3 ms·
Is it fair to say Airbus is better at FBW because they have more experience with it?
by dehrmann 7y ago
Is it fair to say Airbus is better at FBW because they have more experience with it?
- orwin 7y agoAnd they have an history with FBW-caused accidents. Especially AF296 killed 3 people when they try to demonstrate the anti-stall capacity of the FBW during an airshow. Airbus modified the way the fbw control reclamation worked after this. After the Rio-Paris accident (forgot the flight name, it was AF too), they changed the way the degradation worked wehn sensor fails (i think now 3 different mode exists, and information is more visible). Those incident killed people, and there is a chance that the first one was actually caused only by the manufacturer (the second one was 99% the pilot though, the remaining 1% was: better information, better sims and better gradation so that even new, tired pilot can't make this kind of mistake).
- thatswrong0 7y agoThat AF 296 was caused by FBW is more of a conspiracy theory than anything else. Even if it were true that the pilots applied TOGA power a few seconds before the investigation concluded they did, they were still flying way too low with engines at idle. Poor planning, pilot error.
- PaulHoule 7y agoThere have been plenty of accidents involving the failure of old analog control systems too. FBW adds cyber-related failure modes, but it is hard if not impossible to make the traditional hydraulics, strings, springs and pully-based systems resilient against failures since the number of things you have to duplicate explodes exponentially.
- PaulHoule 7y agoBoeing's FBW is about as good as Airbus's FBW. One big difference is that the pilot and co-pilot's yokes on a Boeing plane are mechanically connected to each other so they share the feelings. Airbus uses "sidestick" controllers which aren't quite as nice but are perfectly adequate. Boeing, however, uses FBW only on their large aircraft, but not on the 737, which is their most flown aircraft. All Airbus planes are FBW, because their competitor to the 737, the A320 is FBW.