9 ms·
It's been rather disturbing to see this whole thing play out --- I'm not taking sides here, but Apple "flexing its arms" in this manner shows that it is willing
by userbinator 7y ago
It's been rather disturbing to see this whole thing play out --- I'm not taking sides here, but Apple "flexing its arms" in this manner shows that it is willing and has the power to go beyond policing its App Store and such (which while I do not like, I feel it does have the right to) and involve itself in the affairs of third-party software which it did not originally install. (This is subtly different from updating things like OS files, for example. Some other comments here suggest that the installation of this update is controlled by a setting described as being for system related updates, which a user would expect to leave his/her third-party software alone.)
You may agree with its decision this time, but will you always agree? Apple's wielding of power in this way is likely to attract the attention of groups such as copyright/IP lobbyists, which have an immense desire to have all "non-authorised" files/software erased from all user's machines.
As the saying goes, "two wrongs don't make a right".
In any case, the idea of the OS/platform vendor meddling with third-party software that it doesn't like just feels wrong. I know Apple has historically held tight control over its mobile platforms, but the Mac is meant to be different.
I am not an Apple customer, and I now feel even more reluctant to become one.
- saagarjha 7y ago> Some other comments here suggest that the installation of this update is controlled by a setting described as being for system related updates, which a user would expect to leave his/her third-party software alone. The setting is called "Install system data files and security updates": it's not just system components.
- hunter2_ 7y agoI suppose that depends on the application of the transitive property of English grammar: "Install (system) (data files and security updates)" or "Install (system data files) and (security updates)"
- lonelappde 7y agoRemoving a malware app is installing a system security update.
- hunter2_ 7y agoWould you happen to have any examples outside of this particular update where an OS security update goes and changes something that the OS didn't itself create? Genuinely curious if this is a thing. The word "system" can be scoped any which way (see system of systems) but typically means "part of the OS" in this context.
- johnhart 7y agoMicrosoft does this monthly with the Malicious Software Removal Tool which comes down as part of Windows Update.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- HelloNurse 7y agoIsn't it a security update of a system data file (the malware removal tool configuration)? And it is a security update meant to annihilate a serious malware threat, not to mess with legitimate third party software.
- castis 7y agoHow do you feel about Windows Defender?
- walrus01 7y agoI think the difference here is that apple explicitly does not have an "anti malware" configuration section of the MacOS control panel. There's configuration for automated system updates, which most technical people understand to mean security patches and things that are equivalent to windows hotfixes and servicepacks. I am with the "two wrongs don't make a right" people here. Zoom was reckless and their casual disregard for the initial security report left a very bad taste in my mouth. I'm now highly unlikely to use one of their products willingly. But having Apple initiate unattended removal of software that a person willingly installed on their own workstation machine is also unacceptable, unless they specifically opted in and checked "enable" on something that is very similar to windows defender.
- scarface74 7y agoIf Apple removed a piece of ransomware that you installed would you have a problem with that? Do you think anyone would have installed Zoom if they knew that it would allow any random website to activate your camera?
- walrus01 7y agoNo, and I'm 100% in agreement with the need for it to be removed, it was clearly malware. The question I see is really that Apple doesn't inform its users of the existence of this feature, unless you really search for it. Having something as simple as a functional-equivalent to Windows Defender with its own icon in Control Panel, which is fully enabled in the default operating system installation, should be sufficient. Personally, unless I am specifically aware of the existence and enabled status of some anti-malware application, I don't think it's a good precedent to set for operating system vendors to start silently removing software from peoples' machines. Really all it should take is apple making people aware of the feature's existence.
- rorykoehler 7y agoI'm fine with this. I can always leave Apple and go to Linux if they do something drastic.
- dingaling 7y agoAfter years of pouring thousands of dollars into Apple's coffers you expect that Linux will still be there when you need it... Real principles would involve switching now.
- rorykoehler 7y agoI like Apple products and software. Why would I switch?
- mft_ 7y agoa) (s)he did set out his principle - that (s)he'd switch if Apple did something found personally egregious. Isn't this a sufficiently reasonable principle to follow? b) Linux seems pretty solid, no...? c) I'd argue that a better position might be 'support Linux now, in case you need it in the future'.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoThat's why the only safe OS is indeed Linux. Say, Xubuntu or Fedora. Microsoft has turned the masses into unpaid QA along with extracting their digital wealth. Mac/iOS is a dictatorial wasteland. And Android is adtechs wet dream.
- edoceo 7y agoThere is only Gentoo. So much control, so free. I've had to manually approve licenses to install fonts. A few other trade offs but I control and own all the bits
- lonelappde 7y agoIt's weird to call Linux "safe" because it lacks an optional anti-malware service.
