13 ms·
The Coming Boeing Bailout?
- KeAShizuku 7y agoI don't think things are going that badly for Boeing. There are only two aircraft producers and Airbus is at full capacity. The airline industry is still growing. You would actually have to try really hard to fuck this up. It would be amusing if the US government gives them money though. European alleged subsidy of Airbus is the latest accusation of Trump and one of the causes of the US-EU trade war.
- polotics 7y agoAt how many provoked deaths does "badly" begin in your (quote) thinking?
- onli 7y ago> You would actually have to try really hard to fuck this up. Murdering 350 civilians with lies and negligence for profit and "shareholder value" just might suffice. They put a plane into the air that flies itself automatically into the ground after all, with no opportunity for the pilots to save the plane. You can't fuck up more. > It would be amusing if the US government gives them money though. The US is already giving them money, indirectly. The EU is just also giving Airbus money. That's the core of the issue of Trumps position and why the conflict can't be easily solved.
- sokoloff 7y ago> They put a plane into the air that flies itself automatically into the ground after all, with no opportunity for the pilots to save the plane. You can't fuck up more. Though Boeing has significant contribution, if you read the report on the Ethiopian Air 737-Max crash, I think it's easy to see several places where there was ample opportunity for the pilots to save the plane, particularly in light of the LionAir crash. Even in the LionAir case, a prior LionAir crew did save the airplane on an earlier flight by following the manufacturer provided checklist. Boeing made a serious design error here. However, it's not nearly as serious as the quoted sentence, IMO.
- onli 7y agoI was honestly under the impression that the provided checklist did not work, as it included elements that did not work in the 737-MAX as expected when coming from earlier models. Plus the fact that the forces were to strong, the pilot could not manually correct the course. Besides, did the pilots have opportunity to read and implement the new checklist?
- sokoloff 7y agoThere was no new checklist. (Arguably, this may be a problem.) The existing checklist was unchanged from other 737s and the required actions were all "memory items" (items which must be recalled and implemented by the crew from memory, prior to referencing and completing the written checklist in the QRH). Any 737 crewmember would have had to have demonstrated those checklist items, from memory, prior to receiving their type-rating to fly the jet. Runaway trim is a "no joke" event in nearly any type and is a memory item in any type I'm familiar with. The Ethiopian Air crew seemed to correctly diagnose the issue, got the aircraft somewhat under control and then, in an attempt to fix the trim issue, undid the corrective checklist item, ran the trim aircraft-nose-up using the thumb switch (so far, excellent!!) and then, inexplicably, left the stab trim power enabled without commanding further aircraft-nose-up. So, they diagnosed the issue, initially did all the right things, then undid them [with good reason], then failed to re-do them. (I agree that Boeing still wears a lot of blame here. It's just not the case that the crews were helpless and unaware passengers.)
- onli 7y agoWell, okay. https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/2/18518176/boeing-737-max-crash-problems-human-error-mcas-faa https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/2/18518176/boeing-737-max-cr... agrees (though I vehemently disagree with its title when interpreting it as referring to pilot errors! But that might be the point). Problem seems to be that it was basically impossible to realize which checklist to follow and to identify the problem. I think my sentence when interpreted with that in mind still works (and you are still right as well): Pilots had no opportunity (several reasons, like not being informed about system changes) to save the plane, but not it was 100% impossible during the whole incident to save the plane (it was probably impossible after they deactivated the electric trim system).
- chopin 7y agoI am not so sure. Not only Boeing but also FAA have come under close scrutiny. And if the OP is right, there will be more accidents involving poor design decisions. After that, the public will shy away at least from flying newer Boeing models. Even a bailout could leave Boeing with only the military arm as nobody wants to fly with their civilian planes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- iSnow 7y agoIt would be kind of amusing if that was the beginning of the end of the duopoly and the rise of Comac as a third player.
- sschueller 7y agoHow much more support does Boeing need? [1] Maybe the should start considering stop cutting so many corners. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/jul/02/donald-trump-new-tariffs-eu-cheese-whisky-aircraft-subsidies https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/jul/02/donald-trum...
