41 ms·
Assholes: A Probing Examination
- jchw 7y agoI really love the euphemisms/double entendres/word play. It definitely makes it more fun to read. One thing I realize as I read this is that, I’ve definitely engaged in certain ‘asshole behaviors’ at times. It’s been a long challenge to become more socially skilled and handle pressure/emotions better, but a lot of bad habits linger, I think. The worst habit of which is definitely complaining about coworkers to other coworkers. Not in a hateful or personal way, but sometimes when I get frustrated by something someone does, I vent to someone unrelated instead of confronting the other person. Another terrible habit that I had in the past was a tendency to respond while still fuming, which never ends well; usually it ends in both sides of an argument escalating while others grab the popcorn. I hope I make enough effort to not be the kind of asshole that needs to be flushed out of an org, but similarly hopefully it’s not just me that is imperfect at the art of not being an asshole.
- rodhilton 7y ago>Another terrible habit that I had in the past was a tendency to respond while still fuming, which never ends well; usually it ends in both sides of an argument escalating while others grab the popcorn. Right there with you and I'm the asshole who wrote this post. I know I have a tendency to want to strike back when I feel struck and I also have a tendency to go way overboard, in that "don't throw the first punch but throw the last" kind of way. Honestly I think everyone has asshole behaviors every now and then, a true asshole doesn't know or doesn't care when they act like a prick. The fact that this is something you're consciously aware of and working on I think means you're fine. One book I might recommend though is 'Nonviolent Communication' by Marshall Rosenberg. It definitely feels a little hippy dippy at times and the skeptical asshole in me occasionally rolls my eyes at it, but I think it's really helped me understand some of my own communication tendencies and given me a lot of tools to help curb my own shit.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoHaven't come across Marshall Rosenberg, will have to look him up when I get a chance. Have you come across Fred Kofman, he has this thing he calls Verbal Aikido, check it out here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O6N9nvk8bvE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O6N9nvk8bvE - he also has some books that fall loosely in to the hippy dippy category while still valuable in my opinion.
- aasasd 7y agoRosenberg also narrates the audiobook version. His delivery is a big relief compared to the usual bravadoish and disconcertingly deranged manner of the self-help or ‘soft skills’ genre. Even though I'm still having trouble with the anecdotal nature of the argument, it's a lot better than e.g. “Don't Sweat The Small Stuff.”
- sokoloff 7y agoI’m giggling more than I probably should at the well-chosen sub-headers in the article.
- keyle 7y agoAlso "Picture unrelated" are unrelentingly cunning.
- pnutjam 7y agoYou can train people technically, but it's hard to unasshole someone.
- lallysingh 7y agoSomeone in authority has to tell them specifically what they're doing wrong and that they have to stop. I've seen people fired when they didn't listen. The improvement to the rest of the company greatly exceeded the loss from that individual. It is a big factor in psychological safety.
- jimmaswell 7y agoI dunno, seems easy enough to give a set of rules to follow in the workplace but as someone who's worked as a college tutor, it can be hard to impossible to get some people up to speed technically.
- pnutjam 7y agoTrue, you can't train anyone, but whether someone is trainable and eager to learn is usually apparent very quickly. It's not always something that comes across in an interview, but usually.
- smelendez 7y agoI think both are hard but often doable! And you can set up processes to limit harm from untrained or malicious people. For some reason this doesn't seem to be widely done when it comes to internal "asshole" behavior. Lots of companies require code reviews before software gets deployed or require two signatures on a company check. But they'll have freeform meetings where anyone can speak next if they manage to grab the "floor" and won't maintain records to prevent someone from claiming undue credit for an accomplishment.
- dboreham 7y agoYou can: it's called CBT, but it's costly and the subject has to want to become less of an asshole.
- 7y ago
- appwiz 7y agoThe last paragraph is pure gold!
- gorbachev 7y agoA+ for creative writing for sure :) Still laughing.
- DonHopkins 7y agoHe forgot to mention the important roll of a long paper trail for cleanly wiping out assholes.
- appwiz 7y agoAlso see "Brilliant Jerks in Engineering[1]" by Brendan Gregg. [1] http://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2017-11-13/brilliant-jerks.html
- kspp 7y agoClickable link: http://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2017-11-13/brilliant-jerks.html http://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2017-11-13/brilliant-jerks.... Saves one second per person, that's like a whole man-day across all the readers.
- klenwell 7y ago> Asshole behavior begets additional asshole behavior from others. Non-assholes are hardened into assholes over time to survive, and a spiral of incivility reigns. I've been infected by this before. Never again. (I prefer to slap up so I ended up getting shown the door.) Before we go through a hiring round with my team nowadays, I like us to review what I've seen approvingly referred to over on Metafilter as The Baboon Article: https://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/13/science/no-time-for-bullies-baboons-retool-their-culture.html https://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/13/science/no-time-for-bulli...
- neilv 7y agoThe end of The Baboon Article: > Dr. Sapolsky has no idea how long the good times will last. ''I confess I'm rooting for the troop to stay like this forever, but I worry about how vulnerable they may be,'' he said. ''All it would take is two or three jerky adolescent males entering at the same time to tilt the balance and destroy the culture.''