- zaptheimpaler 7y agolol they removed what would be called horrific spyware if it wasn’t made by Zoom and you’re over here on some lofty criticism about possible implications years into the future any OS (and many other apps) that update have the power to do what you’re afraid of, and much more. plus i don’t really see a bright line between system level software and an app when apps can access your video cam, mic, all your files - basically your whole computer.
- heyoni 7y agoThat's it right there. This isn't some gray area, questionable thing like that time they pushed a David Bowie song onto people's iTunes. Remember that? People completely lost their minds over it, and I agree with the sentiment. This isn't third-party anything. No one even knew this was running on their machine and it was demonstrably abusable. Good riddance!
- pvg 7y agoa David Bowie song It was an entire U2 album, a far greater offense.
- bredren 7y agoIt’s blasphemous to equate these artists.
- dclowd9901 7y agoIf it was a Bowie song, people probably would've been happy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoAs one of those people who got really annoyed by it, here's two reasons why: One: On the family iPad we had at the time, we hadn't ever uploaded music to it from the family library, because there wasn't enough space for it all. Whenever anyone opened control panel and accidentally pressed "play", something by U2 (with a not-appropriate-for-little-children album cover) would come on. Two: It was hard to remove that darn album. I couldn't figure out how to get it to go away for the life of me. There's also a fundamental difference between someone adding something like Clippy to your desktop (or a U2 album) and someone saying "you need to fix your stuff or you get kicked out."
- lonelappde 7y agoIf you can't see a difference between deleting files not authorized by the person who bought, installed, and uses the OS, and deleting files not authorized by third parties, I don't know what to tell you.
- Operyl 7y agoDoes Windows not distribute automated tools via Windows Updates from time-to-time to remove Malware _and_ PUP (Potentially Unwanted Programs). I'd argue that the entire Zoom debacle is probably a PUP since a user _uninstalled_ Zoom. And the Zoom web server can _reinstall_ Zoom.
- pvg 7y agoI find it pretty hard to make sense of an argument that frames the removal of trivially exploitable, extremely privacy-violating malware from users' systems as a 'wrong'. The software itself continues to work and was minimally affected, if at all. If quickly intervening to protect your customers' privacy from an egregious threat is wrong, I want all my vendors to be wrong.
- filmgirlcw 7y agoThere are reports there was another RCE that Zoom didn’t/wouldn’t fix. This is what Gatekeeper and the built-in anti-malware engine is suppose to do — remove malware. If you don’t want this feature, you can turn it off, but this is a sane default and a good thing. Apple didn’t flex anything here, it removed malware from its users computers. https://twitter.com/riskybusiness/status/1148824808236318721 https://twitter.com/riskybusiness/status/1148824808236318721
- a13n 7y agoI'm so glad that Apple pushes updates to protect me as a user. Why would I want to be vulnerable to unwanted webcam access? I am an Apple customer, and I now feel even happier about being one.
- Crinus 7y ago> Why would I want to be vulnerable to unwanted webcam access? You shouldn't want. But at the same time i do not think it is a good idea to want Apple to be able to silently remove arbitrary applications they had nothing to do with from your computer. At the very least they should ask the user about it or quarantine the software and inform the user about it. AFAIK this is what Windows Defender does when it finds malicious files.
- oil25 7y agoWell said. Apple loves to flex muscle as a show of force - virtue signaling - when there is some great drama going on. It is terrifying to know they have covert remote root code execution on Macs and iPhones at all times, which they may use without your consent of even knowledge. To me, that is a greater security risk and the reason I will not use their products in favor of open source operating systems only. It saddens me to see how soon people forget Apple participates in PRISM surveillance and has been literally criticized for human rights violations in China, yet invite them to control their computers. I expect people will down-vote this comment, but expressing my disgust for such an authoritarian world view is more important to me, and should be recognized as such by the hacker community. Unfortunately it seems too many of us will sacrifice autonomy and control for the promise of centrally-administered, ominous "security" working in the shadows.
- userbinator 7y agoThe RCE is a given for anything that has automatic updates enabled, and IMHO isn't really the focus of this issue; the main concern is with the scope of what they are allowed to "update", and the legal ramifications thereof. Yes, Apple does have the power to change every bit on your hard disk if you let it. Things like EULAs are supposed to govern to what extent they can use that power.
- oil25 7y ago> Yes, Apple does have the power to change every bit on your hard disk if you let it. Things like EULAs are supposed to govern to what extent they can use that power. Please help me understand this. Where in the EULA or elsewhere have users allowed Apple to remotely install a U2 album, or delete third-party software? What of the fact the EULA itself can change at any time without any posted notice? Or worse, what if Apple is forced or breached to deliver a "security update" which steals personal information or bricks your device? Why is this not a legitimate concern to technical professionals? Or, where is the documentation which at least explains this behavior to put curious minds at ease?
