6 ms·
I thought LIFTR was the coolest thing ever. MSRs could have revolutionized power generation... about two decades ago. Solar/Wind/Storage are beating almost eve
by AtlasBarfed 7y ago
I thought LIFTR was the coolest thing ever. MSRs could have revolutionized power generation... about two decades ago.
Solar/Wind/Storage are beating almost everything. Everything they aren't... they will, very soon.
It's possible that MSRs could be scaled down and their liquid nature means that the reactor could simply be replaced on a schedule and the entire old reactor "reprocessed". But the investment won't be there with wind/solar/battery eating everyone's lunch.
And that's IF regulatory was simplified and IF you were able to get enough starting fuel to initiate breeding of the thorium.
- ajross 7y agoThis is exactly the issue. Nuclear simply missed the boat. It couldn't win against coal on a balance sheet and it's surely not going to catch up to renewables now. There's nothing wrong with it. A cheap fission technology would be a good thing. But at this stage literally no one is interesting in throwing money at a technology that is now into its eighth (!) decade of maturity. The low hanging fruit got picked by our grandparents.
- dgudkov 7y ago>It couldn't win against coal on a balance sheet It did win against coal on a balance sheet. It's the environmental concerns that stopped nuclear from proliferation, not the economical.
- wffurr 7y agoAnd the environmental costs for nuclear were internalized by regulation, while the same did not happen for coal. This is still well within the realm of economics.
- twic 7y ago> the environmental costs for nuclear were internalized by regulation, while the same did not happen for coal It very much did happen for coal. That's what this whole global warming business is about.
- jddj 7y agointernalized by regulation would imply that the externalities (eg. Climate change) are effectively factored into the cost of producing power by burning coal due to the cost of complying to imposed regulations. This still isn't the case in most of the world.
- Bluestrike2 7y agoAs far as coal's negative externalities go, carbon emissions and their impact on climate change were only some of the most well-known. There's extensive air and water pollution from both mining and electricity production, with negative health effects for everyone from the miners who mine the coal to those living near the power plants themselves. Mining operations can also have pretty significant environmental impacts in addition to the pollution. Fossil-fuel power plants result in thousands of premature deaths each year, millions of lost workdays, and billions in annual healthcare spending.[0][1][2] And estimates are difficult, so it's easy to undervalue their costs; for C02 emissions, for example, more evidence in recent years suggests that we're drastically underestimating the social and economic damages of carbon emissions.[3] Very, very few of these consequences have ever been priced into coal-fired power production; for decades, it's been a de facto subsidy. And while we're seeing some shifts needed to lower emissions to fight climate change, many of the identified externalities still aren't priced in. Nuclear energy never received that kind of benefit of the doubt, or the sort of friendly regulatory capture that let society ignore many of its own negative externalities and risks. 0. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/graphic-science-health-care-burden-of-fossil-fuels/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/graphic-science-h... 1. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-human-cost-of-energy/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-human-cost-of... 2. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0156308 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=info%3Adoi%2F10... 3. https://news.stanford.edu/2015/01/12/emissions-social-costs-011215/ https://news.stanford.edu/2015/01/12/emissions-social-costs-...
- kragen 7y agoI agree. I posted detailed calculations arguing this point of view a week ago in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20365309 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20365309.
- remontoire 7y agoI was very disappointed, expecting you to show something about storage costs, but you just handwave that part, even though you go into very specific numbers and extrapolation for the actual pv's. May I suggest this is a major blindspot and probably where it completely falls down?
- kragen 7y agoI don't know enough about storage costs to calculate them well, although several recent low-priced PV power-purchase agreements have included storage components, including the one we're talking about here. I look forward to seeing your calculations!
- alex_young 7y agoPerhaps this is hard to calculate because it's unbounded? Typically: Known costs for (anything) < ( some storage cost * forever ) Maybe there's something wrong with my math?
- kragen 7y agoWell, sure, storage costs depend in part on how long you have to store the energy, and how often. But surely someone has computed some kind of curve about how much storage is needed for PV to displace increasingly large percentages of peaker and baseload generation, assuming no demand response or other stabilization measures like rolling blackouts?
- pfdietz 7y agoI hope you aren't making the assumption that storage = batteries, then arguing because weeks and months of batteries would be needed, it's impossibly expensive.
- natch 7y agoAlso you can also molten salt with the sun, which is done with way fewer moving parts.