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI work in an extremely male dominated industry, and let me tell you... Never underestimate the ability of one or two jerky adolescent males to massively fuck everything up! Oh dear.
- sdrothrock 7y ago> I prefer to slap up so I ended up getting shown the door. What does "slap up" mean?
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI’m guessing throw punches.
- skrebbel 7y agoBeing an asshole to the boss, I think.
- 7y ago
- keyle 7y agoThis writer is brilliant, very tight article. I wish someone would write the news this way, everyday. Life wouldn't be so dark... Because after all, assholes are popping up in the news constantly.
- rodhilton 7y agoThanks!
- true_tuna 7y agoIt’s actually not hard to sniff out assholes. You just ask them about how they resolved a recent conflict and picture yourself on the other side of the story. We had a great net eng candidate who zero of the interview team said they’d want to work with. Otherwise smart and capable, we gave him s hard pass.
- rodhilton 7y agoI mention a question really similar to that in the article itself and yeah, I think that question and similar ones are probably the first tools we reach for... but while I think those might suss out some obvious assholes, or unintentional assholes, I think it's too easy for self-aware or intentional assholes to answer "what they want to hear" and pass the question. I'm definitely glad you sidestepped this for-sure asshole in your interview process but I think the fact that everyone on your team wanted to avoid him or her kind of supports my "only the world's biggest assholes get weeded out this way" theory. That's why what I advocate for instead is to genuinely build a culture where asshole behavior isn't tolerated, and then warn candidates that you've successfully done this and take it seriously. Self-aware assholes will just bullshit through these kinds of questions, but if you can truly impart how seriously you take this sort of thing to them, they'll weed themselves out of your process.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ambicapter 7y agoHe addressed that point in the final paragraph. Any self-aware asshole can make up a convincing story.
- farazbabar 7y agoAs one grows and evolves, one learns to better themselves. A fairly significant number of smart and capable people have been guilty of acting in not so ideal manner when dealing with incompetent or otherwise incompatible people but the answer to questions like "give me an example of an encounter or interaction that did not go as well as it could" is not to sugarcoat or misrepresent, I think part of growing up is to own one's mistakes honestly, recognize them as such and learn from them and if an interviewer believes they can really ferret out liars that are in reality asshole but have ready answers for such question in order to take a hard pass on folks that disclose past mistakes honestly, well, I am not sure I consider it to be the best strategy, but I am still learning things.
- saagarjha 7y agoIf nothing else, I wonder how long it took the author to come up with those section titles and “unrelated” pictures.
- krumpet 7y agoWhat's ironic is...the only people I can think of that I've worked with over the years who exhibit the signs called out in this piece were VP level or higher.
- Bakary 7y agoBeing an asshole or having dark triad traits is often an adaptive and successful behavior in the modern world.
- noitsnot 7y agoThe signs listed of an asshole are pretty easy to spot but try sniffing out the 'hidden', highly-skilled two-faced exec. asshole. They are readily promoted and treat execs. one way and low-level employees another.
- toomanyrichies 7y agoIt makes sense, in a way. Sociopaths are willing to do things normies aren’t, therefore they have more options, therefore they have more paths to success.
- Iv 7y agoUnfortunately, we have plenty of examples of successful companies where toxic behavior is rampant. I agree that firing assholes improves a company's morale and environment, but sadly there is little evidence that it actually help a company's business.
- lallysingh 7y agoHow many people quit because of the asshole? That's the cost.
- rodhilton 7y agoI linked to as much hard evidence as I could but I'll agree that it's a little light. My hunch, just based on my own observation doing this for 20 years, is that an asshole is like a black hole of productivity, draining it from everyone else to such an extent that they're simply not worth having around, and that no matter how Brilliant they are, the rest of the team can figure out their areas of expertise with the morale boost they get after leaving (or drastically changing their behavior, though sometimes the bridges are burned too much for recovery). Again this is mostly anecdotal, from what I've seen teams do when the Resident Jerk was fired or left. I've never in my 20 years as a professional software developer seen a single person leave a team and then see the team immediately fall to pieces because that person really was the critical lynchpin that people thought. I've seen lots of people stick around far, far too long because folks (management usually) were WORRIED that's what was going to happen, but it never actually seems to.
- Iv 7y agoDisclaimer: I am an independent contractor mostly because I fled what I consider structural defects of the corporate world, so a bit biased. Isn't it a matter of management though? Assholes can be productive to a company if you have a good manager doing damage control and sinking time into firewalling the asshole. Given the prevalence of this disease and the abundance of managers, it seems like a good way to increase the hiring pool of a company. As a manager, you want to contain an asshole just enough so that coworkers do not leave, also enough so that the asshole feels they have to make up for their social behavior with additional skill and hard work (which is not hard, they are often competitive). I believe (and that's the reason why I don't want to employ people) that the optimal point for a business is when you maintain your employees on the edge of quitting. Assholes create stress and competition, an environment where projects often strive and individuals wither. All the ethical managers or business starters I have known have been replaced by more assholish versions. This could be anecdotal evidence of course, but I think that assholes are better suited for a corporate world of greed and competition.
