6 ms·
Hello, my name is Cole and I can be an asshole. The definition posted of an asshole casts a very wide net making discussion difficult. Diversity is important
by colechristensen 7y ago
Hello, my name is Cole and I can be an asshole.
The definition posted of an asshole casts a very wide net making discussion difficult.
Diversity is important and it isn't just about sex and skin color. People act differently, people have different priorities, confidence varies, life situations outside of work alters behavior as do medical conditions and treatments. Different cultures even in this country value vastly different behaviors.
Not everyone is perfect just how they are but everyone doesn't have to act the same way to be acceptable.
Labeling, setting up dichotomies, and othering people can be a much more toxic behavior than being an "asshole".
People with Asperger's or otherwise on the autism spectrum can be huge "assholes" by the definitions here. Does autism make you unemployable?
Behavior issues in the workplace and out are much more nuanced than this.
It is good to be pushed out of your comfort zone in both needing to develop thicker skin AND showing empathy to others' sensibilities but within bounds.
Sorting people into bins: assholes and victims, is problematic.
When it comes down to it, not everyone must work well together. Just like there is a wide diversity of people's dispositions there can be a wide variety of team dispositions. Not fitting into a particular group doesn't have to make a 'wrong' person, it can just mean the best fit is somewhere else. Become a big enough organization and it is something you will have to face.
- wawhal 7y ago> Not everyone is perfect just how they are but everyone doesn't have to act the same way to be acceptable. This undermines the very concept of "law and order". There "must" be restrictions on behaviour if it is intrusive, offensive, inflamatory, indecent etc. I think it is okay to have an enforced "code of conduct" to prevent assholery.
- colechristensen 7y agoLaw and order is not equivalent to government enforced conformity.
- cousin_it 7y agoI mostly like law and order, but: 1) Laws are supposed to be precise. If there was a law against "stirring shit and troublemaking" as the OP suggests, it would be applied mostly against those who are out of favor. 2) Laws presume that the accused person is innocent and give them a say in defense. Good luck with that if you're accused of a code of conduct violation.
- treerock 7y agoSlight quibble. Laws can be broad and imprecise and some might argue, trivial. e.g. > To prove a breach of the peace, the most important things to prove are that someone was alarmed, annoyed or disturbed by the incident.[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_the_peace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_the_peace [edit] These are probably bad laws, but are common enough.
- donatj 7y agoI generally find law and order assholes the most disruptive of assholes. Here we are getting work done and this asshole starts making a federal case out of someone wearing shorts on a Thursday?
- jlg23 7y ago> People with Asperger's or otherwise on the autism spectrum can be huge "assholes" by the definitions here. Does autism make you unemployable? Those "smart assholes" with Asperger I know can be very nice people if being nice is rewarded. But it requires a conscious effort on their side (and fair feedback from those around them). If being an asshole is tolerated, they take the easy route of not caring. > It is good to be pushed out of your comfort zone in both needing to develop thicker skin AND showing empathy to others' sensibilities but within bounds. Maybe. But in my experience, most of the "victims" usually don't speak up. It is those with an already much thicker skin, the ones that don't shy away from a confrontation, who bring up the topic. EDIT: I overall object to the label of "asshole". Insulting people with toxic behavior is toxic in itself.
- mbubb 7y agowrt your edit - we can all be assholes, not-so-benevolent dictators of this and that. recognizing it as such is not toxic.
- johnchristopher 7y ago> People with Asperger's or otherwise on the autism spectrum can be huge "assholes" by the definitions here. Does autism make you unemployable? It's my understanding that on average it's harder to get a job and some kind of jobs look out of reach. Also, is the population ratio of Asperger/autism such that the definition of asshole should be reworded ?
- colechristensen 7y agoThe autism spectrum is wide and diagnosis isn't an exact science. ~1-3% or 1:30 to 1:100 rates are at the right scale. Autism is easy to point at to make one think the response to "assholes" should be thought through more carefully. There are many others, not always as easy.
- johnchristopher 7y agoI see. Yet, I am not ready to believe every asshole I met were undiagnosed people with autism or Asperger though. It's way over 1:100 or even 1:30. Also, I believe assholes have a different set of intentions than people with autism or Asperger but don't quote me on that. I had a client who told me once he could head butt me without feeling bad about it, his doctor explained to him he was schizophrenic and that was why (yeah, right, I know). He was an asshole. Also, I header years later he ended up shot in the head and his body was found in the forest. Even so, one of my older bestie (whose mom was schizophrenic) told me schizophrenic people can be asshole too if they wish and play the game, beyond what could usually comes with the symptoms. All of this is juste anecdotes though. > Autism is easy to point at to make one think the response to "assholes" should be thought through more carefully. There are many others, not always as easy. I believe that whether people are assholes because they are assholes or autism/asp. (and I don't believe every autistic person or asperger is automatically an asshole, quite the contrary) it's up the the other side to find the resilience/methods to deal with it in a respectful way (respect for oneself and the other). Don't put fire on it, whatever the origin.
