12 ms·
Superhuman embeds tracking pixels in user emails
- vultour 7y agoWhat email client loads images by default in 2019? I've used Thunderbird for years and I am pretty sure it has been disabled for a long time, Outlook at work doesn't load anything outside of the firm's domain, and I also remember big news on HN from a while ago saying gmail will start to proxy images which should prevent these things from working. Tracking pixels are so widespread that surely it must work, so what do people use to view their emails?!
- babyslothzoo 7y ago> What email client loads images by default in 2019? Most do. You have to turn it off manually.
- nickfromseattle 7y agoI don't believe Outlook or Gmail do. Am I wrong here? What other apps or clients load images by default?
- NikkiA 7y agoApple Mail, which most apple users use.
- aiddun 7y agoI just realized that gmail doesn't serve proxied images on external clients (mail.app, iOS Mail app). I bet a lot of people don't realize this either.
- Nextgrid 7y agoIt seems that more and more do which is a shame. I'm surprised it's enabled by default on Apple Mail on both iOS and macOS. I'd expect better from a privacy-focused company.
- sleepyhead 7y agoIllegal in Europe due to GDPR.
- zzzeek 7y agohaving an email client that automatically loads images is insane. it means that any spammer / scam emailer can immediately tell if their emails are getting into your inbox vs. being filtered and they can then see where you live, and target their next spam / scam to that geographic location and/or try to find out who you are, etc. a mail provider like fastmail could in theory be loading image links in emails they will deliver to their users and store them into their own local cache, rewriting the email your client receives so that you see the images served off of your email hosting provider's servers. that would be a straightforward way of preventing any sort of image link tracking across the board, is this a thing?
- pkilgore 7y agoThis is something I've been wondering about for quite some time, particularly given that large providers can hash the images and conserve storage space by storing only a single copy of the image per hash. I would suspect there are privacy implications of google caching what's behind every image tag in an email, in addition to the massive traffic / CPU spike such a thing might cause to retrieve the image and hash it, particularly for a very large email campaign. (But I don't know). [Edited to include this link, which I found in another comment here] "Gmail will now serve all images through Google’s own secure proxy servers." https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html
- bzbz 7y agoYes, iirc (though don’t quote me on it) gmail started doing this a while back. Not loading them when the email was sent, but proxying and lazy-loading.
- kpwags 7y agoI seem to recall Gmail doing this a couple years ago. I was working for a marketing company at the time and there were questions as to how we'd track metrics for Gmail addresses since Google would essentially "open" every email and load the images on their servers for their users.
- lwb 7y agoI don't see anything unethical about Superhuman using something that's part of the platform for literally every other business email application (as the author mentions: Salesforce, Mailchimp, etc). Sure it's a little creepy, but this is a silly hill to die on. The author compares tracking email opens and locations with looking into your neighbor's window and seeing them naked. What's different about the latter is that it's actually illegal (look up "peeping tom laws"). Storing someone's public IP address and using it to guess their location is not illegal, and shouldn't be -- we have massively faster internet from things like DNS targeting that do exactly that. If you're going to go after people for tracking user locations then there are much bigger fish in the sea than Superhuman. EDIT: It looks like GDPR does go after the big fish here, which is email tracking in general: https://www.gdpreu.org/compliance/email-tracking/ https://www.gdpreu.org/compliance/email-tracking/ > In its current prevailing form, we expect email tracking to be categorically prohibited under the GDPR without express user consent.
- mcguire 7y agoWait...so "tracking email opens and locations" is different from "looking into your neighbor's window" because the former is legal, but then you mention that email tracking is illegal?
- eanzenberg 7y agoI disagree, and believe IP tracking through email tokens SHOULD be illegal!
- dev_tty01 7y agoAre other people doing it? -- So that is a reasonable test for ethical behavior? Wow. Other platforms similarly unethical behavior is NOT justification for lack of ethics. That might be a financial argument, but it is absolutely not a reasonable approach to ethics. Legal vs. illegal is also not an appropriate basis for proper behavior. I think if we all used that standard for our personal interactions society would rapidly descend into chaos.
