8 ms·
Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University System Pleads for Lifeline
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoPerhaps this makes me a terrible person, but I sometimes half hope to see things like this go through. The people of Alaska asked for this, and it will be interesting to see if they like getting what they asked for. The main reason it's only "half-hope" rather than fully hoping is that the damage from this will still affect people who didn't vote in favor of it. Those kids at the university deserve a better education than they'll get presuming the cut is allowed to stand. Alternately, if I'm wrong about the value of austerity, and these deep cuts do allow the economy of Alaska to grow, that would also be interesting to learn. Previous recent experiments in this approach, particularly Kansas', don't seem to encourage much hope. But I'd be a fool to believe that you can take budgetary changes and trailing economic results in isolation. The system is far more complicated than that.
- pavel_lishin 7y ago> The people of Alaska asked for this Well, kind of. I know this is more of a meta-question about government and democracy, etc., but this was a unilateral action by one elected official: > Gov. Mike J. Dunleavy shocked the state last month by using a veto to cut much deeper, taking away $130 million more from the system that gave him his master’s degree.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoIf you vote for a budget hawk, he wins, and then he does budget hawk things, in my book, that's getting what you asked for. It's true that you don't get to choose the exact shape of what you are getting, but you do get to choose the general direction. The people know or should know that, and vote accordingly. It would be different if, for example, they voted for a tax and spend Democrat and then, when elected, that official had made deep budget and tax cuts.
- roywiggins 7y agoThere's "budget hawk things" and there's "burning down the university to make a point." He was offered deep cuts by the University itself: "Mr. Johnsen, fearing that the governor might not stomach the Legislature’s plan, met with Mr. Dunleavy in late May and quietly provided him with a written plan that he regarded as a drastic alternative: A $49 million reduction spread over several years, with significant cuts to personnel and “a reduced capacity to serve our students and our state.”" This was much more than the legislature passed and budget-hawkish enough for him to claim victory. Instead he just went nuclear and zeroed out $130 million with no warning. That's beyond ordinary budget hawkery and into batshit land.
- mikeyouse 7y ago145,000 people voted for this governor, 125,000 people voted for his opponent. Now all of those people are going to be impacted by these huge cuts to the university system. "They voted for this" ignores that many people voted against it and will be harmed nonetheless.
- mcguire 7y agoOn the other hand, the 230,000 that didn't vote....
- magduf 7y agoSorry, but that's how democracy works. Do you have any suggestions for a political system that somehow lets a minority of voters get the executive they want while the majority simultaneously gets the executive they want? It just isn't feasible to have different executives, with different agendas and budgetary goals, running the same region. Maybe if the two groups of people want to move to separate sides of the state and split the state, they could be happy, but that's not realistic; most likely the two different groups of voters are all living among each other.
- javagram 7y agoThey elected him based on his promise to massively increase their dividend payments, major cuts were baked in from the beginning.
- mcguire 7y agoWill he get re-elected?
- bunnyrooroo 7y agoHe is just in his first year of office. 3 more years after this... yay!....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hedora 7y agoOn problem with saying “that red state asked for it; let them see how they like it when their kids are starving on the streets (since they will also vote against welfare)” is that the US counts votes in a way that means, as more people flee your conservative hell-hole to find work, the remaining people’s votes count more and more. Demographic projections say that the senate will be controlled by < 20% of the US population later this century. Make no mistake about it, western democracy (and our economy / way of life) is under attack by an increasingly fringe minority.
- agarden 7y agoYou talk as if this were an unforeseen consequence of the way our legislature is set up. It is not. Giving the people who live in sparsely populated areas an equal voice with those who live in densely populated areas is the whole point of the Senate. It was designed to work this way and it is doing exactly what it was meant to do.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIronically enough, rural areas in Alaska vote blue and its the urban areas that vote red. So in this case it’s the urban area majority imposing their will on the less dense areas.
- bunnyrooroo 7y agoYou realize that 90% of the population essentially lives in three towns in Alaska right? Ha! Imposing their will?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoYes, and they are white (like my Ketchikan born/raised mom), while the Aleuts who we took the land and the resources from in the first place live in small villages and towns. At any rate, it is just ironic how rural over representation is a right to be granted only when it’s red.
