6 ms·
Pre-Prod HoneyComb LX2K 16-Core Mini ITX Arm Workstation Pre-Order for $550
- techntoke 7y agoProbably better to get a new Ryzen processor and motherboard for around the same price.
- jchw 7y agoI love Ryzen but having more mid range machines on CPU architectures that aren’t AMD64 is a huge net gain for everyone.
- alacombe 7y agoHow so ? Brandishing "diversity" as the epitome of progress is close to nonsensical. My workstation requires 4 4k output, both HDMI 2,0 and display-port, and decent OpenGL & other hardware accelelation support. There is no way I'm ever going to get this working out of the box with a fancy architecture. Yes, I'm using proprietary binary-only software, but I my line of work involve CAD+CAM, not re-invent the wheel. Even industrial system I'm working on right now will use standard off-the shelf part (read x86 or rasppi-like sbc) and STANDARD interfaces, because I don't want to lock myself with a vendor. If the main system crash, I can replace it within 12h with a crappy old system and limit downtime.
- jchw 7y agoYou don’t have to buy this new system. You may continue buying whatever hardware you already buy, effective immediately, indefinitely. I didn’t realize my Hacker News comments had power to prevent folks from doing that to begin with! > Brandishing "diversity" as the epitome of progress is close to nonsensical. Man, it really sounds like you have some things you might want to talk about with a therapist. I haven’t even used the word “diversity” that I can find. All I’m suggesting is maybe an instruction set design that has cruft going back decades might actually not be the global maximum of ISA design, and that there might be real gains by trying to apply modern high-performance processor engineering to a different application ISA. That’s it. The market gets to decide if another ISA will hit critical mass. This is not especially likely for the most part, but I definitely support the research. I’m sorry for all of the snark but really, I am blown away at some of the responses this has garnered. I hope you all realize that this machines existence is not a threat to basically anyone.
- whatshisface 7y agoIs that true? It increases the load on developers.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoDiversity of options is a longer-term tradeoff; it is more expensive in the short term, agreed, but it helps keep the industry from getting stuck in a rut. If you like, it keeps us from getting stuck in local minima, albeit at the cost of not getting to use local minima.
- jchw 7y agoNot really, at least until end users are buying ARM machines. But honestly, I think this bit is overplayed. An extreme majority of modern developers writing software that runs on consumer computers are not writing assembly language, and most of them aren’t even writing code in languages that compile AOT to machine code. I’d argue most of the things people use nowadays run in the browser. Desktop isn’t even the hot new thing anymore, mobile is (or, at least, was.) Ans as fate would have it, mobile platforms are dominated by ARM already. Many modern developers already deal with ARM as it is. Going further down the rabbit hole, I’d argue that most applications aren’t even nearly CPU bound and would run just fine with emulation, and nobody will bat an eye. This isn’t really theoretical, considering there exists x86 emulation in ARM Windows 10. And finally, most open source software already runs on many architectures, just look at how many architectures Debian supports. It does increase load on developers, but not to a degree that would make the benefits to competition unworthy. I think a good amount of developers are capable enough to figure out how to cross compile. Architectural splits are not new. Apple did it twice already with Mac, and while there’s no evidence of a third one on the horizon yet, it’s certainly not beyond them. And hell, maybe in the future, developers largely won’t ship architecture-dependent binaries. It is yet to be seen what might happen with WebAssembly and similar technology.
- alacombe 7y agoAnd then you end up requiring a binary-only library, or can't upgrade with the whatever PCI-e device because no drivers and that's the end of the ARM adventure...
- snaky 7y agoWhat's the point to have slower mid-range machine for the same price? Do we need 16-core PIC16 Mini ATX workstation too?
- unixhero 7y agoMaybe you don't, but the world does.
- jchw 7y agoBecause if we don’t have any architecture competition, innovation is limited to what can be done while remaining compatible with IBM PC DOS. There should be competition. The Intel-compatible monoculture is a bug, not a feature. >Do we need 16-core PIC16 Mini ATX workstation too? Now this is just garbage. I doubt you are really ignorant enough to believe modern ARM cores are effectively in the same class as PIC16. But honestly, unless you have a vested interest in the failure of non-Intel-based architectures, then what do you care? Why the intellectual hostility? Why are we asking “why” instead of “why not?” I like ARM. I would buy this machine.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago> Do we need 16-core PIC16 Mini ATX workstation too? If it were usable for my workloads (running *nix, basically), I would absolutely love that. ...I admit, I'm struggling to think how to scale PIC up that much, and IIRC doesn't it use Harvard architecture? That'd be a struggle. But anyways, yes, if we could make it work then that would be beautiful.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- klez 7y ago> IIRC doesn't it use Harvard architecture? Indeed it does. PIC32, on the other hand, doesn't.