- matz1 7y ago
- RandallBrown 7y agoIn these sort of articles, I wonder why the author never considers benign intentions. The conversation could have easily been "Read receipts are a useful feature." "Yeah. Let's add them" And that was it. Lots of people are not privacy focused and don't think of this as a problem, so it would never occur that their seemingly benign feature could have bigger consequences. It's pretty easy for people who care to "turn off read receipts" by disabling images or blocking it through proxy/vpn/whatever. I personally don't like read receipts, so I will likely not use superhuman. I just don't view it as some major problem.
- harryh 7y agoIt's pretty easy for people who care to "turn off read receipts" by disabling images or blocking it through proxy/vpn/whatever. What about non technical people who have no way of learning that they are being spied upon?
- mcguire 7y agoLikewise, "turn off read receipts" and "disable images" seem like two different things.
- RandallBrown 7y agoMy thesis is that if you care about being tracked enough that you'd want to turn it off, you're also technical enough to do it. I may be wrong.
- harryh 7y agoGo find a non technical person and ask them these two questions: "Do you care if your ex-girl/boyfriend can tell every time you read an old email s/he sent you?" "Have you disabled loading images by default in your email client?" You will see that you are wrong. EDIT: decided to listen to my own advice and conduct a (very non scientific obvs) twitter poll. https://twitter.com/harryh/status/1146120438432616450 https://twitter.com/harryh/status/1146120438432616450
- 7y ago
- nikolay 7y agoI got an invite, scheduled a conference call, and the lady said she I need to screencast how I'm using Gmail. I told her that I'm not letting a stranger peek into and record my Gmail inbox and she said that I cannot sign up without this step, so, I refused, and they lost the income from me. Typical overhyped SV crap. Should rebrand to "Subhuman".
- ASalazarMX 7y agoThis is bananas. Why would anyone need that in the first place? I can't come up with any remotely valid reason.
- NoblePublius 7y agoRahul has written volumes on the SH onboarding process. They train you to use the product so you will actually use it.
- barkingcat 7y agoBut anyone can do that without screensharing the person's own screen. It's called good old fashioned coaching and teaching.
- nikolay 7y agoI told the lady that I have over 35 years of software development experience and I've used all kinds of software and I don't need guidance and I do, I will reach out to them, but she was stubborn and lost a customer. I tweeted to Rahul and the team, but got no response so far! Well... This is not a scalable business model. But the lady was clear: "Superhuman is not for everybody!" Alrighty then!
- NoblePublius 7y agoOver 15,000 users paying $30 per month. $260 million valuation. Perfectly scalable. If you'd like to learn why you're wrong, I encourage you read one of the many lengthy, sincere, and detailed articles with the founder of Superhuman, starting with this one. https://www.drift.com/blog/how-to-measure-product-market-fit/ https://www.drift.com/blog/how-to-measure-product-market-fit...
- peterkelly 7y agoOne of the many reasons I love Little Snitch [1], which among other things is great at notifying you and allowing you to block requests for external resources when reading mail. https://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html https://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html
- exolymph 7y agoThanks for the reminder, buying it now :)
- consumer451 7y agoI just recently got back into Linux as a part-time driver and use this for the same purpose: https://github.com/evilsocket/opensnitch https://github.com/evilsocket/opensnitch Admittedly, I'm a noob so I would be happy to hear about alternatives.
- Nextgrid 7y agoI'd prefer my email client to not load external resources at all. If it attempts to do so (and I have to use a separate firewall to prevent it) I'd consider the email client defective.
- munchbunny 7y agoEmail marketers have been doing this for a very, very long time. As someone who used to work in adtech, my reaction was "well of course they're doing this, every other email marketing tool does it." Personally I think email software should all turn off third party requests by default. If you want images, use data urls or attached images.
