4 ms·

There is literally zero precedent for what you’re talking about. Immigrants jailed in the US because of import taxes? Because of a trade rework? Never. We inter

There is literally zero precedent for what you’re talking about. Immigrants jailed in the US because of import taxes? Because of a trade rework? Never. We interred Japanese after Japan commuted one of the largest terror attacks in US history, that’s it.

dgudkov 7y ago
>There is literally zero precedent for what you’re talking about. That's not exactly true. While China doesn't detain US citizens (yet!) it detains several Canadian citizens presumable because the Huawei's CFO has been arrested in Canada by a US request. See https://time.com/5626289/china-canada-arrest-yantai/ https://time.com/5626289/china-canada-arrest-yantai/ Which makes things even worse - you may become a hostage due to US/China conflicts even if you happened to be a citizen of a US ally.
nkrisc 7y ago
Conflating war and terrorism isn't a good look for the US either.
dang 7y ago
Would you please not create accounts to do political battle on HN? That's against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. We want thoughtful conversation here, not flamewars.
- hostilerhetoric 7y ago
  No dang, I won’t stop because what I’m doing is not against the rules. This is not a political issue, it’s an issue of facts that happens to be about a political topic.
anw 7y ago
While I hesitate to feed the trolling comments... > We interred Japanese after Japan commuted one of the largest terror attacks in US history, that’s it. 1.) "We" did not inter Japanese. Those who made the rules and followed them during that time did. If by "We" you mean "Americans" then that leads to the next point... 2.) Many of the "Japanese" you say were interred were Americans. They were put into camps not because of any actual reason than how they look and where their ancestry hailed from. 3.) Imprisoning people who have done nothing wrong and have lived their lives in this country should make painfully clear the quote, "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
- throwaway5752 7y ago
  I appreciate you replying to that poster. I don't think of it as feeding the trolls, but performing a public service. That kind of disinformative and malicious content is infectious, and it's been to everyone's detriment that it's been allow to fester in so any corners of the internet. It deserved to be called out for being morally and factually wrong.

dgudkov 7y ago

>There is literally zero precedent for what you’re talking about. That's not exactly true. While China doesn't detain US citizens (yet!) it detains several Canadian citizens presumable because the Huawei's CFO has been arrested in Canada by a US request. See https://time.com/5626289/china-canada-arrest-yantai/ https://time.com/5626289/china-canada-arrest-yantai/ Which makes things even worse - you may become a hostage due to US/China conflicts even if you happened to be a citizen of a US ally.

nkrisc 7y ago

Conflating war and terrorism isn't a good look for the US either.

dang 7y ago

Would you please not create accounts to do political battle on HN? That's against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. We want thoughtful conversation here, not flamewars.

hostilerhetoric 7y ago
No dang, I won’t stop because what I’m doing is not against the rules. This is not a political issue, it’s an issue of facts that happens to be about a political topic.

anw 7y ago

While I hesitate to feed the trolling comments... > We interred Japanese after Japan commuted one of the largest terror attacks in US history, that’s it. 1.) "We" did not inter Japanese. Those who made the rules and followed them during that time did. If by "We" you mean "Americans" then that leads to the next point... 2.) Many of the "Japanese" you say were interred were Americans. They were put into camps not because of any actual reason than how they look and where their ancestry hailed from. 3.) Imprisoning people who have done nothing wrong and have lived their lives in this country should make painfully clear the quote, "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."

throwaway5752 7y ago
I appreciate you replying to that poster. I don't think of it as feeding the trolls, but performing a public service. That kind of disinformative and malicious content is infectious, and it's been to everyone's detriment that it's been allow to fester in so any corners of the internet. It deserved to be called out for being morally and factually wrong.