- dboreham 7y ago"At least your number two priority"
- eyeball 7y agoHard to solve when asshole number one is the top person in the department.
- signa11 7y agovote with your feet ?
- DonHopkins 7y agoKick them in the ass?
- cheez 7y agoI .. thought I was an asshole. I am a saint... Good article!
- aitchnyu 7y ago> Eyerolling, sighing, or otherwise negative body language... Tersely worded group e-mails that make people feel uncomfortable... Interrupting people who aren’t done talking... I need a dash of these, but I will hate anybody using it all the time.
- epynonymous 7y agoi strongly believe in a diverse workforce, especially in large companies, diverse workforces often times mean better results especially since problems today are even more complicated. having said that, i totally understand and have seen some of the bad behaviors you mentioned like putting people down, insulting others, this can be quite toxic. i'm not saying i condone any of those types of behaviors because i certainly don't, but i think asshole labeling can be quite arbitrary, e.g. someone that's terse and seemingly abrasive may just be more direct/candid, is he/she an asshole? what i'm saying is that bad behaviors should not be condoned, but these individuals definitely have value to companies and can create beautiful work, and we shouldn't reject them based on certain labeling because the labeling is quite frankly discrimination and should equally not be tolerated. one person that particularly stands out in my mind is linus torvalds. asshole? for sure, by almost all counts of your definition of an asshole. given that he's improved lately and has admitted his issues, but he's still an asshole by my books :) would you want anyone else working on linux kernel which requires having a lot of different contributors working in large teams, probably not.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWhen you learn something from a non-asshole you walk away thankful for the mentorship. Sadly, it often doesn't work like that. Frequently, people just feel like "Damn, I'm good!" and give zero credit to the person who was good to them.
- tomerbd 7y agosome times its much more delicate to track: 1. arrogance 2. cynicism its not always the case that the above 2 make an a*e in most cases not but sometimes yes without having the extreme qualities described in article.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoExcellent article. I hope managers read it. The toughest problem I've had w.r.t. assholes was convincing managers that certain people were in fact assholes and they were not essential to the company's survival. Assholes are extremely good at kissing up and shitting down. And managers don't like to hear they've been manipulated.
- drtillberg 7y agoThe a--hole royalty that I've encountered defeat every measure offered in this article precisely because of the effectiveness of their kissing up and sh---ing down strategy. Actively sabotaging literally every decent person they encounter (because the other people don't share their 'culture'), turning every item in their punchlist into a tool of political conquest where the rules are: make your victims look bad by any means possible, and then the kicker-- when they choose to turn on their social skills, expressing a highly superior feeling of confidence and ability to persuasively blame all the other a--holes for their own tyrranical behavior. No, when you get a royal a--hole into a large organization, I really don't have much hope for average managers with typical business training to do anything but watch.
- kazinator 7y agoYou know, maybe "asshole" is just a manifestation of "empowerment". You give people a safe environment in which they feel free to voice what they really think without fearing repercussions, and there you go.
- rodhilton 7y agoI honestly think this kind of hits the nail on the head. The industry (in my opinion) is far too tolerant of asshole behavior for many reasons, and it's basically just created a safe place to be a jerk without any repercussion. I largely wrote up what I did because I'd like to see this change, we should treat rude and annoying behavior the way that most other industries do by making it something we culturally don't accept. The same folks who realized they could be jerks and it wouldn't hurt their careers will simply figure out that now it will and knock it off.
- Lapsa 7y agoAFAIK people tend to exhibit such behavior to comfort themselves and feel safe
- ganzuul 7y agoAround these parts the term 'attitude disability' gets floated once in a while. It doesn't translate very well... but the translation doesn't need the negative connotation it has over here. Nullifying a circle of tit-for-tat takes a lot of energy, and stable blood sugar. Too much short carbs in prefab food is causing all of us all kinds of damage.
- sz4kerto 7y agoAsshole: people who you don't like. Every interaction with others should make you feel good about yourself otherwise the other person is an asshole. You are never an asshole by definition, of course. Maybe a victim, but asshole -- never. Diversity means having people around who think and behave the same way as you do but have different hairdo or different thing between their legs. Introverted or depressed people are assholes, needless to say. Again, the most important thing for you to prioritize is your own good feelings about yourself because everything that's non-assholey in the world is designed to make you feel good. <3
- dingoegret 7y agoFound the asshole
- NoodleIncident 7y agoThere is a straightforward list of specific behaviors early in the article. None of it is defined by how anyone else feels; that's just the effect of someone who engages in that asshole behavior on a regular basis. The next comment down and probably half of the readers are trying to figure out if they're the asshole themselves, so I don't know where you got the idea that "you" are never the asshole. (Sure is great how HN shows me this wonderful comment on top because it happened to be posted 9 minutes before I loaded the comments)
- sz4kerto 7y agoI'm somewhat satirical of course. However: "Here’s a simple test: if someone walks away from another person feeling bad about themselves, they were probably interacting with an asshole." I'll tell you that eg as manager there is no way that some of your conversations won't end with the other person feeling somewhat bad about themselves. You have to fire people. You have to explain that some behavior was clearly wrong. Sometimes you need to explain that despite best efforts the person is just simply not developing quickly enough professionally. That hurts, however you put it (you can do it carefully, sure). Hey, you will need to explain assholes that they're doing the wrong thing. Are you sure you can do this without making them feel bad about themselves? Just be very careful with labeling people. It's usually not a great strategy, especially if you use terms like asshole. Try to be emphatic, understanding. Labeling people is one way of being an asshole.