- harryf 7y ago> Sorting people into bins: assholes and victims, is problematic. This is true of anything subjective. There are people (intentional assholes in this article) who absolutely _are_ assholes because it gives them pleasure - their ego or otherwise gains something from hurting others. Everyone in a company knows who they without needing to go through a labelling process. Ultimately it's a problem for leaders in a company, those that should be caring about the culture, to remove such people. Paul Graham described this long ago here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UacbJ72dluU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UacbJ72dluU (starts at 4m20s) - a leader in YCombinator he makes the judgement calls.
- harryf 7y agoOh and the other thing I didn't see anyone address is teaching "victims" the right Ju-Jitsu for dealing with (intentional) assholes / bullying - the mindset of don't let anyone make you a victim. I had the "good fortune" of having an internship years ago with a tyrant. This person loved publicly shaming the interns, among a whole bunch of other toxic behaviour, continual needling etc. etc. Their life was a mess, marriage falling apart and alcoholic but beating up the interns was this person's way of boosting their ego up again. They were also a master of ducking and deflecting any possible blame. Being on the receiving end of this for a year, I was so upset and frustrated that I vowed never to let it happen to me again. After trying various strategies I found the most effective solution is very simple: get a group of people laugh at the asshole, ideally as a direct response to bullying from them in a group setting. Typically you only need to pull that off once and they will leave you alone from that point on - most bullys are cowards in the face of real resistance. Actually you don't even need to be funny - you just need to do something that can't missed by the group or the bully and creates awkwardness, e.g. a loud, slow clap in response to their comment then if they quiz you on it, you just say "Just giving you a round of applause" I could write a lot more on this, and much of it would be easy to misinterpret in today's PC culture so I won't but, in essence: don't fall into a victim mindset - stand up for yourself.
- mathieuh 7y agoThis is just complete passive aggressiveness... just tell them to piss off (or some variation thereof), no need to do all this weird sarcastic stuff
- harryf 7y agoI found that doesn't always work. Telling certain types of asshole directly telling them to piss off directly results in something like "I have _no idea_ what you're talking about? You're being too sensitive. And I find your rude/aggressive/whatever manner offensive...", all the while grinning slightly. Some even feed on the fact that they got you annoyed enough to confront them. With that comes exploiting the notion of qualifies as acceptable, professional behaviour such as getting emotional in response to bullying or threatening someone with "piss off or else..."
- w1nst0nsm1th 7y agoPsychopath are by definition assholes. They account for 1%-3% of the population. Narcissists are another category of assholes that account for 1% of the population. There is no ambiguity these people create toxic workplace. There is no ambiguity in a harrasment situation.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThis is why i really dislike the diversity-crowd (straw-man here...). The only result were some laws obligating people to explicitly name the minorities of the month. The only proponent of this is the HR department. Nah, not really, but they have to. The diversity crowds achievement was to give corporations more power. If I were belong to a minority, I wouldn't dislike the diversity crowd, I would hate them with unrequited passion. There is a difference between equality and equity. There is also a conflict between equity and freedom. But these are discussion that will never again surface in the next 10 years, because of the diversity crowd. The straw-man I describe are giant assholes in my opinion. And I wouldn't want to have anything to do with them. Because they are also toxic. edit: Further more, I think people defining an allegedly large and epidemic group of people as untenable, are probably assholes. Unbelievable...
- pnutjam 7y agoIt's easy to "imagine" what you would do if you were a minority. Especially when you haven't lived it. Your asking for diversity of behavior, but you seem to expect everyone to respond like they had your experiences and background.
- raxxorrax 7y agoIt is for anyone who has been an outsider in a social setting. This article describes methods to identify certain character traits and isolating them. This is pretty clear cut for anyone who actually has relevant experience.
- gnull 7y ago> It's easy to "imagine" what you would do if you were a minority. Especially when you haven't lived it. A better way to run the argument would be to address the substance of raxxorrax's argument here, for example by pointing out any specific problem with the way he imagines what minorities feel. Instead, you doubted his ability to imagine it, despite you don't know him at all. This is just an ad hominem attack.
- 7y ago
- mbubb 7y agoExcellent reply. I make the joke ot myself "you are always the last to know that you are the asshole". I think there are systemic problems which can cause folks to be 'assholes' against their best attempts to do otherwise. The original article hugely oversimplifies this. (Not a big fan of the Aspbergers exclusion, though - I see this used a lot)
- woodandsteel 7y ago"Hello, my name is Cole and I can be an asshole. The definition posted of an asshole casts a very wide net making discussion difficult." It sounds like you have made a decision to not examine the cases where you have been an asshole and make serious efforts to improve. And a smart organization might decide to get rid of someone like you.