- Mirioron 7y agoRenewables have the problem that the larger the portion of your power that's generated through these renewables, the exponentially more storage you need. It's not a linear relationship, because you can have weather that doesn't cooperate for long periods of time, but the power can't go out. Another issue is that solar and wind aren't really suitable everywhere. The further north you go the less economical solar becomes. A large chunk of Europe sits further north than the US.
- audunw 7y agoWhat’s happening right now is that renewables are being paired with an increasing number of gas power plants. Since gas power can ramp up so quickly they’re a good match until storage can take over. So I think we already have the solution to the problem you’re describing: just pay to maintain a decent amount of the existing gas power plant. If they’re only there for backup, the impact on CO2 emissions will be negligible. You could even make the gas from renewable sources, since in this scenario the cost of the gas itself is negligible compared to cost of keeping the power plant operational. This is incidentally another reason (current) nuclear is a dead end going forward. They’re a bad match for renewables. What we need isn’t more base load, we need more peaker plants, load following plants, backup plants and energy storage. Nuclear isn’t a good solution in any of these categories.
- olejorgenb 7y agoAny increase in base load would reduce the amount of renewable+gas/storage capacity needed, so at worst it's a neutral match for renewables.
- pfdietz 7y agoAnd if people complain about the peakers releasing CO2, they could be converted to use hydrogen. Hydrogen can be produced either from renewables + electrolysis, or from 24/7 plants reforming methane to hydrogen with the carbon sequestered and the hydrogen stored underground for later use.
- Reason077 7y agoSolar is getting so cheap that it's becoming economical in places that might surprise you. The UK sits further north than almost all of the USA (excl. Alaska), and has a climate not exactly known for its abundant sunshine. But large-scale solar farms are now commercially viable here without subsidy. (eg: https://www.clevehillsolar.com https://www.clevehillsolar.com)
- ivanhoe 7y agoThe cost of manufacturing energy is not the only cost when you need to distribute energy on a large scale. Electrical grids are prone to oscillations and having less and bigger power sources makes things a lot easier and more reliable (and that means cheaper also). You can store energy but that again increases complexity of the grid and costs (even super-cheap storage will always be more expensive than no storage). To partially solve this you can concentrate solar into large solar farms, but than you have a problem with the space available, you need a lot of land for that - which is perhaps less of a problems in US or Australia or Africa, but in densely populated areas like Europe (which is also located more to the North and gets less sun) or Japan this creates problems. Also there is an issue that our climate is changing and becoming more and more unstable, which could cause lots of engineering and exploitation problems for renewables (hurricanes, hail storms, unexpected drops in temperature and periods of bad weather like this summer in Europe in May). So I don't think it's (yet) all that certain which is the best way to go long-term, and IMHO the clear win of renewables is more a picture painted by media than a solid science.
- fpoling 7y agoGrids must be very stable because there is no storage at the end points. If electricity consumers are very OK to be without electricity for few hours per day that alone makes grid much cheaper.
- ivanhoe 7y agoIdeal consumer, from the power network point of view, is as constant as possible. Each time you cut off a consumer node it creates harmonics and surges that need to be compensated upstream. Lots of nodes going on and off simultaneously (and they will as the whole parts of the city have the good sun at the same time) are engineering nightmare, existing grids are just not build to handle it, so they'll need to be upgraded, plus the maintenance costs will go up.
- URSpider94 7y agoIf every endpoint has enough storage to go days without being online, then that’s going to distribute a very large cost to the edge of the grid. Part of the reason that we have a power grid is so that we can pool usage and build capacity based on overall statistics, no absolute peak. Additionally, the cost to operate the grid is based upon the size of the distribution network and maximum carrying capacity. If we all build local storage that takes us off the grid 90% of the time, we are still going to have to pay the utility roughly the same amount to maintain the network as we do today. Check your power bill, the generation costs are probably less than half of your monthly total, so the rest is going to come back to you one way or the other.
- sampo 7y ago> Solar/Wind/Storage are beating almost everything. Does anyone have numbers, how fast (yearly added kWh per capita) has any country built solar+wind lately? Or plans to build in the near future? When Sweden built nuclear in 1976–1986, they added 640 kWh per capita per year. Will some country or state beat that record? Source: this figure https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/353/6299/547/F2.large.jpg https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/353/6299/547/F2.l... in this article https://science.sciencemag.org/content/353/6299/547 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/353/6299/547