3 ms·
It's amazing how many scams and malware-serving websites are in Google Ads, and how aggressively Google refuses to address it. I've actually had Googlers (here
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
It's amazing how many scams and malware-serving websites are in Google Ads, and how aggressively Google refuses to address it. I've actually had Googlers (here on HN) go and report and have removed the malicious sites I reported, just to see them back a handful of hours later, without so much as rotating domain names out.
Google must be stripped of any profit from criminal activity on their platform. When a fraudulent site is removed, Google should be forced to give up all of the profits generated from it. Though I doubt Google would even make the Fortune 500 if it did.
Section 230 absolutely has to go for order and justice to prevail.
My go-to example for the particular type of predatory crimes Google knowingly and willfully enables happens whenever a senior citizen searches for "mapquest": https://www.google.com/search?q=mapquest https://www.google.com/search?q=mapquest
I actually took a call yesterday from someone who "couldn't get directions from MapQuest without installing something". And if you look at the search results, you'll see why: Ads that look like real search results that claim to be MapQuest push the real MapQuest below the scroll fold. And computer-illiterate individuals get taken advantage of, again and again and again. I've been pointing out this example for six or seven years, and the same domains that were operating then are still operating today, because Google simply makes too much money from them to care.
If you work for Google, this is where your paycheck is coming from, and if you use Google, this is the cost of your convenience.
- cwkoss 7y agoGoogle has a strong incentive to be ineffective at catching fraud on their platform, and despite the company line, it shows through their actions.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoIndeed. I think it's fundamentally key to fixing this that profit from fraudulent activity be confiscated. (I'm sure we can find a responsible way to spend it, compensating victims of fraud or something similar.) With ad slots being an auction of sorts, Google benefits from increased bidding when there are more bidders... including fraudulent ones. So there's zero reason for them to prevent fraud. If upon a fraudulent account being reported and shut down, they lost all of their profit from that account's history, they would have a significant incentive to prevent fraud on the platform, since any fraudulent "winners" would completely zero out an ad slot for them.
- la_barba 7y agoIn a way Google probably fears addressing these issues because once they take ownership of them, they are going to be forever saddled and blamed when bad ads get through their review system or when shitty videos get promoted on youtube or when people get some "racist" result when they ask OK Google about $stereotype. Google's main source of cash is replacing humans with automation. For them re-introducing humans (i.e. risk) into the equation means seeing dollar bills grow wings and fly off. Most internet companies do not want their services to have a human labor component. It used to be a joke that you could never call anyone at Google to get any of their shit fixed. They just farmed it out to the "community". But whose laughing now? They used to "organize the worlds information", but 'information' soon changed to 'content', and 'content' to 'content farm'. I doubt any significant percentage of their users are ever going to switch away from Google. There is almost no way to detect if you should have gotten a better search result or a better ranking. The results are OK as long as you get a link that is vaguely useful. Its been years since you could even look at the actual results. They claim a query has a millions of results, but you can't even go past page 20. #Fail ? Us nerds made them popular by recommending them to our friends and family and/or surreptitiously installing Chrome to escape the tech-support-calls-from-hell for IE toolbars and shit. We're partly responsible too..
- tracker1 7y agoThey're already heavily tweaking YouTube and Search results. They really shouldn't have section 230 protections for their ad platforms.
- ac29 7y ago> Section 230 absolutely has to go for order and justice to prevail. For those who are unfamiliar with the reference, section 230 is a provision of a telecommunications act that gives legal immunity to platform providers that host user-provided content [0]. Getting rid of it would absolutely kill this site and 99.99% of similar sites by effectively requiring all user generated content to go through legal review. Absent review, a malevolently minded individual could post libelous or other illegal content on a website and have the site itself be sued. It would have a terribly chilling effect on the internet as we know it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communications_Decency_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communicati...
- apostacy 7y agoI don't think anyone wants to completely get rid of 230, but it should be narrowed. I think an ideal compromise would be that ubiquitous mega-platforms should be held somewhat responsible for what their users post, under certain circumstances. If a platform is already protectively policing and curating content, then they are not really a platform, they are more of a publisher. Companies like Facebook and YouTube should absolutely be open to lawsuits for what users post. They are already investing significant resources in regulating what users post anyway, so they are taking responsibility for it. I think even large websites should still get full 230 protection, if they only have minimal moderation to remove spam or blatantly illegal content, like Craigslist. Craigslist is much more of a neutral platform than Facebook.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThey’re investing significant resources in regulation because the public and lawmakers have demanded they do. Craigslist can afford to be more neutral only because nobody’s trying to organize cyberbullying campaigns or Rohingya genocides through Craigslist.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThis is exactly what these companies want you to believe, but the Internet would survive removing platform immunity. The incentive would definitely move in favor of platforms policing content, but the "chilling effect" would be limited if these platforms wished to remain in business (they do). As I noted in one of my comments, if illicit profits were confiscated even, platforms would have significant motivation to remove illicit content, even if they couldn't be charged for criminal activity themselves.