3 ms·
I still don't think it's happening any time soon: 1. Much like during the PPC-to-X86 transition, Apple will need to emulate Intel x86-64 on ARM64 at reasonable
by otterley 7y ago
I still don't think it's happening any time soon:
1. Much like during the PPC-to-X86 transition, Apple will need to emulate Intel x86-64 on ARM64 at reasonable speed so that legacy software will continue to function. But we haven't seen any such technology yet. (That's not to say it's impossible, just not in view at this time.)
2. Developers will instantly lose their ability to virtualize x86-64 hardware. No more Docker, no more Windows virtualization. A lot of people, particularly developers, who use the Mac today will lose significant functionality.
3. Thunderbolt is an Intel technology and only works with the x86-64 architecture. Apple will have to come up with some viable replacement for it.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIntel donated thunderbolt to the usb-if. Usb4 will be thunderbolt.
- jhbadger 7y agoApple has a long history of doing this, though. The PPC-X86 was actually the second processor migration of the Mac. The first was in the early 90s when Apple moved from the Motorola 68K series to the PPC.
- kalleboo 7y ago1. Doesn't Microsoft have this technology? I haven't seen any first hand reports/benchmarks but what I've heard is that it's tolerable (taking into account how pokey all the non-Apple ARM chips are). And if Apple are making their own chips, I wonder if they could do something to improve emulation performance (special instructions, separate cache etc) 2. From our perspective this is the deal breaker, but the question is how much Apple cares about us. 3. Intel has said they're opening Thunderbolt since the start, they finally donated it to the USB IF and supposedly you're seeing it on some AMD-chip motherboards now
- solarkraft 7y ago1. Speed is not all that important, as long as the software remains usable for the time it takes for the developer to recompile (in most cases) or move over their software to be fully ARM compatible. This will not take long, since Apple users are notorious complainers and developers in the Apple ecosystem used to moving quickly. x86 emulation is already close to a proven technology. Even though it hasn't reached real adoption yet because there is no open source version, there are some commercial offerings for Linux. Microsoft has x86 emulation built into the ARM version of Windows. I have no doubt that Apple could build a version of this as well (they probably already have). 2. With x86 emulation this point is mostly moot, although it will be slower. But then again Windows is also becoming ARM compatible. 3. Thunderbolt 3 is not Intel-exclusive. It does not only work with the x86-64 architecture. It's an open standard.