4 ms·
One of my favorites is the economy. People constantly talk about there only being a finite number of resources or money. While this is true, there is not a fini
by godelski 7y ago
One of my favorites is the economy. People constantly talk about there only being a finite number of resources or money. While this is true, there is not a finite amount of wealth. The whole point of an economy is to generate new wealth and goods. Inventions and innovations. It is easy to see when you take the historical perspective, that the vast majority of us are living much better off than those a hundred years ago and amazingly better than those of just a thousand years.
- wpietri 7y agoAbsolutely. This is also a huge problem in trade. Trump, for example sees trade in zero-sum terms, where if China and Europe are doing well, that's proof that America is losing.
- jasim 7y agoPeak urban real-estate, regions with good weather, clean air and water, natural resources, biodiversity etc. might be counter points. Unless we achieve fundamental breakthroughs in natural and physical sciences as well as improve basic economic incentive structures that drive corporate behaviour, our current prosperity might be short-lived. It is difficult to confidently predict how any of these things will turn out though - our way of life has undergone massive change in the last five decades than it might have anytime before that, and that pace is only accelerating.
- godelski 7y agoI mean more as a generalization. But as a counter point, we do have AC now. We are better at getting access to clean water. I wouldn't say things are short lived, since the trend has been going on for thousands of years. There's definitely been some bumps in the road (some pretty big ones), but usually they are local and short (in the grand scheme of things).
- Retric 7y agoMoney is a surprisingly poor way of measuring an economy. AC may be cheap as a percentage of GDP, but it can make a huge difference in quality of life. However, if you look at meat production as a share of GDP it significantly reduces the calculated economic growth over very long time periods.
- godelski 7y agoYou're exactly right. We have much better access to AC than our ancestors did.
- belorn 7y agoBased on observations I have the opposite view. A lot of human behavior would not make sense if we only measured resources and not social competition over wealth and status. There is even biological aspects like stress which get effected by the relative status between members of a community. Resources however increases each year with more people enjoying the benefits.
- godelski 7y ago> Resources however increases each year with more people enjoying the benefits. > RESOURCES ... INCREASES EACH YEAR I wouldn't call this a zero nor negative sum game if the game is to gather resources (resources with certain value. Which I think you'd agree that more recent resources have higher value. Like an AC vs a fan).
- belorn 7y ago> I wouldn't call this a zero nor negative sum game if the game is to gather resources yes, that would not be a zero sum game. If the game however is about wealth there are things like status symbols which drain resources but increases perceived relative wealth. Would you agree that status symbols with no intrinsic value are a zero sum game? Could a status symbol for wealth work if everyone had it and could afford it?
- godelski 7y agoI'm not sure why you are shifting to status symbols though. I'm talking about things that make people better off. Money, widgets, access to clean water, and medicine. Sure we can talk about status symbols, but it seems kinda contrived to make your point and not the one that we originally started with or have been discussing. So unless you have a good reason for that digression I'm having a hard time seeing this as anything but a non sequitur.
- belorn 7y agoWhen people use imagery to illustrate wealth, for example in a video or say the Wikipedia article for wealth (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth), we see things like gold. Google images for wealth displays jewelry. Expensive cars. Expensive boats. Expensive mansions. Resources would be food, clean water, shelter, land, gasoline, things which purpose fulfill a specific need. I would say that the first thing, wealth, represent a zero-sum game. The value of such items goes down as more people has them, and thus the status of owning them goes down as more people has the same item. Resources however is not a zero-sum game. The value of clean water will always be high regardless of how many other people have clean water. Money in itself sits between wealth and status. It can be used for both, through at some amount it turn from resource and become just accumulated wealth.
- nerdponx 7y agoWhile this is true, there is not a finite amount of wealth. The whole point of an economy is to generate new wealth and goods. Inventions and innovations. This is a frustrating hand-wave that I've been subjected to for far too long. It's absolutely possible that there is a finite amount of wealth. Moreover, even in an economy with positive growth, if a small fraction of individuals capture a large enough amount of the growth, wealth has effectively been capped for everyone else.
- godelski 7y agoFirst off, I hope it is clear that I am talking long trends and not local ones. I thought this would be apparent with phrases like "just a thousand years." What I'm saying is that the vast majority of people on this planet have better access to food, clean water, medicine, housing, etc than our ancestors did. I mean we have AC and people a few hundred years ago had shade and fans. This does not mean that inequality does not exist, nor does it mean that we've made the world a great place and no longer need to improve. It doesn't even say how much further we need to go, just "things have gotten better for most people." If you read my comment that way I do not think it is deniable, but fact. Interpreting it conversely is frustrating because I clearly stated longer trends, not locality. Second off, inequality can still exist in positive sum games. You can even have players which have gained negative utility. Positive sum just means that the total utility from all the players is positive. Doesn't say anything about exploitation, fairness, etc. Third, I'd argue that part of the presumption of a zero sum game is a problem in capitalism. Since many people see "games" as "if I don't get x then that is equivalent to losing x". Or "if person has x then I can't have x". This is the "we both can't be wealthy" mentality or "you having more wealth than me means you're better than me" mentality. Given your comment I think you'd agree that these are destructive mentalities, but they stem from (among many other things) thinking of things as zero sum games. Not that we all can be winners. That said, I do think systems can be exploited and there can be bad actors. But that's not really what we're talking about here is it? I also want to be clear. When I say there is not a finite amount of wealth I am assuming time exists. At any given instance there is only a finite amount of wealth. As time progresses it either increases or decreases. I am saying that given a large enough time frame (which don't have to be that large) the trend is of increasing wealth/resources.
- biql 7y agoFor humans, yes. For other species, sadly, the last hundred years were most likely devastating. Which make me think that in the end, it is a zero sum game as long as we remain on the same planet and don't recycle our waste.
- Existenceblinks 7y ago> vast majority of us Like 1% or 10%?
- godelski 7y agoNo I mean this [0]. Percent of people that live in extreme poverty is plummeting. Or select most other metrics and you will find similar trends (as in >20 year time spans) [0] https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2013/05/World-Poverty-Since-1820.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2013/05/World-Poverty-Sin...
- JetSpiegel 7y agoThe world population between 1820 and now changed so dramatically, those datapoints are virtually meaningless. Not to mention, they indicate either 1/2 or 1/4 (depending on who's counting) lived with less than $2 per day. Not exactly something to celebrate.
- imtringued 7y agoThe economy does none of those things. What you are talking about is technological progress and money is just one of humanity's greatest inventions out of many.