- MobileVet 7y agoWhile Boeing clearly participates in a duopoly... cash flow may necessitate a bailout. Cash on hand is going to get hammered by penalties for out of service planes and lost revenues due to the inability to deliver new planes. Outside of that, it will be interesting to see how endemic the issues were. Here is hoping that this was an isolated incident. The nightmare scenario would be multiple models suffering from a wide range of issues. Even though there haven’t been crashes, the optics and responses would be complicated. If investigations or whistleblowers uncover other issues in other models it could fall apart very quickly. This would crush the economy with travel and shipping grinding to a halt. A bailout of Boeing would be the least of our worries...
- bradleyjg 7y agoWhy necessitate? Businesses sometimes go under, that’s how the system works. The government ought not pick winners and losers.
- willyt 7y agoI’m guessing that it’s considered a strategically important business to US defence? The US government would presumably be unwilling to allow all those teams of specialist engineers and technicians to be disbanded and all the facilities and assets to be sold off as would happen when a normal business fails.
- philjohn 7y agoArguably those people would be able to form new, competing, companies with their know-how and a degree of investment. They would, naturally, have to start out small and grow from there - but Boeing was tiny once, as was McDonald Douglass, Lockheed etc. etc.
- macintux 7y agoBoeing was tiny when it didn’t take billions of dollars to design any new aircraft.
- bhouston 7y agoBoeing and the US government recently killed the Canadian aviation industry by putting on 300% duties on our main manufacturer because of a government bailout it received. See: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/us-issues-final-ruling-upholds-duties-on-bombardier-c-series-planes/article37394931/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/us-issues... As a result Bombardier, Canadian's only large aviation manufacturer, was sold to AirBus: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/bombardier-sells-majority-stake-in-c-series-to-airbus/article36610340/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/bombardie... The cause was a Canadian province (equivalent to a US state) did a $1B equity investment in Bombardier in order to help it survive a tough spot -- a bailout. Thus 300% duties were imposed on the company as a result, thus killing any potential plane sales to the US. But if the US government bails out Boeing, should countries around the world also impose business destroying duties of 300% on Boeing because of the unfair government support? Or do business destroying duties of 300% only get imposed on the aviation industries of smaller countries who do not have as much clout?
- leemailll 7y agoBombardier was not sold to airbus, but major share assets of one type of its airplane, the CSeries to airbus. Bombardier the company still holds 30% of the CSeries, while other types of planes not affected by the deal.
- arcticbull 7y agoThe duties were also overturned in the end, but not before Bombardier gifted 50.01% of the C-Series program to Airbus so it had a chance of survival. The net result was Airbus rebranded the program the A220, committed to building US-destination A220 jets within the US to avoid tariffs anyways and while they significantly weakened one [small] competitor (Bombardier and by extension Investissement Québec) they massively empowered their real competitor (Airbus). Ultimately, their plan backfired and forced them to acquire a large stake in Embraer to remain nominally competitive (I say that because the C-Series planes are much better than similar Embarer aircraft, both longer range and more comfortable) -- all while simultaneously empowering Airbus. They also significantly soured their relationship with the Canadian government jeopardizing both current and future military procurement opportunities. This was an unmitigated failure on their part. (EDIT) To be clear, Bombardier wasn't sold to Airbus, they gifted majority control of the C-Series program to Airbus. The new equity split is 50.01% Airbus, 31% Bombardier and 19% Invesissment Québec.
- kuu 7y agoHow did Boeing make miracles in civilian aircraft? In short, the the civilian engineers were in charge. And it fell apart because the company, due to a merger, killed its engineering-first culture Uhm, this makes me think about the engineering-first of Google. I wonder if Google will end in the same path...
