8 ms·
Why support proprietary Apple Maps instead of Open Street Map? Is the data a lot more precise? Is the viewer smoother? Is it just another step towards aligning
by solarkraft 7y ago
Why support proprietary Apple Maps instead of Open Street Map? Is the data a lot more precise? Is the viewer smoother?
Is it just another step towards aligning with Apple for an eventual buyout/search engine standard?
That said: If privacy is the only concern Apple seems to be a pretty good ally, as the only major player with a significant interest in it.
- Freak_NL 7y ago> Is the data a lot more precise? Perhaps in Apple's own backyard. In the Netherlands it's laughably bad. Cycle tracks? Mostly missing (in a country that has a huge cycling infrastructure). The map doesn't even have building outlines. Google Maps is slightly better, but mostly because of the more extensive mapping of points-of-interest; because business owners add their own information with an almost religious zeal. Bing interestingly enough uses OpenStreetMap (and properly attributes its usage) to gain access to the municipally contributed building outlines OpenStreetMap can use due to its permissive licence. The roads are their own though, and they are quite inaccurate at the lower end of the road hierarchy. OpenStreetMap is probably the most complete map here in the Netherlands (disclaimer: I contribute to OpenStreetMap). DuckDuckGo using Apple Maps instead of OpenStreetMap is a really weird choice for many countries, but perhaps it works better in the US?
- danieldk 7y agoPerhaps in Apple's own backyard. In the Netherlands it's laughably bad. Cycle tracks? Mostly missing (in a country that has a huge cycling infrastructure). The map doesn't even have building outlines. Apple uses Tom Tom data. We never had serious problems with car navigation in Germany where we lived before and in The Netherlands. Bike navigation is indeed bad, but it is also bad with Google Maps once you cycle in nature (outside cities). Then nothing beats a good Garmin GPS with paid maps (e.g. Topo Germany Pro and Topo Benelux), which do not only contain smaller cycling roads, unpaved roads, etc. but typically also contain paths recommended by national cycling associations (ActiveRouting). Unfortunately, it seems they are not updating maps frequently anymore, I guess it's a small market. I hope that OpenStreetMap continues to pick up the slack.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoApple uses Tom Tom data. We never had serious problems with car navigation in Germany where we lived before and in The Netherlands. The car navigation in Germany was fine with Apple Maps for me (although I only used it for one trip), but the public transit info was mostly missing.
- saagarjha 7y agoApple uses a variety of providers in addition to TomTom, which they list here: https://gspe21-ssl.ls.apple.com/html/attribution.html https://gspe21-ssl.ls.apple.com/html/attribution.html
- robin_reala 7y agoData is just frequently different between different mapping services. I was in Seoul recently and Google maps refused to do walking directions. Apple maps did walking directions just fine, but refused to do public transport routing. In the end I just had to swap between them throughout the day.
- scrooched_moose 7y agoOpen Street Map is not remotely usable in many parts of the country. Picking largely at random: South Minneapolis is pretty much unpopulated other than parks/schools/churches: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/44.9256/-93.2303 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/44.9256/-93.2303 Same in a good chunk of Memphis: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/35.1364/-89.9691 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/35.1364/-89.9691 and some major suburbs of Atlanta: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/33.7077/-84.2708 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/33.7077/-84.2708 It appears to be a usability/functionality tradeoff. Apple Maps isn't perfect in privacy nor accuracy/completeness, but OSM is useless for many people.
- Doctor_Fegg 7y agoWhere “the country” is the US, of course. This doesn’t hold true in Europe at all.
- lucb1e 7y agoPlease pick truly at random, not three places in the USA. I once picked 100 random coordinates on land (by picking random coordinates and filtering out those that landed in water). OSM is by far the best. It's not even a competition. I still have to do a writeup of that some day, posting just the stats and methodology (scientific paper style) won't interest most people, and I forgot to capture screenshots, so I basically have to redo it completely. It's almost certainly different if you select random points biased by population centres, but at least know that "not remotely usable" is a very local issue (see the sibling comments about the Netherlands) and that it depends on your use case.
- kalleboo 7y agoAFAIK, OSM is not happy when you use their tile servers for large commercial projects like DDG[0], so DDG would have to run, maintain and update that whole infrastructure themselves. For a service of their size it would probably require at least a dedicated engineer. With Apple Maps, they just have to include some JavaScript and Apple deals with all of that. [0] https://operations.osmfoundation.org/policies/tiles/ https://operations.osmfoundation.org/policies/tiles/