- adnjoo 7y agowhat if the a-hole is the boss?
- glangdale 7y agoThis article is overly fixated on overt assholery. Much of the worst asshole behavior I've encountered has been done by people who are outwardly polite and high functioning and have often never had a cross word for anyone. I would much rather get a tersely worded group email (ooo) than have to do someone else's job for them. Let's be frank. The #1 asshole thing not mentioned here is (shouting and swearing alert) NOT DOING YOUR FUCKING JOB. This is an immense source of frustration for other people, whether because they have to do the person's job for them, or because the person's failure to do their job creates disasters. In many of the situations I've seen (or, frankly, participated in) where someone is behaving somewhat like an asshole, the root of the situation is that (a) someone isn't doing their actual job in a remotely competent way, (b) that someone isn't doing anything to fix that situation and (c) management doesn't know or care.
- Razengan 7y ago> Much of the worst asshole behavior I've encountered has been done by people who are outwardly polite and high functioning and have often never had a cross word for anyone. Indeed, there are many ways to hurt, belittle and generally make someone feel bad or unwelcome without being blamable for anything.
- Udik 7y ago> the root of the situation is that (a) someone isn't doing their actual job in a remotely competent way Not really. I've worked with several assholes. They were all extremely assertive, and usually also very competent (but I've found also the utterly incompetent ones). The problem is that even if they're right 95% of the time, the 5% of the times they're wrong they force everybody along the wrong path, because their purpose as work is not to get stuff done right, but to assert their status. So talking them out of a bad idea is impossible, and they tend to favour solutions that serve more the purpose of demonstrating their skill than to get good results. (As an aside, since assholery is widespread in software engineering, it is legitimate to wonder how much of the so called "best practices" floating around are just exercises in one-upping each other in a status game- "hey, you write your tests first, but you should really write them first in this obscure DSL that is being promoted by the creator of ... ")
- stakhanov 7y agoTo me, the definition of an asshole is slightly different. An asshole is someone who acts out every social interaction on the principle of "dominate or be dominated". It's the lack of a middle ground that makes an asshole, so that people can't just go into an interaction being each other's peers, and also finish the interaction with being each other's peers, having been nice and respectful towards each other, preserved each other's individual freedoms, and exchanged some information. I agree that assholery has a tendency to spread, and the mechanism in my observation is as follows: You can start out NOT being an asshole. When there is an asshole for you to deal with, you'll realize "All of my interactions with this person end up with this person dominating me." But you don't like being dominated because that's natural (psychological reactance), and bad for your career. So next time you interact with that person you know you have to act on the principle of "dominate or be dominated", i.e. the asshole-principle. Soon enough it becomes a habit, and you may inadvertently behave towards non-assholes as an asshole as well, making you an asshole. Another interesting corollary of this definition of asshole is this: If you perceive a lot of assholes around you, maybe YOU are the asshole. It also explains why you find more assholes as you go up the corporate ladder: Being higher up means you get more opportunity for exhibiting domineering behaviour without repercussions (namely towards your subordinates).
- plutonorm 7y agoThis is why I hate working in a male dominated industry. Been trying to leave for years, but there seems to be no way out :(
- woodandsteel 7y ago>To me, the definition of an asshole is slightly different. An asshole is someone who acts out every social interaction on the principle of "dominate or be dominated". Your definition is complementary to the author's. You are talking about relational motivation, the author about the feelings that are evoked in the person being dominated.
- enriquto 7y agoThis article builds on the premise that a few employees are assholes and none of the managers are. In my experience, the reality is the exact opposite, where all managers (especially those at the higher level) are assholes. In that case, none of the considerations of the article seem to be useful. Yet, it is a fun read, especially the "unrelated" pictures and the colorful language. I am surprised by this sentence: > Formalizing social skills as part of the job description can help with this. This kind of thing leads to a subtle but most damaging form of management assholery, whereby employees are "invited" to participate in social gatherings at expensive places, and are frowned upon if they don't participate.