- drawkbox 7y agoCompanies can come back after the HBS MBAs/bizdevs take over, they must return to product/engineering/creative focused though and it is tough, usually it takes a near failure for the problem to be recognized. Apple survived when Jobs came back and focused on products/engineering/creativity. Microsoft survived post-Ballmer after returning to product/engineering led decision making and power structures. Amazon is top of their game due to their relentless focus on product innovation and research and development. Google, I hate to say it, is Microsoft 2004-5, slipping away from product/engineering focus, using their position as business/marketing leverage rather than product/engineering/creativity focused leadership similar to how Microsoft made that same mistake. Companies that don't realize that business and marketing should cede power to product/engineering/creativity and return more to the open mode over the closed mode, well they end in stagnation after the last bit of value is extracted and all grace and position in the market gone. Companies that realize that product/engineering/creativity is most important and then their business/marketing teams boost those efforts in the marketplace, well those companies go on to live a long time and have well established research and development as well as risk taking adventures. Companies that are led by product/engineering/creative respect the open and close modes you must enter so you don't force creativity but let it flow [1]. > We've become fascinated by the fact that we can usually describe the way in which people function at work in terms of two modes: open and closed. > CLOSED MODE > So what i can just add now is that creativity is not possible in the closed mode. >Let me explain a little. By the "closed mode" I mean the mode that we are in most of the time when {we are} at work. >We have inside us a feeling that there's lots to be done and we have to get on with it if we're going to get through it all. >It's an active (probably slightly anxious) mode, although the anxiety can be exciting and pleasurable. >It's a mode which we're probably a little impatient, if only with ourselves. >It has a little tension in it, not much humor. > It's a mode in which we're very purposeful, and it's a mode in which we can get very stressed and even a bit manic, but not creative. > OPEN MODE > By contrast, the open mode, is relaxed… expansive… less purposeful mode… in which we're probably more contemplative, more inclined to humor (which always accompanies a wider perspective) and, consequently, more playful. > It's a mood in which curiosity for its own sake can operate because we're not under pressure to get a specific thing done quickly. We can play, and that is what allows our natural creativity to surface. >But let me make one thing quite clear: we need to be in the open mode when we're pondering a problem but once we come up with a solution, we must then switch to the closed mode to implement it. Because once we've made a decision, we are efficient only if we go through with it decisively, undistracted by doubts about its correctness. >Humor is a natural concomitant in the open mode, but it's a luxury in the closed {mode}. >But here's the problem: we too often get stuck in the closed mode. >Under the pressures which are all too familiar to us we tend to maintain tunnel vision at times when we really need to step back and contemplate the wider view. Businesses that develop products, especially in entertainment, that kill the open mode will kill the company. But default, the HBS MBA and bizdev metric focused production as if resources are mere parts, kills the open mode first, because it isn't quantifiable. The moment you see a research and development department killed or sapped you know that it is just a matter of time for that company unless they can return to the right focus, with business and marketing as the secondary supportive force to a solid product/engineering/creative focus. This is also mentioned in 'How Software Companies Die' which is almost law now: > "The environment that nurtures creative programmers kills management and marketing types - and vice versa." [2] I wonder when this knowledge will make it back to HBS MBA business school, there are plenty of examples in the market. Business and marketing should be the multiplier of your value, they are not the value creators, the product / engineering / creative / research / development / design departments and the people you have are the value creators. [1] https://genius.com/John-cleese-lecture-on-creativity-annotated https://genius.com/John-cleese-lecture-on-creativity-annotat... [2] http://www.call-with-current-continuation.org/rants/how-companies-die.txt http://www.call-with-current-continuation.org/rants/how-comp...
- euroclydon 7y agoTerrible title. Either I skimmed the end of the article or there was nothing about a bailout in there.
- thomasedwards 7y agoThe entire article summaries why there is probably going to be a bailout.
- windexh8er 7y agoI think you missed the point. The implication is that it is the direction we're headed. Which, personally, I find egregious given there's a criminal investigation into the company. I'd love to see the executive ranks do legitimate prison time for their cause of unneeded death.
