6 ms·
And yet, somehow, over the last 20 years the crime rate in the US has dropped tremendously. Every single one of those prisoners was convicted of some crime or a
by philwelch 16y ago
And yet, somehow, over the last 20 years the crime rate in the US has dropped tremendously. Every single one of those prisoners was convicted of some crime or another by a comparatively just court system.
The underlying problem--criminality in some American cultures--is difficult and rather unique to the United States. Other rich countries are more culturally homogenous and hence suffer less criminality, though that's changing if you look, for instance, at Scandinavia, where the rate of rapes has risen dramatically as more and more Muslims immigrate there.
- joelmichael 16y agoYou got downvoted because people disagreed with you, not because you didn't elegantly state a perfectly valid perspective.
- jellicle 16y agoHis perspective isn't valid. "The court system" actually consists of many parts: --the legislature who chose to make particular laws --the police who chose to enforce particular laws --the prosecutors who chose to pursue particular cases --the courts who adjudicated the final case Every one of those four groups is biased against particular groups in the U.S.A. Arguing that the courts alone are "comparatively just" is not only false (race is a notable bias in the courts themselves), it neglects all the other factors that are also biased.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 16y agoYou're not telling the whole story though--of course incarceration rates are going to go up when crime goes up (though it's a lagging indicator), but the crime rate has been declining since the 1990's--or "over the last 20 years", as I put it. (2010-1990=20). Simply pointing out that crime rates haven't declined below 1965 levels yet misframes the entire issue.
- _delirium 16y agoSimply picking an arbitrary period of time over which crime rates happen to have declined, and claiming with no evidence that there's a causal factor that happens to nicely match some preconceived notions about "bad cultures", misframes the entire issue imo. If you look at actual studies on the subject, there is little to no scientific evidence that tougher incarceration policies reduce crime. There is about as much evidence that they actually increase crime, in fact, depending on the conditions of incarceration and gang ties that that fosters.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's not exactly "arbitrary", since it corresponds to a number of anti-crime measures specifically aimed at incarcerating criminals for longer periods of time. For instance, 23 states, covering a majority of the American population, passed "three strikes" laws in the 1990's. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_strikes_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_strikes_law For clarification on my thoughts about cultural heterogenity, please look at this comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2036933 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2036933
- _delirium 16y agoThere wasn't a particularly big increase in incarceration rates starting in the 1990s, though. The first big uptick was 1973-1983 or so, and then the pace accelerated in the mid-1980s, actually stabilizing by the late 1990s: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Incarceration_rate_of_inmates_incarcerated_under_state_and_federal_jurisdiction_per_100,000_population_1925-2008.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Incarceration_rate_of_inma... Why would the big increase in incarceration rates starting in the 1970s cause a decrease in crime only in the 1990s?
- philwelch 16y agoIt's an interesting and complicated question. If you look at the graph, the derivative of the incarceration rate actually peaks around 1990, which is still pre-three-strikes. And in retrospect, three-strikes laws wouldn't have increased the incarceration rate very much because someone convicted of three felonies is presumably someone who would have a high frequency of imprisonment anyway, and rounding that frequency to 1 wouldn't have as great an effect. (If you're in and out of prison frequently enough, enough that you're in prison 80% of the time, sentencing you to life only increases the prison population by 0.2 of a person by aggregate.) Although, come to think of it, that might be the answer--a lot of the criminals we first imprisoned in the 70's ended up being recidivists, and cracking down on recidivism in the 90's through longer sentences and three strikes laws decreased crime when the recidivists ended up staying in prison, rather than leaving prison to commit more crimes every few years. The sad part is, this might even apply to people who were unjustly imprisoned for drugs. Someone in prison on drug charges is going to be more likely to get involved in gangs while in prison, and hence become a more dangerous criminal when let out.
- Groxx 16y ago>Every single one of those prisoners was convicted of some crime or another by a comparatively just court system. Like this one?
- philwelch 16y agoThis one isn't a prisoner because he hasn't been convicted. In the US system, there's a distinction between jail (i.e. pre-trial detention) and prison (i.e. post-conviction incarceration).
- Groxx 16y agoTrue, though they both have massive effects on ones life and others' view of them (especially professionally). It's nearly as bad, especially after 7 months.
- Confusion 16y agoAnd yet, somehow, over the last 20 years the crime rate in the US has dropped tremendously. Crime rates in all Western countries have dropped over the last 20 years. More interestingly, the crime rate in the US does not significantly differ from that in other countries[1]. Even taking the statistics from [1] at face value (they are probably skewed by various different definitions for 'crime'), The Netherlands has the same crime rate as the US, yet the prison population is six times smaller (per capita)[2]. Considering the various other Western countries doesn't make that better. Your assertion that the US suffers from --criminality in some American cultures-- seems unfounded. [1] http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_tot_cri_percap-crime-total-crimes-per-capita http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_tot_cri_percap-crime-t... [2] http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_pri_per_cap-crime-prisoners-per-capita http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_pri_per_cap-crime-pris...