- HelloNurse 7y agoIf a job description "formalizes social skills" I expect very distressing interviews in which HR idiots are going to judge my personality and my values and an oppressive environment in which, for instance, managers are going to draw a line between disagreeing and having a bad attitude.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 7y agoAt least 10 thousand years of civilization, and we are still trying to figure out each other and ourselves. Why is "Don't be a dick" so hard to codify? All these religions, ethics and philosophical systems, and all this technology, convenience and comforts.. and we still have so much friction in interacting with others of our own species. The best solution we seem to have found is leaving each other alone. I've come to believe that true maturity is the realization that everyone is capable of feeling the same things you feel. But most of us – me included – seem to have "Single Player Syndrome" where we feel that we are the only person capable of feeling what we feel, and everyone else is an NPC with diluted senses and processing capabilities.
- julius_set 7y agoThe major problem is we die, so if we didn’t die then yes those 10,000 years of civilization would help because of the life experiences of the survivors, So: 1.) Not everyone reads history books 2.) We die 3.) Social stats reset at birth, pray you have parents who treat you and other people well The only permanent solution is an evolution of our species where the asshole gene is gone or a collective hive mind
- Razengan 7y agoSome social improvements do propagate across generations. For example, we no longer throw virgins into volcanoes. On the other hand there are also regressions with pockets of civilization reverting to outdated practices here and there, even now.
- C4stor 7y agoMultiple hypothesis I can quickly think of, I wouldn't know which ones are correct or not : - "Don't be a dick" doesn't offer any advantage for one's genome transmission, meaning any genetic base to being a dick will get transmitted no problem. - Being a dick propagates, while not being one doesn't, meaning the society has a whole becomes "dick-ish by default" (much like entropy, with dick-iness) unless this is actively acted on. - Religions, culture, nations, companies... actively encourage people to being dicks to everybody not in their group, to preserve and expand the group, meaning we're actively trained to being dicks by our social environment - Our brains default to "everyone is an enemy unless proven otherwise" , meaning people will tend to be dicks by default. - Not being a dick makes one socially vulnerable, so it's only achievable in very safe contexts and not by default
- deanmoriarty 7y agoI’ve been struggling a little bit with this myself, and while I don’t think it’s been a massive problem for me (yet), I am aware of it. I have a very assertive personality, which has done wonders for my career despite my average technical competency. Managers love to hear from me because I have (and have been told so) good communication skills, specifically the ability to quickly summarize pros and cons of solutions, while keeping extreme fairness in my technical judgements. On top of this, my “fearless” (asshole?) personality makes me treat everyone in the hierarchy (including VPs and upper management) as peers, and I have no problem arguing with them if I feel I have a reasonable technical issue I care about and diverging opinions from theirs. Most of my brilliant coworkers, much more technically talented than me, tend to be more introvert and never “pick an argument with management”, which also means they never get the visibility I get, which results in public praises, financial incentives, and interesting work. I wonder if they perceive me as asshole.
- abyssin 7y agoI can find myself in your description. One thing I conscientiously do in the hope of not being an asshole is using my assertiveness to publicly praise those brilliant introvert coworkers that I feel deserve more recognition than they get.
- ochronus 7y agoMY. GOD. THE. WORDING. 'probing assholes' 'asshole examination' 'sniffing out assholes' I hope it was intentional.
- jotm 7y agoOf course it was, look at the pictures :D It would've been a punnier article if the subject was different... Or if the author wasn't wrong about half of the things (my subjective opinion).
- colechristensen 7y agoHello, my name is Cole and I can be an asshole. The definition posted of an asshole casts a very wide net making discussion difficult. Diversity is important and it isn't just about sex and skin color. People act differently, people have different priorities, confidence varies, life situations outside of work alters behavior as do medical conditions and treatments. Different cultures even in this country value vastly different behaviors. Not everyone is perfect just how they are but everyone doesn't have to act the same way to be acceptable. Labeling, setting up dichotomies, and othering people can be a much more toxic behavior than being an "asshole". People with Asperger's or otherwise on the autism spectrum can be huge "assholes" by the definitions here. Does autism make you unemployable? Behavior issues in the workplace and out are much more nuanced than this. It is good to be pushed out of your comfort zone in both needing to develop thicker skin AND showing empathy to others' sensibilities but within bounds. Sorting people into bins: assholes and victims, is problematic. When it comes down to it, not everyone must work well together. Just like there is a wide diversity of people's dispositions there can be a wide variety of team dispositions. Not fitting into a particular group doesn't have to make a 'wrong' person, it can just mean the best fit is somewhere else. Become a big enough organization and it is something you will have to face.
- wawhal 7y ago> Not everyone is perfect just how they are but everyone doesn't have to act the same way to be acceptable. This undermines the very concept of "law and order". There "must" be restrictions on behaviour if it is intrusive, offensive, inflamatory, indecent etc. I think it is okay to have an enforced "code of conduct" to prevent assholery.
- colechristensen 7y agoLaw and order is not equivalent to government enforced conformity.
- cousin_it 7y agoI mostly like law and order, but: 1) Laws are supposed to be precise. If there was a law against "stirring shit and troublemaking" as the OP suggests, it would be applied mostly against those who are out of favor. 2) Laws presume that the accused person is innocent and give them a say in defense. Good luck with that if you're accused of a code of conduct violation.