- cush 7y agoThey worked with Zoom to kill the zombie servers which were left behind after Zoom is uninstalled. Not really flexing. Zoom accidentally created malware, and Apple killed it using the same mechanisms they would to kill other malware.
- scarface74 7y agoHow do you “accidentally” write software that can reinstall itself?
- filmgirlcw 7y agoThat’s being pretty kind to a company that bypassed a system setting designed to respect user permissions by writing an always-running insecure web server —- and then refusing to remove that web server and even reinstalling itself when you remove the app. Oh, and a company that defended the insecure web server up until the moment the public outrage exploded and/or the RCE it had willfully ignored was about to be revealed. Oh, and a public company at that, that’s trying to convince businesses to use its product as it primary video chat system. Apple worked with Zoom insofar as Apple cleaned up Zoom’s mess because of Zoom’s poor/unethical software practices.
- askafriend 7y ago> but Apple "flexing its arms" in this manner shows that it is willing and has the power to go beyond policing its App Store and such (which while I do not like, I feel it does have the right to) and involve itself in the affairs of third-party software which it did not originally install. I love this. This is why I'll keep buying Apple.
- itcheeze 7y agoI agree that this entire thing has been disturbing. Leaving behind a web server after you perform an uninstall by Zoom is unbelievable in my opinion. It's not even the fact that there was a vulnerability that makes me angry, it's the idea that you say uninstall, and it knowingly leaves a web server running on your machine. Then, Apple, can push a silent update to simply kill software on your machine which as I understand it wasn't installed through the app store. In this case I may be happy that it's no longer running, but the whole thing is disturbing. Looking at the Security & Privacy settings on my MacBook, I see nothing about running any anti-virus or anti-malware. The closest setting I can see that might be this is under software update, where I have the option to install automatically the system data files and security updates. It's kind of a stretch for me to consider the ability to kill some software Apple might construe as malware at anytime the same thing as a "security update". To me, a security update would patch Apple code which had a vulnerability. Where do I tell Apple to whitelist software in the future they might not like which I've chosen to install not going through the App Store? It's actually news to me that I'm running Anti-X on my Mac, I didn't think I was. Considering the fact that I have to learn new places for all the buttons every time Microsoft gets bored and changes things for the "better" I'm really disappointed. System76 is looking better and better.
- whalesalad 7y agoI was waiting for this comment. > You may agree with its decision this time, but will you always agree? Yes, I will. At least I am not going to lose sleep over it until Apple does abuse that power. I am actually even more happy to be an Apple user knowing that the mothership said hell naw to the naw naw naw naw to this horseshit Zoom has been pulling. If I were Apple, I'd be taking this as a personal slight against my entire user base.
- Crinus 7y ago> At least I am not going to lose sleep over it until Apple does abuse that power. What if Apple abuses that power in ways that not everyone sees as "abuse", yet they are affected by it? The reason you are not already seeing this act as abuse is because you happen to agree with it. What if you didn't agree? What if you were in the minority? What if the reason you where in the minority was that the majority simply didn't had the necessary understanding, experience and/or knowledge to see the issue you see? If something can be abused, it will be abused, there isn't a matter of if, it is a matter of when. And with that in mind it is better to try and avoid being abused than wait for the abuse to happen and see what you can do after the fact.
- ncallaway 7y agoThis same line of reasoning could apply to any Windows or Mac OS update that disables and removes known viruses and malware. Is it appropriate for Microsoft and Apple to push updates that disable and remove those from infected computers? If so, what is the significant difference?
- Crinus 7y agoWindows Defender doesn't remove stuff silently, it shows you notifications, provides control to ignore parts of your computer you know can misfire and you can revert the actions it does.
- userbinator 7y agoNo, and there is no difference, because "infected" in their eyes is not necessarily so in the user's. To give a clear example, AVs have had a long history of false positive problems with things like cracks, keygens, and demoscene productions. Even then, for the most part(? I have not used a persistent AV for a long time) I believe they still tell you first and then let you decide what to do when they find something. I remember many years ago when the first widespread worms for Windows started circulating. All MS did was publish news and a removal tool. It was publicised greatly, but the ultimate choice was left to the owners of the computers, and that's how it should be. All the big tech companies (and even a lot of the smaller ones) are becoming increasingly authoritarian, and that's the most concerning thing about this.
- e40 7y agoGiven that it exposed Apple's users to possible privacy violations and Apple's actions didn't remove any function from Zoom (it operated fine, if installed when this action took place), I'd say I'm happier as an Apple customer.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 7y agoThis sort of mentality means that nontechnical users will never be protected. Someone needs to take an active role in security and this kind of action is part of it. If the app developer is skirting the issue, Apple should be the company to step up. Who else will solve an issue on this scale? The developer should have stepped up and fixed it; instead they chose to dismiss it. Apple made the right call for this instance, especially after the completely insufficient excuses given by Zoom’s CIO.