- nabla9 7y agoGovernments should have predatory practice towards shareholders in these cases. If company can't be allowed to fail (strategically important or government regulated sector like banking) there should be 'fluid bankruptcy' option. When they default or fail their obligations, the next day the government owns them without operations being disrupted. Shareholders lose everything overnight and any private debt would have standard 50% haircut (lenders would know this beforehand). Government would then sell the stocks back to the market within 10 years or so. Bailouts are subsidies for risk.
- bradleyjg 7y agoThere is a third group of people whose incentives towards risk need to be taken into account -- employees. When the government takes over the employees should be moved to the GS or SES schedules.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat might guarantee that the company remains a money-loser, dependent on the government forever.
- pinkfoot 7y agoWhat you will discover is that you soon have no systemically-important high-tech companies. For example, the excessive litigation in the 1970s against general aviation just led to Cessna and co. making planes designed in the 1940s.
- fendy3002 7y agoGovernment in my country will use that to take the shares, then do corruption from inside and fattening their wallets. Im against shareholder is immune because of bailout, but I don't think government handling business can be better.
- grenoire 7y agoAgreed, as little trust as you might have in stockholders, hold not much more for your government.
- ptah 7y agoor let the free market and invisible hand take swift care of it
- Anarch157a 7y agoFree market and Invisible Hand bot fails when there's a monopoly/duopoly, especially when the players are deeply embedded in government structures, like Boing is, thanks to their status as the largest defense contractor for the US military.
- leemailll 7y agoBoeing still has more than 5000 planes orders to be delivered (http://investors.boeing.com/investors/fact-sheets/default.aspx http://investors.boeing.com/investors/fact-sheets/default.as...), I don't think they will try to change any time soon when things seem going well albeit 737max.
- xmichael999 7y agoThe cancellations haven't officially taken place, but you can be damn sure everyone other than committed 737 fleets like Southwest have unofficially already cancelled their orders of MAX's. Air Canada is the perfect example, it's the first time to introduce 737's to their fleet - they are waiting for the dust to settle but you can be damn sure the 737's they already own will be sold and Boeing will largely give them their money back too and the rest of their order will never be completed.
- leemailll 7y agoI’m not trying to defend Boeing and I also think the problem for 737max is a serious blow to boeing, but I suspect the only chance for massive cancellations of its orders is when ffa designates it as a new airworthiness type. Even that might depend on contract details. What also make the cancellations less likely, in my opinion is that its competitors, the A320neo has a backlog of more than 10 years at the current production rate. And the smaller a220, the former bombardier cseries, has a backlog of almost 400 planes. Besides, at 2019 France air show, IAG put an order of 200 737max in a letter of intent which is quite surprising and strange
- selimthegrim 7y agoIf there is a220 backlog why is there still FUD about assembling them in Mobile?
- lefty2 7y agoAirbus can always just increase production if the demand was high enough
- betimsl 7y agoGreat article. Now: > In 1993, a Defense official in the Clinton administration, Bill Perry, called defense contractor CEOs to a dinner, nicknamed “the last supper.” Bill you devil. Jokes aside, now imagine you're this guy and have all this power in your hands, imagine that for a second, what would you do? If you ask him, he did great. Because all he knows is that, he can't see past the situation because he is a small minded creature. This begs a question is he responsible? Well I don't think so. It's us, us people that go to polls and vote. Now imagine the frustration of the good Boeing engineers of that time. You probably can't because of the today's culture, a culture where nobody is giving a shit about anything. No matter what though, it's very important not to lose the compass and not forget for what you have fought when the time comes.
- saiya-jin 7y ago> This begs a question is he responsible? Well yes he is. It doesn't matter that much what his original intentions were (not that we will ever learn true intentions of these backdoor deals, politics is dirty at every level), the result is what it is. And this meeting was the decisive push for it. Will he stand trial for this? I can't imagine it happening. Can he claim to be a good moral person who did only the best possible choices for mankind/US citizens in his life? Absolutely not.
