- microdrum 7y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2018/11/20/18104366/tumblr-ios-app-child-pornography-removed-from-app-store https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/20/18104366/tumblr-ios-app-...
- stetrain 7y ago
- reaperducer 7y agoForm what I read in the article it doesn't sound all that terrible. If Apple were to remove all non-Apple podcasts from its platform, that would be bad. This is just Apple supplementing what's already available. It's very much like Apple rolling out original television shows on the AppleTV. It's not like HBO is getting kicked out. It makes sense to me that Apple would do this. Since it's making podcasts a separate program on the Mac, it wants to make it more popular and useful. As far as I can tell, there's nothing stopping another person, company, or organization from producing podcasts that blow Apple's offerings out of the water and still distributing them through Apple. When that happens, I'll worry. Until then, this seems like an OK way to draw attention to podcasts as a whole.
- MBCook 7y agoApple having original podcasts, EVEN IF FREE, means there are now two classes of citizens on its platform. First class (Apple stuff), and ‘the rest’. And I don’t trust that ‘the rest’ will continue to get good treatment like they have. It’s too easy to stop featuring big podcasts from companies who are now your podcast competitors. Basically they’re losing their neutrality.
- dmix 7y agoThat would only be bad if Apple had a monopoly or the other platforms all copy Apple and it cannibalizes the freedom of podcasting in general. But if it’s limited to a few ‘premium’ shows/platforms - while 99% of other content is open - I don’t really see it as a problem. Particularly if the only way they can finance the shows is by limiting it to their platform, then I’d rather have them still produce that content than not at all… Sometimes it’s the only way it makes sense as a business, there is no open alternative. Spotify, Netflix, and every other streaming service functions this way with non-portable content and providing clients on every platform. While piracy fills the void for those who can’t pay or access the platform (for geographic reasons or w/e). But I have to agree with the OP, it isn’t really a podcast anymore if it’s tied to one platform. It’s more like an on-demand XM radio show than a podcast.
- 7y ago
- Swenrekcah 7y agoCompletely agree that if it’s not accessible on any app then it’s not a podcast. I also would pay for a podcast app that could guarantee that the audio file was the same for all listeners.
- snailmailman 7y agoI wish the later could be possible. I have no idea how podcast-ads work but lately i noticed some podcasts giving me seemingly location-dependent ads. (about something in a nearby major city) either everyone is getting advertisements for a very dallas targeted ad, or are the podcast companies making several versions of the podcast and serving different ones to different people? sounds like a lot of extra work to me, but I suppose its not hard to automate stitching a few ads into an audio file.
- mattferderer 7y agoThe guys on .NET Rocks have talked a bit about this & being able to tweak & update ads over time. One big reason is people still listen to their old shows & they would like those ads to still have value. I believe the host of your podcast files that people download will send different audio files to different people with different ads targeted in.
- bscphil 7y agoI agree - actually I've gotten into the habit of trying to track down the original RSS feed for each podcast I listen to. Often the link shared by the podcaster will be to rehosters like Google Play or iTunes, or lesser-known services, that have tracking and probably the ability to insert custom ads. The worst is when they make the elitist move of only linking iTunes, making their podcast unlistenable (on mobile at least) to most people worldwide. But most of the time the original file is getting pulled by the rehoster from an unprotected RSS feed, and these can be easy to find. You can get the RSS feeds for Soundcloud, as an example. Others are hosted on Libsyn.com, and you can often find them by searching for the podcast name and "site:libsyn.com" in the search engine of your choice. That said, I don't listen to podcasts enough any more to say whether this is a universal solution at all. Actually, the fact that podcasts have unblockable ads is one of the main reasons I no longer bother.
- neves 7y agoI see a lot of good podcast apps for Apple but I couldn't find a nice one for Android. I would like to pay for one, but I can't a reasonable one that allows me to make my playlists and speed listen without drowning me in ads. Sure I can spend hours trying each one of the dozens, but would my fellow HN have any suggestion?
- nyc640 7y agoHave you tried Pocket Casts? Any reason it doesn’t work for you?
- neves 7y agoNever tried because it is paid. I didn't know if it was good.
- dageshi 7y agoI've used Podcast Addict for years, I don't use playlists or change the playback speed but after just checking it looks like you can do both.
- lordgrenville 7y ago+1 for Podcast Addict. Terrific free app. I've used it for several years and it keeps getting better.
- julianz 7y agoPocket Casts. End of story. It has speed settings and silence trimming, playlists, syncs across devices, and you pay for it so there's no ads.
- neves 7y agoI just bought it. Looks really nice. I like to speed listen to news podcasts, but music ones must be heard at 1x speed. It is very nice that it has customized settings by podcast.
- 7y ago
- walshemj 7y agoIf your doing it professionally or even as a serious amateur its a "show"
- NowThenGoodBad 7y agoApple's podcast app used to be great. I used to be able to easily subscribe and download all the episodes for a show, navigate to any show, and get back to what I was listening to all in a few taps. As it stands now, if you want to add all of the episodes from a show that you have listened to for the past 14 years that somehow was not subscribed to on your device, you have to go to the show and subscribe, go to available episodes and tap on the + next to every.single.episode and even then sometimes episodes get lost. You can set the custom settings to download all available, but it won't download the episodes of a subscribed podcast if you haven't explicitly added them (tap that + sign) Also, can we just set the screen podcast app opens on to our own choice? I literally have to go through an extra menu just to see my show listing. Yes, I've created a "station" for the shows but that's immensely inconvenient if I want to listen to one show continuously without having to navigate to the shows page (guess I have to create a station for every show...) I don't think the Apple funded shows will be bad. This article really seems to be creating a mountain out of nothing. Hopefully, this means that some lucky podcaster or media group makes $$$ off of a deal with Apple.