4 ms·
Yes, but I don’t think that was the factor here. Ancient technology was astoundingly precise (see the famous Antikythera mechanism). I think the problem was ro
by atoav 7y ago
Yes, but I don’t think that was the factor here. Ancient technology was astoundingly precise (see the famous Antikythera mechanism).
I think the problem was roads. If you combine bad (or nonexistent) roads with airless hard tires, the result is much much less useful than any modern bike on any modern road.
The first bikes were indeed wooden with wooden wheels. No ball bearings, no hollow steel tubes etc. But streets.
I could now say something about how engineers are so specialized in their perspective they cannot judge things without bringing current conventions into it but hey, every profession comes with it’s weakness.
- ghaff 7y agoBoth factors are relevant. Modern mountain bikes with pneumatic tires (for example) would have been very useful going back to medieval times when roads were pretty rough. And, as you say, given streets, even low-grade bikes can be useful.
- sk5t 7y agoWould a wooden bicycle, with not-very-freely-spinning wheels, and a bone-jarring ride, be worth the considerable expense of purchasing? Would it even be better than walking and/or using a wheelbarrow? Doesn't the thing produced have to rise above a certain level of utility to merit making some copies of it? For human-scale power, I am not sure a bicycle without bearings or pneumatic tires works other than as a curiosity.
- loeg 7y ago> For human-scale power, I am not sure a bicycle without bearings or pneumatic tires works other than as a curiosity. Pretty much all modern rideshare bicycles do not have pneumatic tires, FWIW. Ride quality suffers, but it's not an awful tradeoff for short trips with whatever squishy compound they use now.
- mikepurvis 7y agoYeah but the alternative in antiquity wasn't "whatever squishy compound", it was wood, perhaps with a metal strap around it, like a carriage wheel.
- atoav 7y agoWhich is why in the early wooden “bikes” (you were sitting on a wooden bar and pushing with your legs) they made the bar “squishy” by adding some sort of saddle or some adapted spring dampers or sth.
- loeg 7y agoUnderstood.
- DoctorOetker 7y agoIt's interesting that wood is considered impractical for a bicycle... but somehow practical for a carriage? Carriages used to have suspensions (made from some elastic whale bone I believe). If someone would attempt to build a bicycle in a time of carriages with carriage wheels, I would then expect this person to also copy (at least in analogy) the suspension systems for carriages of that time, if not on the first try at least on the second...
- CydeWeys 7y agoThat's not really accurate. Docked bikeshare systems in US major cities use real pneumatic tires. Citibike in NYC, whatever Ford Bike in SF is called now, Capital Bikeshare in DC, and more. It's just some of the cheap dockless purveyors that use non-pneumatic tires, and these companies have been dropping like flies. The docked bikeshares by contrast are still (slowly) expanding with their superior, but admittedly more expensive, bicycles.
- B1FF_PSUVM 7y ago> be worth the considerable expense of purchasing Anyone with the means to pay would much rather use an animal-pulled cart instead of literally making an ass of himself. Or just ride a horse like a gentleman. (Until the 'mad dogs and Englishmen' craze hit.)
- atoav 7y agoI think bicycling was really not relevant, because the peasants would probably rather take a mule or a wagon to carry stuff around and the aristocrats would rather take a comfortable carriage. There was basically no rich middle class which had the time and money to fool around with individual transportation, and the other classes had either no real reason to want this or it was pure luxury.
- Someone 7y agoGoogling “bicycles in Africa” gives me plenty of examples of peasants who, I guess, would rather use a mule or wagon, but cannot afford one, and are much helped with a bicycle. I also would think such people existed elsewhere in the world centuries ago.
- ncmncm 7y agoBicycles in Africa can exist only as output of the massive industrial base elsewhere. Chinese wheelbarrows are the real endpoint of pre-industrial transportation.
- nickbauman 7y agoThe Antikythera Mechanism was a completely exotic Roman artifact. It was the space shuttle of its time. Not really a fair comparison. Dually, Romans were known for their extensive roads system. My family home sites directly below the Ancient Roman frontier in Germany, where you can climb a mountain and still find a 10 foot wide stone road they built 2000 years ago mostly intact
- entee 7y agoAs any cyclist who has been on cobblestones can tell you, the pavers used on Roman roads aren't friendly to bikes. This would be doubly true without a pneumatic tire. Amazing engineering but not suitable for a bicycle.
- hinkley 7y agoSee also: Paris-Roubaix. They often use customized bikes for that to keep from shaking their fillings out.
- magduf 7y agoThey actually use road bikes for these, though they're versions that are now called "endurance bikes". They're a pretty popular segment of road bike sales now. The two biggest models are the Specialized Roubaix (named after the race of course), and the Trek Domane. Both are basically road bikes with relaxed geometry and some compliance features to reduce/absorb vibration so the rider doesn't get tired as quickly. And of course wider tires, typically 28 or 32mm, but this has actually become the norm these days for road bikes anyway. (23mm tires used to be the norm, but that's gone out of fashion now, as people have decided you don't gain enough in efficiency with such skinny tires to make the downsides (punishing ride quality) worth it.)
- nickbauman 7y agoThe Roman pavers you would ride on today are 2000 years old, remember. Back then they were in much better shape, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_roads#/media/File:PompeiiStreet.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_roads#/media/File:Pompei...
- benj111 7y ago"see the famous Antikythera mechanism" As a counterpoint see the marine chronometer for measuring longitude. Clocks had been around for centuries so easy right? [1] Making something strong/reliable is easy, making something precise is 'easy', making something strong/reliable and precise, oh and preferably lightweight is hard. You do have a good point about roads though. In fact in the UK the first push to tarmac the roads came from cyclists, not from motorists. And the first tyres were for a certain Mr Dunlops sons bicycle. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_chronometer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_chronometer
- roywiggins 7y agoEven marine chronometers, once they were perfected, were very expensive, artisan pieces that had to be handmade.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- roywiggins 7y ago> Ancient technology was astoundingly precise Highly skilled artisans could make one-off pieces fit together exactly. Doing so at scale was prohibitively expensive, because machine tools hadn't been invented that let you precisely machine things identically. So, if you had a broken bicycle, you'd need a skilled artisan just to repair it- off-the-shelf parts were impossible. Every single bike would have been a unique object. This is how guns, ships, clocks, and basically everything was made before reliable methods of achieving precision were invented at the dawn of the industrial revolution. The antikythera mechanism had inherent looseness in its hand-wrought gears which greatly limited how accurate it could have been. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism#Accuracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antikythera_mechanism#Accuracy (source: this book, which I gather is pretty accurate, if pop-history https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B072BFJB3Z https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B072BFJB3Z )
- blattimwind 7y ago> Ancient technology was astoundingly precise (see the famous Antikythera mechanism). Ancient technology was neither accurate nor precise. Making two specific things fit (e.g. THIS dowel pin in THAT hole in a brass plate) does not require precision in the actual sense of the word, you can achieve the goal by consistently small iterations (ex: grinding the dowel down until wanted fit is achieved). Precision (all my threads are the same) and accuracy (and they fit with the thread from every other machine shop) are what made the industrial revolution. Ancient technology had neither of those.