4 ms·
Understanding his fate allows him to be an icon for disenfranchised minorities as well.
by mywittyname 7y ago
Understanding his fate allows him to be an icon for disenfranchised minorities as well.
- criddell 7y agoDoes his end makes him more of an icon for disenfranchised minorities than the immense contributions this genius made over his life. If history were different and he were hit by a bus or lived a long life, he would still be an icon, no?
- iamnotacrook 7y ago"Does his end makes him more of an icon for disenfranchised minorities than the immense contributions this genius made over his life". Yes. "If history were different and he were hit by a bus or lived a long life, he would still be an icon, no?" Yes, but in that situation he would not be such an icon for disenfranchised minorities because the nonsense gay people had to deal with back then wouldn't have been so visible. Are there any other people from that particular point in time and location who are remembered for suffering and dying as he did?
- criddell 7y ago> in that situation he would not be such an icon for disenfranchised minorities In other words, he's an icon to different people for different reasons? That makes sense.
- mywittyname 7y agoWe shouldn't discount the value of having important people in history who were minorities, outcasts, or otherwise disenfranchised. To most young people, he's probably seen in the same light as Newton, Plato, or any of the other Smart People in History. But to an LGBTQ person, he can be looked to as a person who did great things while suffering from a social stigma that they too encounter on a daily basis. Young people want to learn about heroes that are like them.
- imtringued 7y agoThat's not the point. The people that celebrate him now hated him so much in the past that they have driven him to suicide.
- criddell 7y agoSurely the people that drove him to suicide are mostly dead now. Turing has a lot of admirers here and few of us are old enough to remember a time when he was alive (I'm guessing there aren't a lot of HN members older than 70).
- GarrisonPrime 7y agoHow so? As a gay man, I’m not encouraged by the story of his abuse. If anything it serves as an oppressive reminder that some people will always irrationally wish me harm. Perhaps some people feel “empowered” by a victim mentality, but that doesn’t seem very socially progressive to me.
- mywittyname 7y agoThe encouragement comes from knowing that someone like them accomplished great things despite being different and being attacked for something they couldn't help. The reason we should talk about his fate is that I don't believe in white-washing history. Society was full of assholes who had no problem destroying the lives of people who were different. Keeping light of these atrocities fresh in peoples' minds provides for a mechanism to show the progress of society and helps prevent regressions.