- luckylion 7y agoSuperhuman isn't an email marketing tool, and it's not opt-in email.
- jhunter1016 7y agoThe amount of pixel-tracking apologists make red herring arguments in these comments is proof that tech, and probably specifically SV tech, is not ready to embrace privacy.
- pcmonk 7y agoI hate tracking pixels, read receipts, and all similar stuff. The only thing worse than lack of privacy, though, is privacy theater, and that's what we've had. It's a good thing for more people to realize that this stuff happens all the time, so they can take action about it if they want to.
- luckylion 7y agoThat sounds like an accelerationist position: instead of having some remnants of privacy, make them lose it all so they realize the value and take action to get back full/more privacy. What if the revolution never happens? Then what little "privacy theater" stood between the corporations and the users is swept away. When corporations need to show some restraint, even if only to not appear completely evil, at least it's some restraint.
- maemilius 7y agoYou and I must have very different ideas about what "privacy theater" means. To me, privacy theater is the _illusion_ of privacy not real privacy. So, removing "privacy theater" does nothing to your actual privacy and only shows you how exposed you really are.
- pcmonk 7y agoI'm generally opposed to accelerationism because it's too black-and-white. When there's some good to preserve, that's usually worth preserving. However, in this case I think we're already at the bottom since these methods are used regularly. Having a coworker know whether I read their email is the most benign version of tracking (even though I still don't like it). The difference to me is that accelerationism says "it's bad; let's make it worse so that people will realize they need a revolution". Anti-theater says "it's bad; let's tell people know how bad it is".
- mbrumlow 7y ago> no matter what email client you use Nope, not my email client, Emacs/Mu4e simply flat out won't notify you by any means that I have viewed the e-mail. Man, the world has gotten weird. Its like people forgot emails were actually just text.
- kevincrane 7y agoBecause for almost the entire world they’re not.
- throwaway9010 7y agoAside from remote images, they store all of your emails on their servers. Not sure why they don't receive the same scrutiny that other email apps like Edison have [1]. I've heard enough fishy stories from former engineers there — people should think twice before logging in and letting them ingest your full account history (as with any third party email app, which Gmail is already cracking down on [2]). [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2018/07/02/third-party-email-apps-reading-user-emails/ https://www.macrumors.com/2018/07/02/third-party-email-apps-... [2] https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/10/08/google-updates-gmail-api-policies-developers-will-require-app-reviews-security-assessments/ https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/10/08/google-updates-gmai...
- Cd00d 7y agoEdison packages up info from user emails and sells that on the data market. Maybe Superhuman isn't doing this (yet), and therefore aren't being scrutinized for this security/privacy lapse in the same way.
- sahaskatta 7y agoI do not think this is true. I'm pretty sure it's all locally stored aside from "scheduled emails" which are temporarily stored on their services before they are deleted. Note: I'm not using Superhuman currently, but tried it briefly a few months ago.
- jbob2000 7y agoThis is just email tech playing catch up with instant messaging, twitter, and other communication tools. At least with email I can block images and prevent the tracking from occurring. I can't do that with facebook or twitter.
- harryh 7y agoThis is not correct, and there is even a section in the post rebutting this point (did you read it?). See "Email clients have done this for years. Even Apple does this with iMessage"
- jld 7y agoFrom the article: > Superhuman doesn’t even let its own customers turn images off. So merely by using Superhuman, you are vulnerable to the exact same spying that Superhuman enables you to do to others.
- Skunkleton 7y agoAll superhuman is doing is giving access the same tech that every company uses to monitor emails sent to individuals. If you don't like it (and you absolutely shouldn't), then don't use superhuman and turn of automatic image downloads in your email client.
- ajiang 7y agoThe problem is that the person that "doesn't like it" isn't the user of Superhuman, it is the recipient, who doesn't get a choice as to what email client the sender is using.