- 7y ago
- velcrovan 7y agoWhether or not this is a good strategy depends on how much damage will be caused and whether the subject is likely to actually make the connection between their choice and the harm it caused. A parenting analogy may be in order. Once I stopped my then 2yr old from walking over some broken glass, to her loud objection. It would have been stupid to allow even such impermanent injuries as bloody cuts on her feet in order to "teach her a lesson" that she would not actually have learned. In today’s economy, selling your university system for scrap is a horribly damaging move even for a well-populated state with a diverse economy. In Alaska it could be fatal.
- magduf 7y agoThe problem with your parenting analogy is that we live under democratic systems, where the voters get to choose how to run things (indirectly, by electing representatives). The voters are all adults. If they want to do something utterly stupid, who's supposed to step in and stop them? Any person doing so would be acting in an anti-democratic manner; usually we deride such systems of government as "authoritarian". So unless there's some benevolent aliens that you're counting on to step in and save us from ourselves, it comes down to democracy vs. authoritarianism: do we let the voters choose to shoot themselves in the foot, or do we give all the power to some person or elite cabal and let them do what they think is best? I do agree that ruining your state university system is a bad move long-term, but if that's what the voters want, if you support democracy, you have to give it to them.
- velcrovan 7y agoA representative democracy, which is what we have, is a good middle ground. If the governor had campaigned on gutting the university in particular to achieve his goal, rather than on a vague promise of "more $" I might be more inclined to agree with you. As it is I think the responsible thing to do is for the legislature to override him on this if possible until the next election.
- magduf 7y agoHow exactly did the voters think the governor was going to make "more $"? Create it out of thin air? The voters got exactly what they voted for, and most likely they voted for legislators with the same views as the governor. You're right though: it is a pretty good middle ground. It results in a state/nation that operates more or less according to the wishes of its citizens. The citizens of Alaska want bigger oil dividends and don't care about university education, so that's exactly what they're getting. Of course, this doesn't mean the citizens are getting what's best for them, but they're getting what they think is best, and if that means disaster for them in the future, it's their own fault.
- jccalhoun 7y agoThe problem is that the people who voted for this are adults, not the children who aren't old enough to vote but are the ones getting screwed by this.
- jrumbut 7y agoUnfortunately these institutions take a long time to build and a short time to destroy. How will we know what changes take place in the health of an individual working in the various dangerous occupations common in Alaska (logging, fishing, oil, and mining) over the course of 10 years. It takes 10 years to find out! How can workers demand payment for the true hazards they face if they don't know the hazards they face? Who benefits from ignorance?
- DamnYuppie 7y agoThe one thing I have not seen mentioned here at all is that a great portion of the cost of Universities is now being consumed by administrative personnel. It is possible that this will force the university to be more cost conscious without a great decrease in the quality of their education offered. I get the sense that the comments here equate a reduction in budget to annihilation of higher education. I find this to be a bit extreme as there needs to be a reasonable conversation about the cost of that education and what resources and personnel are really required to deliver it and are the students/society really getting value for their money at current prices.
- mlevental 7y agothere are two countervailing forces to them "learning their lesson" : memory is short and this fact that you allude >But I'd be a fool to believe that you can take budgetary changes and trailing economic results in isolation. The system is far more complicated than that. is exploited by those with a vested interest to place blame elsewhere
- analog31 7y agoThis would require more detailed analysis. Did the people really ask for it? Does the election system in Alaska result in a government with a connection to public sentiment? I live in a heavily gerrymandered state, so it's not even clear what it means to say that we have an elected government.
- bunnyrooroo 7y agoHuge state, less than a million people, 90% of the population is in 3 towns. Alaska is nothing like the rest of the country, that should be clear.
- willk 7y agoThis feels really short sighted, all for an increased annual payout to residents that won't cover the cost of sending students to higher education.
- surge 7y agoThe way I heard it described, the annual payout will increase, where as that money now goes towards social programs primarily aimed at children and families. So while that money will be in citizen's pockets, it likely won't get spent in a manner that will benefit society long term.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> social programs primarily aimed at children and families > it likely won't get spent in a manner that will benefit society long term. I don't understand how you reconcile these two statements. Social safety nets benefit society long term.
- slowmovintarget 7y ago... the poster you quote was saying the money will go into pockets instead of safety nets and this is likely for the worse. The statements are already reconciled. The phrasing might have been a bit confusing, and this could lead one to think there was a conflict, but this was an agreement post.
- pbreit 7y agoUnpopular opinion: there's probably a lot of fat to be cut and this is possibly the only way to do it. Prediction: The most customer-unfriendly trimming will come first.