- philwelch 16y agoThis is where the lack of controlled experimentation makes the data harder to read. To match the Dutch imprisonment rate, the US would have to release some 84% of its prison population, or in other words, to not have imprisoned those people to begin with. But if we did that, the crime rate would be different because, presumably, at least some of those people would have gone on to commit crimes! I'll readily concede that at least half, maybe 60% of the US prison population is only locked up for drug offenses, and that legalizing drugs by the end of this week won't affect the rates of other crimes[1]. 84% seems high. [1] I couldn't easily find any good breakdown of what all these people are imprisoned for, and would appreciate it. That said, as much I'm in favor of drug legalization, drug possession and sale is still a crime, and it's also a crime in nearly every other country you're comparing crime rates to.
- true_religion 16y agoYou can reduce the prison population by giving out smaller prison terms.
- barrkel 16y agoThat makes your argument circular: you suggest that the US has higher criminality and this justifies the larger prison population; but faced with statistics that show it's not particularly higher, you now suggest the criminality would be higher if the prison population were lower. In other words, the prison population is large because there are more criminal actors; and there are more criminal actors, because there is a large prison population.
- dtf 16y agoYou seem to be saying that if we got rid of all the blacks and muslims we'd have far less crime. Did I misread you?
- philwelch 16y agoYou seem to be accusing me of racism rather than offering a counterargument. Did I misread you? Cultural homogeneity and its effects on crime transcend race. European immigration to the US during the 19th and 20th centuries were linked to crime as well. Usually, the dominant cultures in a heterogenous society will exclude and oppress minority populations, which leads to poverty and desperation. The problem really is cultural heterogeneity, not anybody's race. Acceptance of minority populations into the greater culture solves the problem much more effectively than any kind of antagonistic separatism, that's for sure. Plus, assuming cultural heterogeneity leads to higher crime doesn't necessarily mean it's a bad idea. I happen to think the benefits of a diverse, heterogenous society outweigh the costs. That doesn't mean the costs don't exist. EDIT: In particular, check this link out: http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_tot_cri_percap-crime-total-crimes-per-capita http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_tot_cri_percap-crime-t... There are countries with majority Muslim populations with lower-than-average crime rates--check out Turkey and Tunisia, as do countries with majority black populations--check out Zambia, Zimbabwe, and Jamaica. Obviously Islam, or blackness, isn't the problem here.
- mda 16y agoYou said this: "if you look, for instance, at Scandinavia, where the rate of rapes has risen dramatically as more and more Muslims immigrate there." making correlation with increased rape rates with "muslim" immigrants and then said "Obviously Islam, or blackness, isn't the problem here" How is this consistent? Do you have any single evidence your blanket group of "muslim immigrants" caused the increase in rape? Make your mind please.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's consistent in that, apparently, the crime rates in Muslim countries continue to be low. http://www.aftenposten.no/english/local/article190268.ece http://www.aftenposten.no/english/local/article190268.ece http://centurean2.wordpress.com/2009/09/02/muslim-rape-epidemic-puts-sweden-at-top-of-euro-rape-statistics-peace-in-europe-surrender/ http://centurean2.wordpress.com/2009/09/02/muslim-rape-epide...
- nostrademons 16y agoMany of those crimes are drug crimes, which are only a crime because we've chosen to make them so. It's not all that hard to change a law to make a certain group of people whose habits you dislike criminals.
- shin_lao 16y agoAll crimes are crimes because we decided to make them so.
- derefr 16y agoDepends on your definition of "decide." Some things are crimes because it is in human nature to revile them, and to enforce social mores against them.
- bugsy 16y agoWhat things exactly? Killing people? That is widely supported through ongoing wars, trade embargoes, abortion, and the death penalty. Rape? What we call rape in many states in the USA, an 18 yr old having consensual sex with a 16 yr old, is accepted in other parts of the world. Or let's take Sweden's definition, having consensual sex without a condom. That's not against the law in most places. Pedophilia? Anthropologists claim found that it is common and accepted in Polynesia and other cultures. Cannibalism? Again, supposedly many cultures practice it and consider it an acceptable and beneficial practice. What exactly is universally reviled by human nature? Copraphilia? That's not illegal though.
- derefr 16y agoThe most obvious case is property theft. Everyone feels some sort of base emotional sting when something that they have grown attached to is forcefully taken away from them. This can be generalized to conceptual belongings: pride, control, honor, dignity, etc. can also be "stolen" in various ways. The more serious immoral acts, however, of the kind that leave their subjects unable to emote (whether because they are dead, in a coma, "brainwashed", or whatever else) have to be analyzed from an in-group vs. out-group perspective. Given a "tribal unit", murder by outsiders of the tribe, to insiders in the tribe is universally reviled by tribe members. As we all (except sociopaths) mentally assign ourselves one or more tribes, this is generalizable back to all of humanity.
- baltcode 16y agoOr, there is a problem with the "justice system" and how it deals with minorities, non-white people, immigrants or members of some other less powerful group. One glaring example: http://www.theworld.org/2010/12/06/missouri-court-guatemalan-boy/ http://www.theworld.org/2010/12/06/missouri-court-guatemalan...
- pinchyfingers 16y ago"Comparatively just court system" !? Dude pull your head out of your ass, you're drinking some really dangerous Kool Aid. How was this 17 year old kid treated with any justice? The cops destroyed his private property and ruined his family's life to protect their own power-tripping asses. The core of being American should be to question and challenge authority at every opportunity. It's why we have the First and Second Amendments. It makes me sick that so many Americans are spineless slaves to this dying corrupt government.