- bdavis__ 7y agoNot a viewpoint I agree with. Boeing has plenty of business. 737 MAX sales may suffer, but that will not kill the Boeing Company. Aviation is a deadly serious business. Design is done by people, which are highly flawed cogs in the system. The system was broken. (meaning design, verification, and certification process). The system can be fixed. Incompetence at some levels; perhaps. Not murder and not criminal behavior. Given a crew that has experienced an AOA sensor failure during MCAS operation in the simulator, I would fly on a 737 MAX as it was delivered. Without concern.
- amluto 7y ago> Given a crew that has experienced an AOA sensor failure during MCAS operation in the simulator, I would fly on a 737 MAX as it was delivered. Without concern. How about if the crew failed to recover in the simulator?
- bdavis__ 7y agoIf they fail to recover the first time, that would be excellent. (the pilot thinks "wow, this is hard and I need to learn..") Pilots do not like to die. If the first attempt was incorrect, they will do it again. and again. and again. A crew that was unsuccessful would not leave the training device until they had mastery of the situation. (and, the airline would not let them fly) For a single crew, the simulator time is very cheap. very cheap * 10,000 crew members shows up on a spreadsheet; thus the avoidance of simulator training by management.
- michaelmrose 7y agoDesigning a plane with 1 AOA sensor that can fail and cause the plane go into try really hard to crash into the ground mode is criminal negligence. The real universe has enough failure modes without engineering our own pitfalls. The engineers who signed off on this and their managers should be extradited to the countries involved to stand trial for criminal negligence.
- joyjoyjoy 7y ago"Given a crew that has experienced an AOA sensor failure during MCAS operation in the simulator, I would fly on a 737 MAX as it was delivered. Without concern." Make sure your pilot is a bodybuilder or something. "But Lemme said the Ethiopian pilots most likely were unable to carry out that last instruction in the Boeing emergency procedure — because they simply couldn’t physically move that wheel against the heavy forces acting on the tail." “The forces on the tail could have been too great,” Lemme said. “They couldn’t turn the manual trim wheel.”
- markus_zhang 7y agoThe problem is that corruption has already reached the core. The military-industry complex, the revolving door scheme, pretty much everything. I mean the system still works because the United States, so far, is still the most powerful country. But for how long? The elites are not doing their job, so the people should pick up from here. But the thing is, the people are not able to do this either.
- adventured 7y ago> because the United States, so far, is still the most powerful country. ... But for how long? What would be the competition to the US other than China (which is insular, nationalist to the extreme and protectionist to the extreme)? If China is the only superpower competitor, then the structure you just described will continue to work perpetually as there is no alternative. There is a common fantasy that the US is suddenly going to collapse, because 'all empires end.' It's nothing more than a fantasy because US wealth and power is derived from its domestic economic output, not from conquering foreigners or invading countries like Afghanistan (despite what the collapse-fantasy types would like to believe; the US already had the largest economy by 1890, long before the dollar became the global reserve standard). The US economy is built on its enormous scientific and R&D output, which is unrivaled in world history. That positioning of strength spans aerospace, spacetech, medtech, biotech, pharma, agriculture, software, mobile, semiconductors, intellectual property broadly, media & cultural export, finance & banking (Visa is worth $400b, Deutsche Bank is worth $16b; US banks are eating Europe right now, because of how weak their financial position is in contrast). The US is the world's #2 manufacturer by a large margin and is likely to regain ground on China from here forward (they will lose manufacturing share globally). The US has a position in energy that is unrivaled overall, including its oil and natural gas potential. The US has by far the strongest and most profitable airlines, which are now looking outward and beginning to buy into the rest of the world's weaker airlines. The US still has 19 of the world's top 20 universities, and 40x of the top 50. That's one of its critical foundations supporting its economy in the post WW2 era. The rest of the world has nothing even remotely like it. The US position is still expanding, not contracting. It has added an economy the size of Germany + France since the great recession. Simultaneously, China is gobbling up position / influence / economy / power in the other half of the world the US doesn't control. There is no peer to the US in the 'West' and there is not going to be. Most of Europe has seen zero economic growth since 2006-2007, their stagnation is going to get worse rather than better. They will fall further behind (and their politics will get much worse as that happens). Japan (third largest economy) is going to see little to no economic growth for the next 20 years at least. So where's the competitor going to come from? It's not. The US will continue to grow more powerful, wealthier, and its economy will continue to out-grow Europe and its military capabilities will continue to expand far beyond what Europe is capable of. China will be the sole competitor to the US in the 21st century and the two will split the world in half.