- jonathanstrange 7y agoI checked how this test fares in Academia my country (I won't mention its name) and there seems to be a surprising number of assholes here. I'm even suspecting that I might be one. > Insulting or degrading individuals or groups Every boss in my country does this from time to time. -1 > Joking and teasing to belittle others My British colleagues do that, but otherwise it's rare. +1 > Tersely worded group e-mails that make people feel uncomfortable I do that. -1 > Slapping down people of lower status in the company hierarchy Everybody in my country seems to do that, I rarely found any exceptions. (I'm a foreigner and where I come from this is frowned upon.) -1 > Eyerolling, sighing, or otherwise negative body language while others are speaking Every boss in my country does that, even the nice ones! -1 > Ignoring people trying to contribute Every boss does that if they don't want contributions at a time. -1 > Interrupting people who aren’t done talking Extremely common. -1 > Touching or invading personal space Normal for all people in my country. It's in Southern Europe. -1 > Threatening or intimidating confrontations Many bosses do that where I live. I only dream of beating up annoying colleagues. -1 > Publicly calling out and blaming others Habitually done in my country of residence, unless by "others" you mean a boss, then it's not done at all. -1 > Undermining someone’s confidence for asking questions That one is rare. Especially the psychopathic narcissist are always happy to answer questions. +1 > Gossiping about coworkers to other coworkers Everybody I've ever met in Academia has done that. -1 > Cliquey behavior and exclusion Everybody does that in every country and on every conference I've ever been. -1 > Taking credit for the ideas or work of others Our bosses love to do that. Some of them want their name to appear on books they never even read, let alone written. -1 > Stirring shit and troublemaking Sounds what I do when somebody really annoys me or is totally incompetent or just a plain asshole. -1 > Singling people out for uncommon traits they have Yep, everybody does that. We had a guy using unreadable powerpoint colors all the time, wearing bizarre ties in an environment where nobody wears ties, and generally suffering from Asperger so much that he sat down on the farthest table from everyone else to have lunch at international conferences. I liked him, but he was singled out for his behaviour. -1 > Dismissing the opinions and ideas of others without discussion Everybody does that in our institute. X is dismissive of Y's work, Y is dismissive of Z's work, and so on, until the full circle is reached. -1 Thinking about it, we could be a whole institute of assholes according to these criteria. That being said, I personally prefer to work together with a competent asshole rather than with an incompetent nice guy. I'm fine with an arrogant colleague if he has a reason for being arrogant, if there is something behind it. (Admittedly, these people tend to be the least arrogant, but there are exceptions.) Nice incompetent fools in higher positions, on the other hand, infuriate me more than anything else.
- marksweston 7y ago> It may seem “unfair” to toy with the idea of losing the assholes, particularly the unintentional assholes. Since they “don’t know better” it seems almost cruel to let them go simply because they’re making everyone around them miserable, and it somehow feels like a smaller request to have 50 people tolerate one asshole’s behavior than to demand one asshole figure out how to not alienate everyone with whom they interact. Frankly, I think you’d be doing an asshole a favor by losing them, nothing is a better teacher than failure. So….. Once you have successfully labelled someone, you should actively fight any tendency towards empathy with them. Don’t bother worrying about whether their behaviour was intentional. Just kick them out. It’s for their own good. At this point, I’m labelling the author an asshole.
- Hasknewbie 7y agoYes, this article felt like reading the rant of a scientologist about 'suppressive persons'...
- DonHopkins 7y agoYour intolerance of religion has been noted, and will go on your permanent record. ;)
- pavel_lishin 7y agoIt's very nice that the "correct" answer also happens to be the most convenient and easiest one for the author.
- woodandsteel 7y ago>Once you have successfully labelled someone, you should actively fight any tendency towards empathy with them. Don’t bother worrying about whether their behaviour was intentional. Just kick them out. It’s for their own good. That's not what the article said. It said that first you make clear to them their behavior is unacceptable, and if that doesn't work then get after them every time the exhibit asshole behavior, and only if that doesn't work after months of effort, then fire them.
- d--b 7y agoI work for a company where the CEO has specifically implemented a "no-asshole strategy" from the start. He too talked about the "asshole effect" that causes companies to fall apart. Hire one asshole, and everybody eventually turns into an asshole. Results: the company is only nice guys, and it feels so good. Sure we occasionally hire the asshole. But they're rooted out fairly quickly. How to keep assholes at bay: 1. Stay small: Bringing the right people in is more important that shipping that project faster. Fast growing companies all get the asshole disease and then have to cut their arms off. 2. Have a lot of people interview: I had 18 interviews for my job. The company had 25 people.
- wozmirek 7y agoInteresting bit about the 18 interviews. While your company sounds like something really cool, I'd probably not go through all those interviews unless a) they're brief and we move through them quickly (like, in <2 months tops), b) I know about the process in advance so I can prepare and c) I'm paid for my time, starting from after the screening interview. Regarding c) - 18 interviews, each taking at least 30 minutes (screening would be 15 on average but other would make up for it), that's roughly 9 full hours of my very own time, if not more.