- walterbell 7y agoArm desktop is useful for native development builds. Quoting Linus, https://www.extremetech.com/computing/286311-linus-torvalds-claims-arm-wont-win-in-the-server-space https://www.extremetech.com/computing/286311-linus-torvalds-... > ... as long as everybody does cross-development, the platform won’t be all that stable. Or successful ... If you develop on x86, then you’re going to want to deploy on x86 ... It was literally this “develop at home” issue. Thousands of small companies ended up having random small internal workloads where it was easy to just get a random whitebox PC and run some silly small thing on it yourself. Then as the workload expanded, it became a “real server”. And then once that thing expanded, suddenly it made a whole lot of sense to let somebody else manage the hardware and hosting, and the cloud took over.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dpifke 7y agoDoes anyone know if this has a closed coprocessor equivalent to the Intel Management Engine? Or how open the firmware is?
- snazz 7y agoI'm also wondering how the BIOS/UEFI equivalent on these machines works--I really hate how the Raspberry Pi does it (boot partition on SD card contains all data).
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoThis board appears to have some flash onboard, so it's at least better than booting from SD card.
- linux4kix 7y agoThe COM Express 7 module, has SPI-NOR for booting, a second SPI for UEFI secure variable storage, and eMMC for an embedded or recovery OS. Other than that you can boot your distro from eMMC, USB, Sata, or NVME.
- mikedelfino 7y agoCould you please elaborate on how Raspberry Pi's approach is an issue?
- zamadatix 7y agoBetween the official boot firmware not being UEFI compatible and not being onboard it means you have to create a custom installation image and apply it to the disk rather than grabbing a generic installer and going. Also you need to do this for each bootable media you wish to create rather than once (and update each).
- monocasa 7y agoPhilosophically, I actually like the RPi approach (ie. a simple image with device tree) a lot more than ACPI/UEFI. ACPI involves a whole super privileged virtual machine with byte code from god knows where, whereas device tree gives more or less complete control over to the kernel image (sure PSCI is a thing, but that's a lot more defined WRT boundaries to me than ACPI). Basically an ACPI system is a lot easier to bootstrap because you don't need to support all of the little subcomponents of the board explicitly, but once you supprt devoce tree, you support the board in a much more complete and meaningful way, and it's truly your kernel running the show.
- 1-6 7y agoLet the RISC vs CISC wars begin!
- messe 7y agoModern ARM isn't really RISC any more, at least in the original sense of "reduced instruction set".
- neilv 7y agoSounds like the pre-production board is for people who can't wait until a production board with mainline Linux support is available: > The pre-production developer board is fitted with NXP LX2160A pre-production silicon which explains some of the limitations. [...] software features will be limited with the lack of SBSA compliance, UEFI and mainline Linux support. It will support Linux 4.14.x only. BTW, would be nice if the production board had Coreboot support, whether or not it has UEFI by default.
- avuton 7y agoIn the comments, the company responds: "I have asked marketing and sales to update that copy. Those versions are target shipping software, which is actually bumped on the developer board as NXP has just released a 4.19 based BSP. These boards will be fully supported by all mainline support that progresses."
- linux4kix 7y agoCoreboot isn't immediately on our radar. We have both u-boot and EDK2 running, although EDK2 needs more work. Mainline support for the SOC is already making it into mainline and we can boot a mainline kernel with limited functionality. Getting anything into mainline is a process, but we hope to have everything supported by the end of the year.
- als0 7y agoIf they manage to get SBSA support then they will need UEFI by default. Doesn't mean they couldn't use Coreboot as a first stage loader with an EDK2 payload for all the EFI bits.
- UomoNero 7y agoSome advice for a mini-itx (or other format) board, low/mid budget, with more then 1 SATA port? I want to build a NAS to replace my old ReadyNas...
- jerrysievert 7y agothis one has 4 SATA.
- alacombe 7y agoPretty much any mini-itx board (ie. <$100) comes with 4 sata standard.
- UomoNero 7y ago? I can’t find one. Really. I lost my “google kungfu”. Can you give me some direction? I will love you!
- m0zg 7y agoNVIDIA Jetson Xavier is quite usable as a "workstation" as well. I actually develop ARM SIMD code on it. 8 cores + GPU. $700 on Amazon right now.