- xmichael999 7y agoLet's not forget yesterday Boeing announce a human life is worth $289,017 https://www.slashgear.com/boeing-reveals-100m-737-max-victim-fund-after-2018s-record-101bn-revenue-03582726/ https://www.slashgear.com/boeing-reveals-100m-737-max-victim...
- CydeWeys 7y agoThat's quite pathetic, given that the actuarial value of a life is actually around $5-10M (in the US anyway). They're going to end up paying out a lot more money in the lawsuits though, so we don't know the final total number yet.
- xmichael999 7y agoLet's not forget where the two max's crashed. Ethiopia and Indonesia. Some bean counters already decided the value of a life in these, "shit hole countries." I wouldn't be surprised if they literally took the cost of living index in the US and compared it to these countries and proudly patted themselves on this back when they came up with this amazing cost savings... I hope the individuals, airlines and the countries themselves find a way to sue Boeing into the ground.
- sn41 7y agoEthiopian Airlines is a Star Alliance member. It must be one of the premier customers of Boeing, and was one of the first airlines to introduce the Dreamliner and 737 MAX into their fleets. If word gets around that this is how they treat their good customers, this itself might be a nail in the coffin for Boeing.
- unscaled 7y agoIt's also the largest airline in Africa and it has been growing rapidly. Definitely a customer you'd want to keep satisfied.
- CydeWeys 7y ago
- mmargerum 7y agoThe Max software -- plagued by issues that could keep the planes grounded months longer after U.S. regulators this week revealed a new flaw -- was developed at a time Boeing was laying off experienced engineers and pressing suppliers to cut costs. Increasingly, the iconic American planemaker and its subcontractors have relied on temporary workers making as little as $9 an hour to develop and test software, often from countries lacking a deep background in aerospace -- notably India. In offices across from Seattle’s Boeing Field, recent college graduates employed by the Indian software developer HCL Technologies Ltd. occupied several rows of desks, said Mark Rabin, a former Boeing software engineer who worked in a flight-test group that supported the Max. Don't feel sorry for them and hope the govt doesnt give them a penny.
- mannykannot 7y agoThis article repeats the claim that the MCAS software was faulty, but is there any evidence of coding-level errors? There is the systems engineering failure of not comparing the two available AofA sensors to detect faults, if not going for at least triple-redundancy, but the root cause there is not a coding error. It has been suggested that high AofA readings should have been rejected unconditionally, but that approach can have its own problems, as in AF447 where the stall warnings stopped as the airplane became more deeply stalled. One should not leave the decision as whether to do that up to the programmer's discretion.
- bdavis__ 7y agokind of depends on how you name it. my understanding is the code 'worked per requirements', meaning it did everything that it was supposed to, as defined by the requirements allocated to it. for things like this, there is a layer of 'systems engineering', that decides (hopefully using an engineering process) how the airplane will work. this is codified into a 'specification', that is then handed over to software to implement. if you are a software engineer given this task, you implement it per the specification. nothing more and nothing less. of course, if you have a concern, you bring it up (both informally and formally). there is no 'discretion' by the programmer. The number of AOA sensors, how much control authority, how often the inputs are applied, are all decided by systems engineers (with aeronautical engineers input and analysis). the software engineer cannot 'second guess' if AOA failure has been considered and change the implementation.
- _ph_ 7y agoThe MCAS is a good example, why certain software must not be outsourced. Implementing the software correctly to spec isn't enough, you need enough understanding of the application to question the spec itself.