- d--b 7y agoI had one quick phone screening, then 2-3 hours on Skype, then they flew me over for a full day of interviews. the whole thing was less than a month.
- fasteo 7y agoOfftopic. Slang for "asshole" in Spanish is "capullo" or "gilipollas". Originally, these words described a dumb,candid,innocent person, but nowadays they are used to refer to "smart assholes". "listillo" is another word for "smart asshole" that I like. Literally, it means "little smart person". Diminutive of the word "listo" (smart) "enterao" is yet another word for "smart asshole". It is a contraction of "enterado", a person that knows about everything. Sorry for the interlude. (*) By the OP standard, I am an asshole.
- nestorherre 7y agoThat's in Spain's spanish, not in America's spanish.
- olgeni 7y agoI always get the impression that it's "technical assholes" vs. "wise managers who should be brave enough to fire the assholes." In practice: I see lots of assholes in management up to the director level, and the CEO doesn't do anything because they just hired their friends. Then, people just leave. Nobody cares because the issue of "tech assholes" is trendy these days.
- DFHippie 7y agoI think the issue of assholes winding up in management was covered.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI deal with rather...prickly folks on a daily basis. Nothing like dealing with folks that have multiple violent felonies on their record (and, to be fair, many of them are now extremely decent people) to help develop your "people skills." I try not to be an asshole, myself, and do try to avoid contact with them, where possible; but we don't always have the luxury of being able to pick those with whom we must interact. In my experience, I have found that I have a great deal more control over the nature of my interactions than you would expect. If I am dealing with an asshole, I can rather quickly figure out what kinds of things are likely to exacerbate their issues, and avoid those behaviors. Doesn't let them off the hook, but helps me to exert a bit of control over our relationship.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoI have one RIGHT NOW that I'm working on trying to dismiss. SHE is such a PITA. The way we're doing this to put it on paper is to do a "performance improvement plan." This, this, this needs to be done by this time. If not, this will happen.
- sixtypoundhound 7y agoNaive. The author has no concept of how psychologically damaging these ideas can be in the hands of a passive aggressive HR team. Put the genie back in the bottle. Values are good; they can rally a team. Feedback is good. What's missing is that feedback is never a two way street; there is always part of the company which is effectively immune from critique, by virtue of their position and rank. And this is where the psychopaths gather. Bullshit happens. Senior executives frequently re-write the corporate narrative to justify developments. Sometimes this is for the greater good, other times it merely pads their own situation. Nobody is incorruptible - when you have people, you have bad actors. Now lets look at how this is communicated. As a society, we're pretty good at dealing with getting screwed over by assholes. The interactions are mercifully short - most assholes have learned to give the bad news and get offstage as quickly as possible. Some beer is consumed, some words are said, and life goes on. Most importantly: the recipient of the "dick move" is able to process and recognize it for what it is, a self centered pile of shit inflicted by their superiors. There is minimal lasting damage. Now these fuckers.... would use values to rationalize all significant events. From the bully pulpit of their role in HR and senior leadership. With licence to lie, omit, and otherwise distort facts to support their narrative. While the employee was bound by an "integrity policy" and a "code of conduct" that required "professionalism". Not that these are bad things, but when one side can lie - and the other cannot call them on it... you're going to have a bad day. So basically - all of these "discussions" devolve into a fucked up version of a therapy session where the other person really doesn't have your best interests at heart. Where you are directly questioned and attacked on your values and the degree to which they align with whatever your inquisitor currently wants. And all of this deranged feedback is carefully calibrated to operate at a very personal level - there's nothing wrong with us, all of this is a function of your personal deficiencies. I survived. Got a great job offer from an ex-boss. And left. My kids and wife commented a month later: "Wow, Dad finally started smiling again". Yeah. That bad. Literally fucked with my own perceptions of my self-worth. A lesser person would have been driven into therapy. This is not how a workplace should operate.
- dhimes 7y agoA lesser person would have been driven into therapy. Careful there.
- tomp 7y agoI'm pretty sure one or both of Elon Musk or Donald Trump (both exceptionally successful individuals admired by many) would be judged as massive assholes by almost any person. So I'm not sure "being an asshole" is really a good reason to disqualify someone...
- Melchizedek 7y agoThis post conflates two very different things: 1. Benign lack of social skills (terse emails etc.). These people are not a major problem in my experience, and are sometimes even under-appreciated because they don't (successfully at least) sell themselves or play politics. They don't really have bad intentions and can often improve their behavior. 2. Narcissism (belittling others, must always be right, etc.) This is a _huge_ problem that in severe cases can destroy an organization. Such people are basically incurable because this is a deep seated psychological problem (really a personality disorder) and nothing a manager can fix. You must get rid of such people at all costs.
- mcs_ 7y agoI'm an asshole. If you work form me, work come first, as is the most important thing to me, after (and outside the office) your life, lifestyle and everything that is important for you.