- Skunkleton 7y agoAnd my point is that a large percentage of emails sent contain tracking pixels already. Privacy conscious recipients should already have automatic image downloading disabled.
- 7y ago
- Udik 7y agoI thought that this trick was as old as html email, and that (at least) gmail was actually caching images on their side to prevent tracking?
- Mathnerd314 7y agoThey're proxied but follow the caching rules sent by the server, so for tracking purposes they're not cached. You get entries with proper date/time, proper tracking ID, but anonymous Google IP / user agent. Posts I found that seem readable: https://movableink.com/blog/gmails-recent-image-handling-changes-the-impact-and-resolution/ https://movableink.com/blog/gmails-recent-image-handling-cha... https://movableink.com/blog/real-time-content-and-re-open-tracking-return-to-gmail/ https://movableink.com/blog/real-time-content-and-re-open-tr...
- chipperyman573 7y agoI may be wrong but I believe google cached it after you open the email first. So your IP is hidden and you can't tell how many times someone has opened an email, but you know the timestamp of the first time they do.
- jalk 7y agoThe Gmail image-proxy honors the regular http cache headers, so marketing mails get their open rates ‘correct’ but cannot see cookies/ip addresse
- deogeo 7y agoWhy do e-mail clients still load images by default? This is not a new attack, or even hard to predict.
- staunch 7y agoI thought Gmail's solution to this was to always download every image in your email and then proxy the image from their own servers when you view it. This results in a meaningless 100% "open rate" for Gmail and does not reveal an end-user's IP address.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bduerst 7y agoThis is correct: https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html
- chimeracoder 7y ago> This is correct: https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html No, it's wrong. The first time you open the email, the image is retrieved. It's only subsequent views that are cached. So the sender can still see when you read the email; they just can't see how many times you read it afterwards.
- bduerst 7y agoNot quite, the sender still doesn't get location and your browser fingerprint. The receipt of email is still received though.
- chimeracoder 7y ago> Not quite, the sender still doesn't get location and your browser fingerprint. Yes, but the key question was about the open rate. The statement: > I thought Gmail's solution to this was to always download every image in your email and then proxy the image from their own servers when you view it. This results in a meaningless 100% "open rate" for Gmail is incorrect because a) GMail does not always download every image in your email b) GMail does not have a 100% open rate.
- kop316 7y agoWhile this may be "what aboutism", I noted that the post sets a cookie on your browser by just visiting the site. Considering the person is saying how bad it is to have a tracking pixel in email, the site that hoats this article can now do similar things by putting that cookie in your browser
- ryanisnan 7y agoNot quite the same. With email pixel tracking, anyone can theoretically obtain your broader geographical position just by sending you an email via Superhuman.
- kop316 7y agoIn order for pixel tracking to work, one has to open the email and load the pixel. I don't think you can track someone just by sending an email.
- kreetx 7y agoYeah. I guess they try to offer the customer something extra. But this doesn't look like to be the thing they should offer.
- pcmonk 7y agoThis has been the case since always. It just wasn't as obvious to users because consumer-oriented mail software didn't include it.
- manigandham 7y agoYou requested the page from their server so they know you visited. Setting a cookie doesn't do anything unless you come back to the same site, at which point you request the page and they know again anyway.
- guitarbill 7y agoThat assuming e.g. your IP address doesn't change. Cookies can be used for tracking - in this case they aren't though, the cookie for me is "resolution: 1920,1", which is set by this inline script: <script>document.cookie="resolution="+Math.max(screen.width,screen.height)+("devicePixelRatio" in window ? ","+devicePixelRatio : ",1")+"; path=/";</script> I can't tell what it's used for (seems unused in the other JS files), but as far as cookies go, that seems pretty benign.
- docker_up 7y agoCan I turn off tracking pixels in Gmail?
