4 ms·
Better headline is “LA is reducing carbon output by 50% by replacing coal electricity production with natural gas.” It will be funny when the switch from natur
by prepend 7y ago
Better headline is “LA is reducing carbon output by 50% by replacing coal electricity production with natural gas.”
It will be funny when the switch from natural gas to solar in twenty years has a headline of “LA is finally ditching natural gas - and replacing it with another polluting fuel.”
- macspoofing 7y agoExcept if you go solar, then natural-gas comes along for the ride, because you need something that can backup the daily, and seasonal variability in solar output. This is why natural gas companies are one of the biggest lobby groups for wind and solar deployments.
- todd3834 7y agoWouldn’t it use much much less natural gas though?
- cbcoutinho 7y agoNo, because of the various 'baseload' energy sources that maintain the bulk of the electricity capacity, natural gas is the quickest to turn on and off. This flexibility lends itself to be a better 'backup' than a coal or nuclear plant. Increasing the capacity of solar and wind essentially makes the grid less stable and requires other baseload sources to be more flexible. Natural gas power plants, being more flexible than the others, see that as a huge potential to corner off a chunk of the baseload market.
- bilbo0s 7y agoOf course. LNG plants are somewhat unique in that you can switch them on and off like light switches. And that's the name of the game: Try to minimize pollutants. Pollutants can never go to zero. There will always be some. Question is, which strategy gets you closest to zero. Wind+Water is the lowest pollutant profile we know of currently, and such a system in a state or city would still produce a lot of pollutants during its build out.
- macspoofing 7y ago>And that's the name of the game: Try to minimize pollutants. No. The name of the game is to remove CO2 emissions. Because, as I've been told, CO2 emissions are an existential threat to humanity. Or is that not the case anymore? >Wind+Water is the lowest pollutant profile we know of currently No. Nuclear is. Hydro works but is geographically dependent. Both Wind and Water have huge environmental footprints with enormous impact on local ecosystems.
- bilbo0s 7y agoAll pollutants are existential threats to humans. As a matter of fact, that's a very large part of the reason we call them "pollutants". You're saying that CO2 can affect more humans, which is likely true. But whether you kill 100000 or 100000000, you're still killing. And though pollutants could kill 100000 or 100000000, to date there has not been such massive losses attributed to pollutants. (Dropping radioactive nuclear warheads on cities doesn't count, because we meant to kill those people.) Also, pumped hydro is not geographically dependent. Where are people parroting that idea from? You dig a cylinder into the bedrock, water proof it and fill it with water. There's a piston at the top that lowers slowly over time, thus providing the flow back into the top of the cylinder for power. Finally, every energy plant has enormous impacts on local ecosystems. Do you want to save the squirrels, or the humans? If you want to save both, Wind+Water is unquestionably the best system to build. But it's enormously expensive. (Ask the average civil engineer how much drilling the pylons for an average skyscraper costs. Yeah, this would cost even more and you'd be drilling pylon equivalents for 20 skyscrapers at the same time.) So people instead use the cheapest system to build, which is Wind+LNG.
- macspoofing 7y ago>All pollutants are existential threats to humans If that's the way you see CO2 emissions, then I have no quarrel with you - though you may be at odds with the entire environmental movement and possibly climatologists. Carbon emissions are not sold today as just another pollutant (out of many) that needs to be managed. They are sold as THE existential threat to humanity. If you don't see that, then nuclear is not necessary, you can get good, clean power generation from natural gas and wind/solar mix.
- Mrdarknezz 7y agoExcept they'll ditch natural gas for nuclear
- M2Ys4U 7y agoWhich is a good thing.
- bilbo0s 7y agoEvery energy source will pollute. Solar, GeoThermal, Wind and Hydro will pollute during their construction. Everything else we know of will pollute during their construction as well as during operation. Most have pollutants you need to deal with well after being taken out of operation. People who want 100% pollutant free energy are being unreasonable. At our level of species intelligence and technological know how, we're basically in the position of having to pick a poison and go with it. (Or pick several poisons as the case may be.)
- ajross 7y agoYes, but there's both a battle and a war afoot. In isolation, replacing coal with gas is a win, but LA: 1. Has a political base willing to tolerate more cost than a mere gas plant. 2. Is comparatively wealthy and thus has the budget for a more expensive option. 3. Is in a renewables dream zone: mildest climate of any large city (i.e. smallest daily and seasonal usage swings), clear skies almost year round and steady ocean winds blowing over coastal ridge lines. The thinking to an activist is that LA needs to be doing more, because let's be honest: there are other local governments in the US who will be doing less simply because of political affiliation. And I think that's exactly right.
- prepend 7y agoThat’s a good point, but this article doesn’t talk about trade offs. What would the price be for all wind, or all solar, or all nuclear. The headline is misleading and a much better article, to me, would be about what went into this decision and the timeline. This is not the only plant feeding LA and should be a mixture of renewables and this plant.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoThat's mostly because said political base doesn't know where the power comes from until they hear about it. Check out stacked bar graph further down. LA is 30% renewable, 31% natural gas, 18% coal, and 21% something else in 2017. So they're still getting 49% from fossil fuels.