- bdavis__ 7y agoanything that is connected to the flight controls, is too important to sub out (unless you are subbing it out to someone better that you are). making an airplane is a huge endeavor that crosses across many domains. you have to have competency up and down the 'stack'. Boeing does. Maybe this will cause a re-look at outsourcing policies. (edit. yes, this software was not outsourced. but it may add another dimension other than cost for future decisions)
- seren 7y agoWhat is more worrying for Boeing is that a SW fix might not be that easy to implement. According to that article [0], the fix is running too slowly on the Flight Control Computers, that are based on a 80286 architecture. I am not sure how reliable this info is, and that should not be surprising given the cost of verification or certification of an aircraft, but I am still surprised that a 2019 plane, has still some HW and SW from the 1980ies. Edit : There are actually more details in Wikipedia [1] >In June 2019, "in a special Boeing simulator that is designed for engineering reviews"[75], FAA pilots performed a stress testing scenario – an abnormal condition identified through FMEA after the MCAS update was implemented[76] – for evaluating the effect of a fault in a microprocessor: as expected from the scenario, the horizontal stabilizer pointed the nose downward. Although the test pilot ultimately recovered control, the system was slow to respond to the proper runaway stabilizer checklist steps, due to an 80286[77] microprocessor being overwhelmed with data. The FAA characterized the slow responsiveness as "catastrophic", whereas Boeing initially classified it as "major". The solution appears to consist in rerouting data across multiple chips. Boeing stated that the issue can be fixed in software.[78] The software change will not be ready for evaluation until at least September 2019.[79] Boeing also said that it agreed with additional requirements that the FAA required it to fulfill, and added that it was working toward resolving the safety risk. It will not offer the MAX for certification until all requirements have been satisfied.[80] [0] https://www.moonofalabama.org/2019/06/boeings-software-fix-for-the-737-max-problem-overwhelms-the-planes-computer.html https://www.moonofalabama.org/2019/06/boeings-software-fix-f... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maneuvering_Characteristics_Augmentation_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maneuvering_Characteristics_Au...
- 0815test 7y ago> According to that article, the fix is running too slowly on the Flight Control Computers, that are based on a 80286 architecture. See, that's the nice thing. All they have to do is push the Turbo button, it will work like a charm.
- tempguy9999 7y agoPossibly talking rubbish but: a 286 is simple, well understood both in terms of its spec and its performance (no fancy pipelines, no cache, so very predictable performance), is fabbed probably in the order of a micrometer so highly resistant to cosmic rays (assuming CRs do affect circuitry), inerface to memory that is equally 'boring', those 286s are perhaps hardened and quite possibly still produced for this purpose. All the above is speculation but I can imagine that I'd like very old, boring, predictable and very understood tech rather than the latest. That said, it is a bit unexpected.
- canada_dry 7y ago> military procurement and engineering created a corrupt design process, with unnecessary complexity, poor safety standards Assuming this permeates a considerable amount of the US military spending I'm curious how much it deflates the true value? The US spends more than double China on military, and although it is likely a portion of their (China) budget goes towards graft and corruption my suspicion is that actual design, development and manufacturing is much more efficient (e.g. lack of environmental controls and labor unions) and would support the argument that the US is on course to losing its position of top military force (to China) within the next two decades.
- mrj 7y agoThe US spends a _lot_ of that on graft and corruption, as well. Even the article linked here mentioned playing politics with procurement, but also consider the billions and billions paid for military hardware that doesn't work and the Pentagon has gone on record saying they don't even want. The US has grown comfortable thinking it's still ahead while they continue to prepare for a style of war that will not come. If history is any guide, the next big war will be fought with a technology that takes advantage of the weaknesses of the previous leader, despite spending advantages.
- sslayer 7y agoThis article didn't seem to have any point to it other than bashing. I didn't see any hard facts pointing to the necessity of a bailout, rather a crude opinion piece designed to manipulate stock prices?
- KuhlMensch 7y agoCtrl + F "China", 0 results Oh? How can you talk about Boeing's current financial state and the trade tension between US and China? https://fortune.com/2019/03/26/china-airbus-order-boeing/ https://fortune.com/2019/03/26/china-airbus-order-boeing/
- Zenst 7y agoIs there any airline manufacturer since 1950 that was not born or kept alive on the back of governmental subsidies/grants/bailouts or lucrative military contracts to fund R&D?