- save_ferris 7y agoCutting the budget by 41% just isn't responsible, no matter how you slice it. The governor is explicitly making this cut in order to increase the oil revenue dividend for residents to $3K per year.
- pbreit 7y agoIt wasn't the budget that was cut by 41%, just the government's contribution. There's still tuition, bonds, etc.
- scifi6546 7y agoThat is still a huge cut to UA. The quality of education and research will be severely hurt by that cut. Many of the education programs do not make money and that is fine because they provide an important service to the state. That is creating smart people who work in AK rather than leaving AK forever
- rayiner 7y agoThere is a lot of fat to cut. The US spends almost twice as much per student on tertiary education per student, and about 2.6% of GDP in tertiary education, compared to the OECD average of 1.5%. Not to mention that tertiary education funding is regressive. It tends to help those who are already relatively well off.
- uptown 7y ago"Unpopular opinion: there's probably a lot of fat to be cut and this is possibly the only way to do it." What makes that an opinion? Seems like conjecture more than anything.
- bunnyrooroo 7y agoHello, I actually live in Alaska. I'm quite concerned about how the NY Times portrayed this. While I don't agree with all of the cuts to the University or the budget as a whole, the way this is being portrayed is interesting. If veto holds, and the cuts to the University take effect, Alaska will still spend 3 times as much per student than the average state. Yes, you heard that correct, Alaska will still contribute 3 times as much in state funding, per student, to their college students than the average state in the lower 48. Going to college for in state residents is one of the lowest tuition rates in the nation for a state school. Secondly, it didn't get mentioned that Alaska has one University system. There are an amazing amount of redundancies in the system that could eliminated for greater efficiencies and savings. Lastly, it rarely gets mentioned that the UA system has a huge amount of administrative overhead costs. I attended the UA system and there always seems to be quadruple the administrative staff to actually teaching/research going on. The last thing I would say is that the State legislatures did a very poor job of overspending while oil prices were good and then when the price of oil dropped, boom!, we had a deficit. Better fiscal restraint and spending prior to the price of oil dropping would have saved a lot of his heartache. Not to mention that Alaska is dependent on oil for its current existence and once fossil fuel use is eliminated, this state will lose 75% of its residents. Just my two cents.
- doctorpangloss 7y agoAnother interpretation of your exact data is that this great amount of funding paid off, it educated you and attracted talented people to University of Alaska.
- rayiner 7y agoWhat is that an interpretation of the data?
- bunnyrooroo 7y agoUA is a decent University System, but not more than that. In fact, a few months ago, the University of Alaska Anchorage lost accreditation for their teacher program. Yes, you read that correctly. The largest University in Alaska lost their accreditation for a program that is one of the most needed in the state. Getting people to teach in Alaska is a major issue for obvious reasons, and the largest university in the state did such a poor job that they lost their ability to graduate licensed teachers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- joshe 7y agoWorth pointing out that the money from the cuts goes to the Alaska Permanent Fund dividends at about $3,000 per year (instead of $1,600). Each permanent resident gets that every year. It's about a third of the universal basic income proposals ($10,000). Unusual to have such a stark trade off between a progressive program and the ballooning cost of education.
- gnusty_gnurc 7y agoHard to feel bad for any higher-ed institutions nowadays. It's clear that degrees are essentially signaling that's captured by outrageously bloated, rent-seeking institutions. I'm completely sympathetic to the idealism that colleges are vital institutions of education, but there's something systemically wrong with college price, criminally so, and the issue isn't just "we're not spending enough."
- scifi6546 7y agoUA is nothing like a corporation it is tied to the state. Yes it has quite a bit of waste but fundamentally the institutions goal is to do research and to educate
- DuskStar 7y agoFundamentally the goal of UA is to survive and grow, like all other organizations. If research and education furthers that goal, then that's what it'll attempt to do - but if bloat and cost disease further that goal expect to see those too.
- scifi6546 7y agosurprisingly a lot of the people there actually care about science and some people care about teaching
- DuskStar 7y agoOh, of course - but individual goals are not organisational imperatives.
- scifi6546 7y agoNot always. UA is composed of many sub groups. They usually have little to do with each other. Some of these groups are very wastefull and just try to further their existance. But a large portion of the groups are actually concerned with doing things in the real world. I do not want to give specific examples but I have plenty of experience with people that actually want to do good things in the world at UA.