3 ms·
Agriculture is pretty much the dumbest thing you can do to land (other than simply poisoning it.) It's a process of converting ecosystems into people (and, sin
by carapace 7y ago
Agriculture is pretty much the dumbest thing you can do to land (other than simply poisoning it.) It's a process of converting ecosystems into people (and, since the invention of artificial nitrogen fertilizer, converting oil into people.)
Ecosystems are more productive, so if we imitate Nature with "applied ecology" (such as Permaculture), we can actually create a new kind of civilization. One that generates more healthy soil than it loses.
Toby Hemenway (RIP) gave a talk, "Redesigning Civilization -- with Permaculture"
> Modern agriculture, industry and finance all extract more than they give back, and the Earth is starting to show the strain. How did we get in this mess and what can we do to help our culture get back on track? The ecological design approach known as permaculture offers powerful tools for the design of regenerative, fair ways to provide food, energy, livelihood, and other needs while letting humans share the planet with the rest of nature. This presentation will give you insight into why our culture has become fundamentally unsustainable, and offers ecologically based solutions that can help create a just and sustainable society. This is the sequel to Toby's popular talk, "How Permaculture Can Save Humanity and The Planet, but not Civilization."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6b7zJ-hx_c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6b7zJ-hx_c
- quixoticelixer- 7y agoYeah bro who needs food anyway
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat is nakedly not true at all for yields and shows a massive ignorance of history, trophic layers, ecology, and economics to declare it less productive. Less biodiversity by definition but that is essentially the whole point of agriculture - producing what you want. Permaculture really seems to be the new Lysenkoism. They keep on making grand claims about their sustainability and output and how it is the only sustainable way yet their yields aren't even any better than conventional farming with crop rotation. If you want to preserve nature your best bet is unsexy density - scales better than local and distributed. Even solar and wind which benefit from being spread around are still clustered.
- carapace 7y agoYou haven't had time to watch the video? > Permaculture really seems to be the new Lysenkoism. No need for insults. > That is nakedly not true at all for yields and shows a massive ignorance of history, trophic layers, ecology, and economics to declare it less productive. Yeah, I actually know a lot about this and you are just plain wrong. Agriculture has always been destructive. The masses of people have historically been miserable and malnourished, suffered from regular famines, etc. Applied ecology generates greater yields per acre, and per unit of labor input, than any other system we have tried. It's a new form of civilization.