3 ms·
Good question. COnsider: First, PLoS fees are lower and as a nonprofit only have to support operation (no profit). Also as a nonprofit there is some transpar
by gumby 7y ago
Good question. COnsider:
First, PLoS fees are lower and as a nonprofit only have to support operation (no profit). Also as a nonprofit there is some transparency as to where those fees go, so I assume that publishing there really does cost something like $1600.
Second PLoS's fee rules include the sentence "Authors' ability to pay publication fees will never be a consideration in the decision whether to publish."
Elsevier's "unfair advantage" (something we're supposed to look for on HN) or IP is their ownership of journals that acquired renown over decades. Publication in those journals as opposed to others has, depending on your field, tremendous effect on tenure and grant opportunities. It takes a long time to transfer that repetitional benefit to other institutions like PLoS.
That's why physics (with a more fluid tradition of journal bona fides and a wider use of preprints and passing papers around) was the pioneer field for open access and the like while, say, medicinal chemistry has been a laggard in this area. Doesn't mean the researchers want it that way, but those cultural traditions take a while to change.
If UCB and some other high profile institutions (I'm looking at you, MIT!) can declare a policy away from these journals it will provide cover to allow others to do the same.
- titanomachy 7y agoPhysics has always been a pioneer when it comes to information. Didn't physicists basically invent the internet to make collaboration easier? Also I guess some (theoretical) physics/math papers kind of stand on their own. If you proved the Poincaré conjecture, it doesn't matter if you post it in Science or on your WordPress blog: anyone in the field can verify the correctness of your work. Contrast with life science where reproducing work is hard and bona fides count for much more. There's no inherent reason a non-profit can't provide those bona fides just as well, though. I also hope institutions do the right thing here.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> Didn't physicists basically invent the internet to make collaboration easier? You mean the Web? For the Internet, no they didn't. It was created by a US military organization.
- 0815test 7y ago> (I'm looking at you, MIT!) You couldn't choose a worse example than that. MIT famously screwed Aaron Swartz legally over public domain (pre-1923) papers, by baselessly claiming that his access had been "unauthorized" when in fact it was entirely consistent with their own pre-existing policies! They are a bad actor in this whole issue and aren't going to do a thing.
- aj7 7y agoGreatest stain on MIT since Poole and Pyle.
- gumby 7y agoI'm an alum and I agree and I mentioned MIT because I think it should take a stand to atone for that.
- j1vms 7y ago> famously screwed (over) infamously is what you mean, particularly considering "screwed (over)" is very much an understatement in regards to the sombre culmination of that legal case. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#MIT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#MIT