- orpheline 7y agoI've dealt with my share through the years... the most problematic asshole I encountered was definitely in the 'unintentional' mold: friendly, outgoing, always willing to help others... So what made this person an asshole? They WOULD NOT LET GO their solution to a problem. If the team agreed on another approach, every planning meeting or conversation for the next month got derailed to rehash why this persons' idea was the best, and why we should change our decision. If we held to the original decision, this person would call team meetings with PO and PM 'to help resolve the issue'. This person didn't badger juniors. On the contrary, this person would have side conversations with the most junior devs to get them 'onside', then come to the senior devs with "the rest of us have been talking and we think the way forward is X". Caused a lot of divisiveness on our team before getting fired.
- ordinaryperson 7y agoYes, this is a better point than the one the OP was making: while everyone can agree assholes are bad it's not always easy to spot them. Similar to your experience: I had a colleague who was extremely negative. Everything was horrible, every manager was stupid. Nothing was done right, ever. We never worked on the right project and if we did we never did it the right way, according to him. I think he just valued his role as a contrarian: if everyone else was wrong all the time it meant he was always right, that he knew better and more than the rest of us. I used to tell him if he hated things that he should suggest better ways of doing things to management or, if all else fails, find a new role or new company that would make him happier. But he never did, he just liked complaining and/or making others miserable. But he didn't walk around with a sign that said "asshole" -- he could be polite and friendly and well-adjusted during the normal course of a work day. Then what do you do? Do you engage the person and argue with them? Ignore them and hope the problem goes away? We all know toxic coworkers exist, the question is how to change their behavior or deal with them effectively.
- alexandercrohde 7y agoI do think there is another side to this though. I think equally bad for the organization are people who are entirely supportive of huge mistakes: - Encouraging people to try any technology they want in an important, tight-deadline project - Telling people there's "No wrong way" to do things - Spending tons of time mentoring people who show little/no-motivation and low rate-of-learning - Refusing to perform a root-cause-analysis because it might seem to indirectly indicate blame - Inviting unknowledgeable people who talk to much to meetings above their station for "inclusion" - Not correcting the spread of misinformation
- bawana 7y agoIs assholish-ness a sign of a good founder? Do incubators use this as a secret criterion for admission? Ultimately can we write a word2vec implementation that produces an ‘asshole score’ based on a personal essay or job description as?
- paulfurley 7y agoNot sure exactly how but I’ve mostly avoided places where being an asshole is acceptable. This could be to do with actively avoiding bro-fest type places, looking for high-impact rather than high-pay kind of work, but I can’t really take credit. Separately, I’m quite shocked reading this HN thread seeing people defending the behaviour the article describes. I suddenly feel like I don’t really know the tech industry at all!
- tomatotomato37 7y agoMy problem with this is that it assumes there's only a single isolated asshole in the company and he exists in a social vacuum. It's much more common for multiple assholes of varying degrees to exist somewhere, and being assholes there's a very good chance they are not working together and instead are engaged with each other in GoT-tier power struggles. If a firable asshole is suppressing a worse unfirable asshole, do you still try to get rid of the former?
- mbubb 7y agoThere are assholes who are "constraints" (in the "Goal" or "Phoenix Project" meaning of this word). The newer incarnation of the BOFH. How do you get around this? This is a problem at the core of devops (as an idea not as the pseudo position). Management should look at constraints to see where the likely conditions for assholery are.
- giaour 7y agoThe article's advice on making positivity an official part of a company's culture is great! As is the mentorship/management strategy described for fostering positive behavior in problem cases. But firing an "unintentional asshole" over their lack of social skills seems like an easy way to be on the receiving end of lawsuit, particularly if terminated employee has a medical condition that explains the behavior in whole or in part. Firing someone with autism over their lack of social skills could land you in deep shit.
- alexozer 7y agoFavorite quote from the article: "It's better to have a hole in your team than an asshole."
- runamok 7y agoThe article rang true for me in that I am the asshole to some people but I don't start out an asshole. I just get impatient after explaining or documenting something 10 times and people ignoring it. I still want to minimize that bad karma but just letting people be bad at their job with no consequences doesn't seem good either.
- Veen 7y agoIf everyone who exhibits some of the qualities on this list is an asshole, I don’t think I’ve ever met anyone who isn’t as asshole.
- woodandsteel 7y agoWhat the author meant by the term asshole is someone who is consistently this way, not just occasionally.
- t176 7y agoFirstly, what's the opposite of asshole. Is there a name for that? Secondly, this: >Really, you can’t afford to keep assholes around - it’s better to have a hole in your team than an asshole. That may not always be true. It may actually be better to have an asshole than a teamhole, particularly if project delivery is dependent on the asshole. It may be unpleasant but unavoidable - at least temporarily. It may also be a financial issue and financial issues affect shareholders, and shareholders can be assholes. You win some, you lose some. The closing section made it all worth while. Probably the best 3 paragraphs I've read all year.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoDo you have a problem? There is help. There is hope! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1QFlgnN-7Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1QFlgnN-7Q
- Data_Junkie 7y agoAuthor seems a little butt hurt.