25 ms·
Google’s 4k-Word Privacy Policy Is a History of the Internet
- booleandilemma 7y ago“Google’s Policy Google’s policy on our” Was that typo in Google’s original 1999 privacy policy or is that just the New York Times sucking at copying and pasting?
- foldr 7y agoIt's a heading copied without formatting.
- MichaelApproved 7y agoTo clarify, it currently shows it like this: > Google’s Policy Google’s policy on our wholly controlled and operated Internet sites... This is what it should look like formatted: Google’s Policy Google’s policy on our wholly controlled and operated Internet sites...
- groovybits 7y agoThis article is probably intended as a jab at Google for having a Privacy Policy that is absurdly long. However, this is also proof of how far we've come in regulating how personal information is identified and stored. For example, the data comparison between 1999 and 2019 - Simply saying "We collect personal information you provide and clickthrough information" is certainly not enough nowadays. A short and generic policy lends itself to legal abuse, whereas the longer and specific policy tells you exactly what to expect from using the service. Can things be made more clear? Always. But I think this trend is generally for the better.
- donmcronald 7y agoWhat difference does it even make? If they want to collect new info, they just add it to the all encompassing policy for “everything Google” and the opt out option (lose access?) is too detrimental, so I have to agree. They might as well just say “we collect everything.”
- groovybits 7y ago> If they want to collect new info, they just add it to the all encompassing policy for “everything Google” Well the policy is not a binary blob. Google does more than most services by providing a full archive of their policies, as well as a clear-cut comparison of each. https://policies.google.com/privacy/archive https://policies.google.com/privacy/archive FWIW, their most recent comparison is nearly all clarifications, with only one completely new addition.
- Filligree 7y agoThat's exactly the sort of thing the GDPR is meant to address, actually. They shouldn't be able to force opt-in of a policy to access a service that doesn't itself need that information.
- rando444 7y agoIt's not about the collection so much as it is about how they use it. They're going to be making money off you. It's important that you don't have a means to claim retribution.
- danso 7y agoAlso in Google's defense, the services (and ostensible benefits) Google provides in 1999 vs 2019 are so far different in scope that it's not a particularly helpful comparison/contrast. The year of GMail's launch vs 2019 would cut more to the point.
- umeshunni 7y agoI'm really curious about the volume of tech-bashing opinion pieces that the NYTimes (and other corporate media outlets) publish on a daily basis. It's starting to rival the volume of Trump-bashing articles they used to publish at the peak of the US election cycle. Do they have an entire department devoted to churning out this content? Are they hiring freelancers are paying them by the word/click? Do they also pay people to post them and upvote them on reddit/HN etc? In the last day alone (from a search on HN): https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/09/opinion/email-tracking.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/09/opinion/email-tracking.ht... https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/10/opinion/google-privacy-policy.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/10/opinion/googl... https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/10/opinion/internet-democracy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/10/opinion/internet-democrac... https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/09/books/review/the-code-margaret-omara.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/09/books/review/the-code-mar... Most of them are just rehashing the same "big tech bad. media is freedom" spiel.
- jrockway 7y agoThey publish a lot of articles. I thought they were pretty hard on Hillary during the election too.
- lonelappde 7y agoNYTimes writes a lot of articles. The anti tech ones are highlighted here because that's what HN likes.
- throwaway2048 7y agoHN is far more cynical about tech in general than NYT is.
- kabwj 7y agoAlso Facebook. It’s because media companies used to control all the information and opinion. Now they’re losing that power to big tech. They are mad. But ultimately they will lose, for better or for worse.
- donmcronald 7y agoI hate adhesive ToS / Privacy Policies. I think options for data export should have to be sent to the user alongside privacy policy changes. I also think companies should be required to show TOS / Privacy Policies in a modal dialog that’s displayed for the amount of time a fast reader would take to read them. If the average person reads 250 words / min with 70-80% comprehension, that’s 16 minutes for a 4k word policy. Since it’s legalese, I bet it’s 30+ minutes for most people. That’s ridiculous.
- skybrian 7y agoPeople are already pretty annoyed by constant cookie notices. Do you think making these notices more annoying will be popular? Maybe we need to think about alternatives to what is effectively more legal paperwork in daily life?
- pmlnr 7y agoThe cookie notices are the true face of the modern internet: what should have happened is that there should be no cookies until needed - so not until you log in or do "add to cart" and similar things. No cookies at all. Nothing. Instead the notices happened.
- goto11 7y agoYou don't need to show the cookie notice for stuff like login or shopping carts. It is not about cookies, it is about recording, storing and selling tracking information beyond what is necessary for the functionality of the website.
- lotu 7y agocookies are needed to “frequency cap” ads (avoid showing the same ad over and over and over again) and for enforcing user’s ban on specific ads, (yes google’s ad choices this so, if an ad is annoying you can ban it even if you are not being targeted by that ad). While the former is more for the benefit of the advertiser, the publisher also sometimes tries to avoid annoying the user.
- 7y ago
- jsnell 7y agoThe NYT privacy policy [0] is 5.2K words. It contains basically everything that they're criticizing Google for. And a bit more. Apparently NYT will by default sell (sorry, "rent") your name and postal address to direct mail advertisers. > [If you use technology, someone is using your information. We’ll tell you how — and what you can do about it. Sign up for our limited-run newsletter.] Uh-huh. If there's even a trace of irony in that writing, I can't spot it. [0] https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014892108-Privacy-policy?module=inline https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014892108-Priv...
- smnrchrds 7y agoThere is a separation between NYT the corporation and the editorial staff. Just a couple of weeks ago, there was an article in NYT complaining about CCTVs installed in NYT office [0]. Should we now dismiss every article in NYT complaining about surveillance (especially workplace surveillance) as hypocritical and ironic, because if NYT thinks surveillance is bad, why do they do it themselves? Newspapers like NYT are one of the few institutions where workers enjoy a level of freedom from management in doing their work. The other example is tenured professors. We should celebrate this, not mock it. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/01/opinion/surveillance-cameras-work.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/01/opinion/surveillance-came...
