5 ms·
As much as I love my Model 3, it has quite a few quirks that a car from a traditional automaker wouldn't have: (nonstandard charging connector, snow falls off t
by gwbas1c 7y ago
As much as I love my Model 3, it has quite a few quirks that a car from a traditional automaker wouldn't have: (nonstandard charging connector, snow falls off the rear windshield into the trunk, no power shades over the sunroof, no place to store sunglasses, ect.)
And, as much as I want Tesla to succeed, they really need to figure out how to get some know-how from standard automakers. I never had a pile of snow fall into the back of my Leaf when I opened its trunk! It also had a sunglasses holder, and I didn't need to use a dongle to plug it into a standard charger.
- mauvehaus 7y ago2005 Honda Civic: Water drains from the trunk lid into the trunk when you open it in the rain. If you open the trunk when there's snow on the rear window, it gets jammed up between the trunk lid and the window. The traditional automakers aren't immune from this sort of thing.
- dahfizz 7y agoTurns out making a car is really complicated and full of tradeoffs. A car with no compromises is going to cost 6 figures at least.
- mauvehaus 7y agoYeah, I'm not asking for a perfect car; it isn't made by any automaker, traditional or not. Personally, I'm a great believer in the theory that character is the great redeemer in cars. I once owned an '86 Subaru BRAT. It had all manner of quirks, but character in spades. Loved it, wish I'd never sold it. I will say, the water pouring into the trunk bug is singularly annoying, all the more so since the Civic doesn't have a lot of character to make up for it. Or maybe that's the Civic's manifestation of character, and I haven't yet found the flaw it's there to make up for.
- farisjarrah 7y agoTurns out even cars that are over 6 figures are still totally full of trade offs and compromises. This is a particularly insane example, but luxury cars are still in no way perfect. Doug DeMuro Reviewing a $200000 hummer: https://youtu.be/UqKUExgryXo https://youtu.be/UqKUExgryXo
- magduf 7y agoExotic cars usually have a lot more quirks and compromises than normal cars. They're also not known for being terribly reliable; the ones that are are made by divisions of much larger automakers, so they can raid the parts bin of their cheaper siblings. Jaguar used to be infamous for how unreliable their cars were, until Ford took them over.
- Alupis 7y ago> 2005 Honda Civic That's a 14, approaching 15 year old car. The weather seals and such are probably past their lifespan, and I'd expect Honda has improved the Civic in a number of ways in the last 15 years. That's also comparing a ~$19,000 car to a base model $35,000+ Model 3 (that costs $45,000+ in some cases). They're not supposed to play in the same league. You'd expect the Model 3 (or any Tesla for the price-point) to be a lot better than a generic Honda.
- metaphor 7y agoYou've missed the point. I believe the parent is talking about a 7th generation platform with a fundamental design flaw, not weather seal degradation. Price of the vehicle is completely irrelevant, but to be sure, these types of problems exist in just about every exotic on the market.
- senectus1 7y agoI have the same issue with a 30k 2014 Toyota Camry Hybrid. I think you're being blinkered in your views.
- ryanmercer 7y ago> snow falls off the rear windshield into the trunk That's happened in literally every car I've ever had, when you open the trunk the bit closes to the windshield that becomes the 'bottom' always has an inch or more gap between it and rubber gasket/weather strip. Any snow on the rear window or trunk deck slides down and if there is enough dumps into the trunk, unless it is very wet and can hold itself in a clump.
- jsight 7y agoOthers have responded to the trunk thing, but I will comment about the "non-standard" charging connector. There was no standard available at the time that Tesla started deploying thousands of high-KW chargers. It is hard to blame them for choosing their own. Even now, there are only certain regions where the other networks have advantages over Tesla's (coincidentally, the part of the US I'm in is one of those regions). Tesla is currently promising to support other viable networks in the future, presumably by adapters. At the very least, Chademo is expected for the model 3 in the near future, but hopefully CCS as well. Obviously they already support CCS in Europe. Also, keep in mind that GM is a pretty traditional manufacturer and doesn't even give you a CCS charger without paying for an additional DC fast charging option. Tesla isn't perfect, cars aren't perfect, but Tesla's are as good as they get in EVs right now.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoI'm looking forward to a unified standard, but the charger landscape is a confusing mess. There's type 1 and 2 AC charging, US vs Europe. Each of those has a DC charger version with DC charge pins added below the connector. At least these are mostly a form factor issue. Japan's manufactures have been pushing chademo, which has 2 versions itself and uses a completely different signalling protocol. China has yet another standard, with different signalling, but they're working with chademo to try to unify it in a new version. Then Tesla has theirs. At least Tesla is starting to unify around having adapters for the competing standards, though the adapters aren't cheap. I admit, I do like the CCS system if I were a car manufacturer. You make a larger socket and you can support both AC and DC sources in one connector. Alas, it has the two different connector type standards. But it is still all a mess if you're a car maker.
- jsight 7y agoYeah, its a horrible mess, and I think that is a big part of why Tesla's choice was the right one for them, at least at the time. At least Europe has started to standardize on a reasonable variant of CCS (type 2?) and Tesla is starting to just put these on the car with an adapter for the other types (including Tesla's own proprietary one). That makes a lot of sense to me and that standard seems pretty good. I still don't know why the US hasn't done the same thing. Instead the CCS adapters here are huge and clunky, and there are no adapters for Teslas at all. The stations here get an occasional Bolt charging at well below the capability of the charger and that is about it.
- mprev 7y agoThe amplifier in my BMW died after snow fell from the lid into the boot/trunk and shorted it. Utterly crap design.
- trymas 7y agoJust nitpicking on your arguments, but.. > snow falls off the rear windshield into the trunk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkSuyXnCSO4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkSuyXnCSO4 > no place to store sunglasses Most cars me and my family had - had no such thing (though I agree it's very convenient). I agree that Tesla is mass manufacturing newbie (slow to scale up, compared to the industry veterans), shoddy manufacturing practices/decisions, but they have things sorted where it matters though. Extremely well built batteries with superb longevity (Nissan Leaf's AFAIK are the worst, due to being air-cooled, etc.). Tesla has powerful and more efficient motors/batteries/drivetrain than competitors. Using adapters between power/data connectors is daily occurrence to me. I am not amazed we have this problem with relatively new tech of EVs. I am not sure about charging. Was there any standards when Tesla started developing their Superchargers and Model S, especially for Tesla's demands for very fast charges? Maybe they did not have any other option? P.S. all in all if not Tesla breathing into the car giants' backs (and probably if not diesel-gate), most manufacturers will not be aggressively expanding their EV line-ups now. They would do it in 5-15 years time, when more aggressive regulations would kick-in.
- Alupis 7y ago> > no place to store sunglasses > Most cars me and my family had - had no such thing (though I agree it's very convenient). OK, but we're not discussing budget cars - a Model 3 will run you $35,000 to $45,000+. That's premium car territory - and you should expect premium build quality and features. Skimping on a sunglasses holder is ridiculous for this price level, and while may be trivial by itself, it's indicative of the tier of design that went into the vehicle - budget.
- senectus1 7y ago2014 Toyota Camry Hybrid, Open the trunk after rain and water falls into the boot (trunk). Unfortunately this seems to be a common issue with a lot of car designs.