- innocentoldguy 7y agoI'm actually quite happy to have Apple police its App Store and offer patches that eliminate security holes and malware. There's nothing wrong with Apple trying to make your computer safer and less prone to exploitation, in my opinion.
- diminoten 7y agoJesus Christ, literally do you work for Zoom? This isn't a hot take, this is a fundamental lack of understanding about how macOS, any OS works.
- BinaryIdiot 7y ago> You may agree with its decision this time, but will you always agree? To be honest I'm kinda sick of this argument. Someone brings this argument up _every single time_ a tech company takes action against something malicious. It's a strawman argument at best and at worst a way to give people an out on acting against something that could harm the user. > Apple's wielding of power in this way is likely to attract the attention of groups such as copyright/IP lobbyists, which have an immense desire to have all "non-authorised" files/software erased from all user's machines. This will never happen.
- repolfx 7y agoHow is it a strawman? It's not even a hypothetical, has everyone forgotten already the constant dramas from the era in which Steve Jobs insisted iPhone apps would be banned if they weren't of "very good quality" or whatever the BS wording was? And when he went on his personal moral quest against porn? This seems like overreach to me. It's annoying but it's not like the Zoom app was silently letting people watch me for hours through my webcam without anyone noticing - the app opens a full screen video sharing GUI for goodness sake. Is being joined to a VC without me wanting it when I click a link annoying? Sure. It also serves the attacker no real purpose and thus has never actually happened in the wild. It's also easily fixed. This is a storm in a teacup. Moreover it seems from the last discussion of this on HN that videocall firms do this for a good reason - lots of users get confused by bad Safari permissions GUIs and end up locking themselves out of the app by cancelling the URL open prompt without thinking (which is apparently persistent!) Then they can't join the call. So the only reason these firms are using such a bad workaround to begin with is because Apple screwed up their user interfaces: why is this not on Apple to fix? This appears to send a message to Mac devs that a single troublemaking blogger can cause Apple to kneejerkingly nuke features in your app overnight, regardless of whether you are fixing them, whether they're serious or not or whether it will result in legions of confused and stuck Mac users. Not a great message.
- Crinus 7y ago> Someone brings this argument up _every single time_ a tech company takes action against something malicious. The argument isn't about taking action against something malicious, the argument is about the implications of being able to take that action and what sort of power the company has and if they should have it in light of past abuses (not necessarily but that company, but this is totally irrelevant since companies are made up of people that come and go, they do not have a single "brain" or morality). > This will never happen. You cannot guarantee that.
- michaelmrose 7y agoLogically this suggests not that Apple should stop removing malicious software but perhaps should have user visibility and control over the process. For example if you classify possibly unwanted programs from annoying toolbars to randomware on a scale of 1-3 it might be reasonable to provide a checkbox to allow the user to switch between being warned of a negative program and being given the option to uninstall and having this happen automatically for non critical situations. If the default is to on then 99% of users will be protected. Arguably stuff like ransomware shouldn't be optional lest the malware set the option.
- GeekyBear 7y agoHow well I remember everyone abandoning Microsoft Windows back in the Windows 2000 era when Microsoft first started using Windows Update to push out their monthly Malicious Software Removal Tool, he said sarcastically.
- pwython 7y agoI'll never understand this argument: > Apple's wielding of power in this way... the idea of the OS/platform vendor meddling with third-party software... This is THEIR app store for THEIR operating system. Why in the world would they not be allowed to control their software's features or third party integrations? It reminds me of the ridiculous argument over Windows setting IE as its default browser (and I've been a web dev since the late 90s).
- userbinator 7y agoThis isn't about the App Store, I thought I made that clear in my original comment. While I disagree with the decisions it makes, I think Apple certainly has the right to control its App Store. It reminds me of the ridiculous argument over Windows setting IE as its default browser What do you mean by that? Instead you reminded me that saying "$our_competitor's product is not secure, so we've helpfully removed it and recommend you use $our_equivalent instead" is likely to run afoul of antitrust laws.
- Crinus 7y ago> This is THEIR app store for THEIR operating system. On MY computer. > Why in the world would they not be allowed to control their software's features or third party integrations? Because it is not THEIR computer but MY computer.
- pwython 7y ago> On MY computer. But Apple didn't install macOS on your computer. You chose to use THEIR platform.
- Crinus 7y agoActually they did as macOS comes preinstalled, however this is irrelevant. The computer and the software is running under it must be under the control of the user, otherwise it is the user who is under the control of the software.