- Theodores 7y agoYou know the answer to that question. Comac, UAC, Airbus, Embraer and others all came from government efforts. Bombardier took Canadair off the government's hands to get started, so they might be the nearest there is to 'private free market enterprise'. Boeing live off the the defence contracts but they are arguably totally free market. We know this isn't true and pretend. The article talks about how the McDonnell Douglas and Boeing merger was evil. But there is no discussion on why Airbus is okay when Airbus is a merger of various European defence interests with different cultural values. Why is one merger bad and the other not put under the same scrutiny? Also, why isn't there a supply chain where anyone can enter the market? Pratt and Whitney, Rolls Royce and General Electric make engines, so if you can make your own plane you just bolt on ready made engines. But that is as far as the system integration aspect seems to go. Most auto manufacturers do make their own engines so they are not 'systems integrators'. However, if you want to make cars you could go to Bosch for the bits they make, Johnson Controls for the bits they make, Pirelli for a few tyres and before you knew it there would be everything needed for final assembly. You could even get a contract manufacturer to make the whole thing. With computers anyone can build a PC. But there might only be 2-3 supplier choices for a given component. Some PCs are built for a specialist niche, e.g. point of sales systems, or medical. No heavy handed governments made the PC manufacturers merge into giant mega corporations, they did that themselves opening doors for new entrants in the process. Planes could be more about systems integration, so a given airliner might be able to get a local place to build planes for its requirements from off the shelf parts. The governments could have rationalised the industry to work this way. Imagine if, as per the engine example there are 2-3 suppliers for wings, fuselages, avionics packages, cabin interiors, fuel interiors and so on. This idea can be easily nitpicked, however, aeons ago the U.S. government legislated so that airliners could not build their own planes.
- Zenst 7y ago
- cronix 7y agoAt some point, we need to stop protecting incompetence. It just allows for more incompetence. Let the chips fall where the company bet on them. All of the companies. Or, let them get private insurance for such things. The public shouldn't be their insurance policy.
- Havoc 7y agoBit strange how the article seems to blame McDonnell Douglas for all Boeing's current troubles. First, it uhm no longer exists and second the merger was in 1997 - more than two decades ago! The current mess is flying under the Boeing flag one way or another.
- bonzini 7y agoThey are blaming a culture that according to the author was inherited from McDonnell Douglas. The iPhone is certainly an Apple product just like the 737MAX is a Boeing product, but would you attribute the success of the iPhone to NeXT/Jobs culture or Apple/Amelio culture?
- cryptonector 7y agoIt doesn't matter that the merger was over 20 years ago. What matters is whether there was a lasting cultural change at the merged company, and whether it was for the better or worse. I've worked through half a dozen M&As, and I've seen the culture at the bigger partner in some of them change radically, often because the bigger company will promote executives from the smaller company as part of the deal. This really is a thing, and sometimes it's a very bad thing, though I've also seen it succeed wildly. Executives often don't understand the culture in the companies they lead, or the companies they acquire or merge with. Sometimes they don't even have the luxury of choosing partners on the basis of cultural compatibility.
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoIt must be nice beeing CEO in a comnapy where nothing can go wrong.
- salawat 7y ago>And it was bad software, written by to engineers paid $9/dollar an hour. I really wish people wouldn't grab onto this; I've found no authoritative source linking those outsourced to to the coding of the MCAS, and several that explicitly state that was not the case. While the rest of the article has absolutely valid points, let's not cloud the issue with cheap mudslinging.
- zeristor 7y agoVery interesting, McDonnel Douglas was the company that gave us the DC10. I particular remember that since they weighed up the legal costs of when it would crash with applying a fix; rather short sighted. https://www.designnews.com/aerospace/designed-disaster-dc-10-airliner-part-1/196128601048982 https://www.designnews.com/aerospace/designed-disaster-dc-10...