- icxa 7y ago> We should celebrate this, not mock it. I don't know what dystopian world you want to live in, but any time I see a company profit off sheer hypocrisy, I am going to call it out and mock it. They can have freedom all they want, but this article is generating clicks and revenues for Parent Corp, so they deserve the scrutiny. This isn't some public service they are providing.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoAsking for curiosity: Given the tenured faculty comparison, should we blame tenured faculty who criticize predatory lending when their university accepts students with the same predatory loans? Or perhaps a more direct comparison: Are tenured faculty at D1 sports universities hypocritical for researching the benefits of more funding going towards education and less towards massive stadiums?
- nothis 7y agoWhatboutism. They at least make a critical article about it and they're also a simple newspaper website, not the heart of the internet.
- jeromegv 7y agoIndeed, one controls the most expensive property on the internet, their influence is way beyond the NYT.
- mattigames 7y agoSo you think if NYT were the heart of the internet they will actually do better? Nonsense; the reasons NYT does it at their scale and Google does it at their scale is the same.
- product50 7y agoCan we just automatically flag posts which mentioned "whataboutism"? THey are utterly ignorant and add nothing to the conversation - like this one.
- dang 7y agoCanned arguments like "whataboutism" break the site guideline against shallow dismissals and also the one about calling names in arguments. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0&query=by:dang%20whataboutism https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20404173 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20404173 and marked it off-topic.
- IronWolve 7y ago(recap) 1999 - we collect 4 things 2019 - we collect everything about you
- vntok 7y agoThis is very disingenuous. How about: 1999 - we do 1 service 2019 - we do 100s of services
- Drdrdrq 7y agoSo, under GDPR and as EU citizen, can I get Google to erase all my data if I steer clear of their services? I would really love it if I could, though I'm afraid they would rather pay fines than remove my data.
- lrem 7y agoI don't know the user interface, but some four years ago, when I worked on one of the most important databases in ads, we've had a bunch of business requests preempted by preparing for compliance with the upcoming EU privacy law (we didn't even know its name back then, only that we'll need a way to erase all data about a user on a short notice). I would be rather surprised if all that investment was wasted.
- saltminer 7y agoI believe you can do this without being an EU citizen: https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/7660719?hl=en&dark=1 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/7660719?hl=en&dar...
- lotu 7y agoGDPR fines are up to 4% of global revenue. Do you honestly believe that Google is willing to risk literally Billions of dollars to hold on to your data? It just plain is not worth it so few people ever ask for data to be deleted it costs more to implement the data deletion code than is lost via less good ad targeting.
- Havoc 7y agoDoes anyone actually read privacy policies? My default assumption is that they're all out to f me on this front & it's not like you actually have a choice in the modern world. If it's 4k long then I guess they just needed lots of noise to hide the crux of it.
- dwyerm 7y agoI do. If nothing else, I look for a binding arbitration opt-out, so I can engage that before whatever time period expires.
- Havoc 7y ago>binding arbitration opt-out Fair point. That does assume same legal jurisdiction though. Practically I'm not in the same jurisdiction as any of these websites anyway. None of this is legally enforceable unless a party is sufficiently aggrieved to spend a ton on specialist lawyers. Whether or not I clicked on some internet button privacy policy seems a little pointless in that context
- Raphmedia 7y agoThis reminds me of Pokemon Go forced arbitration opt-out clause that made the news and trended a while back. "The Go terms do include an opt-out provision for people who don’t want to give up their rights. However, you must opt out within 30 days of first agreeing to the Terms of Service. Luckily, many Pokémon Go users have only downloaded and activated the app in the last week, meaning they are still within that timeframe. To Opt Out: Send an email ASAP (before the 30 days have passed) to termsofservice@nianticlabs.com with “Arbitration Opt-out Notice” in the subject line and a clear declaration that you are opting out of the arbitration clause in the Pokémon Go terms of service." https://consumerist.com/2016/07/14/pokemon-go-strips-users-of-their-legal-rights-heres-how-to-opt-out/#more-10247511 https://consumerist.com/2016/07/14/pokemon-go-strips-users-o...
- throwaway2048 7y agoThis is America in 2019, where even toy games on phones subvert your right to legal process...
- Zenst 7y agoI much prefer the retro resolution of 3 words "Do no evil", we're now up to 4k resolution of words, soon we will have 8k resolution of words. Maybe there is some new moore's law in EULA and Privacy Policies as they keep getting larger and larger, when will we reach peak, as there are published books out there with less words.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- flycaliguy 7y agoAny company that has to tell itself not to be evil should be a red flag.
- UweSchmidt 7y agoThe simple idea of presenting users with a text like this is madness. You know I won't read it, you know most people couldn't process or understand it if they tried, you want consent and agreements through a popup in the browser yet you know damn well that it is not an agreement at all. To anyone who does this, who presents complicated privacy guidelines, EULAs in all-caps, insane cookie opt-out checkboxes, please have a hard look in the mirror. Think of a real-world analogy for the kind of roadblocks and contraptions you are building, how you are misleading and exposing your fellow humans. Thanks.
- petilon 7y agoOn a somewhat related topic: Google changed gmail URL to mail.google.com from gmail.com. I think this is for easier tracking of users--it is easier to set cookies that are shared by all Google apps and sites.
- ehsankia 7y agoYesterday, some editor at Google accidentally used "4,000" instead of 4K in their Prime/Chromecast presser, and now today whoever submitted this replaced 4,000 with 4K. Was that a subtle joke?