- aseipp 7y agoHoly hell, they dropped the price on that thing pretty quick! I think you could originally only get the $700 price tag for Xavier via the "developer discount", which only applied to one unit. As a word of note, though, the chips in the Tegra machines are, IME, extremely powerful -- but you're stuck with Linux 4 Tegra and Nvidia's Ubuntu-based distro. At least for the TX1 there was some success getting other distros working (without GPU) but I remember several people running into trouble with the TX2. That may or may not be a dealbreaker for some people (it's a sort of franken-Ubuntu and your only hope for problems are the Nvidia forums) The Solid Run LX2K machine however should (eventually) run any standard AArch64 distro. They also have 16 cores and expandable SATA, as well as an open PCIe 4x slot on these boards, so you can install whatever GPU you like onto it. Not to mention you can plug in a bunch of RAM. You can even buy a slightly different variant of this board with a 100GigE cage on it, still under $1000 USD, which puts it in a very unique position vs any other I've seen. I think the LX2K boards are (now, at this point in time!) a much better sell if you want an actual "arm workstation" as a developer. But the Xavier will be vastly superior if you want a lower power profile (mobile) or if you're doing something like DL inference.
- m0zg 7y agoYou can install whatever GPU you like, but good luck getting aarch64 drivers for it. IMO franken-Ubuntu on Xavier is pretty close to stock, save for CUDA and a few Jetson-specific tools. Certainly close enough to be practical. And you get Pascal-grade CUDA and tensor cores on the Xavier, too. And PyTorch works as well.
- aseipp 7y agoWhy would that be an issue? People already have Mesa and AMDGPU working fine on non-x86 architectures (people have demoed physical POWER, RISC-V and AArch64 machines, all with various Radeon GPUs and the newer AMDGPU stack) and the support gets better and better every release. But it already works fine. Also, Franken-Ubuntu I suppose isn't really my complaint, though I still don't like it. It goes beyond that, though -- the Tegra boards have very custom design that means some things are a huge pain in the ass if you want to even remotely treat them like "normal" computers (for example, want to test that fancy driver you wrote on your AArch64 Tegra machine for that M.2 peripherial? well first you gotta reconfigure the BSP firmware to turn off the power rails to various subcomponents so you can reroute them to things like the M.2 E key slots in the TX2. Gotta disable that USB controller via BSP flash if you want a chip in there, etc etc). It also means I am basically stuck on older kernel versions which may mean features I want to use or develop with are basically off limits (eBPF enhancements, io_uring, etc.) I don't just want to test SIMD; I also need to test actual memory/disk/peripherials, etc. These constraints make perfect sense for Tegra devices -- they are still annoying, for me. I'm not saying the Tegra machines are not nice, or they are not high quality. They absolutely are. If you are just writing code to give the CPUs some work to do, they are great! Flash the default BSP, plug in HDMI, run 'gcc'. They're the highest performing ARM machines for their power profile and size, IME. But the moment you treat them like an "ordinary" computer, all bets are off. These LX2K machines act substantially more like "ordinary" desktop computers, and IMO that's a significant benefit. Now, if you want to do DL inference or GPU programming, I think CUDA is vastly better (for a number of technical reasons). And the Tegra machines would be a good choice! But if you're just writing ARM code and need a desktop, these machines seem perfectly sufficient and can host open source drivers just fine, and will be far more usable in a number of ways vs a Tegra machine. (And also: Nvidia also released some press notes last month that they would be bringing the full CUDA stack to ARM for data-center computing, presumably, including the host driver. So it's possible you may be able to stick a Quadro into these things soon enough and use CUDA to your hearts content!)
- 6thaccount2 7y agoDumb question, but what is this for?
- klez 7y agoNative development on ARM instead of cross-compling, for example. When you reach a certain point down the stack, the machine you develop for/on matters a lot more.
- 6thaccount2 7y agoGotcha
- linux4kix 7y agoWhatever developers want to use it for. It has storage, highspeed networking, 16-cores all in a 32W TDP. We are excited to see what uses the community and our customers come up with for it.
- 6thaccount2 7y agoCould you use it as a desktop computer?
- linux4kix 7y agoAbsolutely. The HoneyComb is targeted as a developer workstation / desktop. The ClearFog CX LX2K is the higher end board aimed at networking and edge compute applications. We are collaborating with most the major distributions making sure we will have the board fully supported as soon as possible.
- 6thaccount2 7y agoThanks for the reply!