5 ms·
The most interesting part there, to me, was the currently first comment by poke111. I'll reproduce it here: Imagine the government found some way to fund itsel
by petercooper 16y ago
The most interesting part there, to me, was the currently first comment by poke111. I'll reproduce it here:
Imagine the government found some way to fund itself without any tax revenue at all. Say, a giant reserve of natural resources were found on federal land, and now tax revenue isn't needed to fund the government. As a libertarian-leaning conservative I personally would be delighted to see all federal income tax go to zero. After all, we've always been told that taxes are needed to fund the government. But somehow I think some people would not be happy that even "rich" people wouldn't have to pay taxes anymore.
And here I think is where the real difference lies: libertarian and conservative type people see taxes as a necessary evil. If the government wouldn't need the money, the ideal situation would be zero taxation. But I think liberals tend to see things in the opposite way: Taxes are a way to acheive fairness, and funding the government is a convenient means to that end, in the absense of which they would find a different means.
Conservatives want to set the level of taxation to match their preferred level of spending (at least in theory), and liberals want to set the level of spending to match their preferred level of taxation. The difference is whether taxation is the means or the end.
Any truth to this technically? It feels right to me but I'm neither an economist or much of a politician.
- DanI-S 16y agoI think he's confusing liberalism with socialism.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoThis is a good article by Charles Krauthammer on that topic: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/09/AR2010120904472.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12... The gist is that President Obama really cut a fantastic deal for liberals yet many were still livid because it also contained an extension of the tax cuts. Hence they want to punish the rich above or equal to achieving their own goals. Personally I think the left is a sliding scale that goes from Moderate to Marx. Marx's famous quote "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need" is in line with the comment you quoted and I think people on the far left believe just that. I think the further you get away from the far left on the sliding scale the less that becomes true.
- DanI-S 16y agoPunish the rich? I'm sure for most people it's about reducing the deficit.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoThat's not the question though. The question wasn't "why don't liberals agree with a tax cut for the Rich" (the answer to that question is exactly your point). The question is "why would they be so angry that they'd turn on the most liberal President elected since Carter and perhaps FDR". Or "Why would this deal make people talk about challenging him in the Primary" That anger isn't about reducing the already ballooning deficit. There's something more there (whether that "more" is to punish the rich is debatable)
- DanI-S 16y agoI'd say the anger comes from the following line of thought: "The extremely wealthy are receiving tax cuts which will barely affect their personal quality of life, yet cost 'the rest of us' billions of dollars. That money would have a far higher quality of life impact if spent on welfare or tax cuts for middle/lower income Americans. Our quality of life is being held down for the sake of theirs, when theirs is already far higher."
- 16y ago
- zdw 16y agoI think this line of dialogue is a way to demonize liberals (which is such a loaded/confused term to begin with), or to align traditionally socialist/communist ideas of equality of outcome with them.
- vgbhjnmkl 16y agoConservatives want to reduce government spending - except to defense companies owned by contributors, liberals want to reduce spending except to government employees that vote for them. Both want to cut government waste and will employ as many civil servants as it takes to do this
- bcrescimanno 16y agoNot necessarily; let's not use the term "Conservative" as a synonym for "The Republican Party" and "Liberal" to mean "The Democratic Party." If we look at conservative libertarianism vs liberalism, the comment is pretty spot on; especially in its conclusion as to how both sides view the purpose of taxation.
- skorgu 16y ago> liberals want to set the level of spending to match their preferred level of taxation I've never met a single human being who thinks this way. I'm not denying that such people exist but it seems to be an absurdly broad brush. Edit: thinko.
- petercooper 16y agoPerhaps I have an unusual viewpoint on here but I'm in the UK and there are certainly people who think that way. The disgust for the rich (or even the "well off") held by what are often called "the working classes" is frequently palpable. I've not encountered this disgust of wealthy people to such a level in the US.
- MaysonL 16y agoThis is historically based: caused by the way the upper class and bourgeoisie have treated and regarded the working class in the UK. Read Orwell's accounts of life in the workhouses during the Depression for more insight.
- mikeryan 16y agoThis argument completely ignore economic factors of taxation and instead looks at motivation, which is going to be different on a case by case basis and virtually impossible to "prove". Personally, as a liberal (who, combined with my wife, is in the "rich" tax bracket), I too see taxes as a necessary evil as well but I also see it as a way provide additional support to those in need with respect to social programs. I don't see it as a way to "level the playing field" as claimed, but thats just my motivation as a counterpoint . A Keynesian liberal (and I probably fall in this camp) sees higher taxes as both a way to fund social programs and fuel the economy so good for the community and good for the pocketbook. There's a whole other world of hurt when you look at that "at least in theory" part. Recent history has shown conservatives being very good at lowering taxes but totally inept at the corresponding reduction in spending. Liberals tend to be better at staying true to their higher taxes, higher spending line. I'm a liberal but I can understand the basic conservative, libertarian economic argument (I have issues with libertarian theory but thats another flamewar) and can even see it as, perhaps, a viable model. But if they can't decrease spending while cutting taxes then their model fails completely.
- jbooth 16y agoIn response, I'd say that attributing nefarious motives beyond any policy point is pretty much conceding that you've lost the policy argument.
- aristus 16y agoThere are governments that get most of their revenue from taxing the extraction of natural resources, eg Venezuela or Alberta. But like Venezuela vs Alberta, the outcome is not guaranteed to be good. IMO the danger of a government that doesn't get its funds from the people is that it doesn't really need the people. The leadership only need to maintain their lock on the golden goose, and that can often be done more cheaply with guns than butter. They people become at best a nuisance to be placated, and at worst a rabble to control with fear.