- gowld 7y agoGmail intercepts tracking pixels at Gmail's server, if you use gmail's client. The sender gets the "open" event and time, but not the client into (IP, etc) http://go/so/20379732 http://go/so/20379732
- docker_up 7y agoThanks, so I can't stop senders from knowing I opened an email?
- modeless 7y agoNote that Gmail defeats the location tracking and browser fingerprinting features by proxying all image requests. So while the read receipts do work, you are not leaking your location or your browser fingerprint to the sender even if you leave image loading on. https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2013/12/images-now-showing.html
- docker_up 7y agoThanks, so I can't stop senders from knowing I opened an email?
- modeless 7y agoYou can, but you have to disable image loading (like any other email client) because any image may have tracking information in it.
- empath75 7y agogoogle, on the other hand, knows all of that information.
- 7y ago
- dannykwells 7y agoOh god superhuman. What a hype train. Finally got an invite...only to learn they don't support Android? And really, only support entirely Mac-based workflows? I mean from a baby startup maybe that's reasonable, but in this case, with all the hype, I think not. My guess is a very well connected founder who was able to get his VC friends to hype the tool, make it elite and club-like, and from there, profit. I look forward to seeing them go down in flames more than most other elitist, stupid startups around.
- dmix 7y agoIt's also Gmail only, which they are pretty up-front about in the puff pieces. Almost every fancy email app I've used has had cross platform issues early on. It's always either iOS or Android only, often little desktop supports (zero for linux) besides maybe some half-baked web site. etc, etc. Superhuman is hardly new in this context. The mac/ios only first approach is super common for better or worse.
- pcmonk 7y agoNot having Android support is frustrating, for sure. However, I've come to appreciate the flow of only being able to really manage email on my laptop. I use the gmail app on Android so I get notifications and can send off a quick response, but I don't feel like I need to do anything else there, like set a reminder for myself or mark it unread. I know it'll still be in my inbox when I get to a computer. Also, I've been using it fine on Linux, except that it didn't support Firefox when I tried it.
- jumbopapa 7y ago> only support entirely Mac-based workflows? I believe the application is Electron based too, so it's not even a technical reason to make it platform specific.
- Pt_ 7y agoThis sort of open tracking with geoIP based location has been around for a while. There are numerous GMail add-ons that provide this functionality eg. Streak there are equivalent's for other clients too. This is written as if Superhuman are the first people to do this, that doesn't justify the behavior but there are others to blame here and the precedent was set prior to Superhuman's implementation with these email tools
- Kique 7y agoAfter reading this I'm now more interested in the showerhead he loves so much and seems so enthusiastic about. It does have great reviews online so I might have to pick one up now.
- kabwj 7y agoIt’s a Commando 450.
- midnightmonster 7y agoNearly every email marketing platform does this for every email they send already, and that’s part of why thunderbird has had images off by default in email since a really long time. (Or maybe I set it that way years ago, but at least it’s an easy setting.) Is it weirder because it’s mail from an individual? I guess so.
- undecisive 7y agoProbably... maybe? Certainly I'd be weirded out if an online catalogue employee had found my name, decided to look at the geolocation data on the tracking pixel and was devotedly interested in where and when I decided to admire the latest in chinese tech. But I think the point is that this is much less likely than on a personal email, and if you don't know the person then it's a little less creepy because it has no emotional meaning to the "stalker"
- gowld 7y agoIt's strange that we put more faith and trust in sociopathic-by-design corporations (which are just large groups of people you don't know, but who have some interest in you) than in humans we willingly correspond with.
- xwdv 7y agoNo it isn’t. Corps are too big to care. An individual with specific interest in you can be far worse.
- billyhoffman 7y agoI mean, yeah I am weirded out by that, and don't like it. And I'm not trying to be (too) snarky, but seriously, what did you think people would do with this technology? HTML email + IP to location + simple automation has driven the multi-billion dollar Martech (marketing technology) market for years. The feature set you are describing has been standard for a years now: - They all use tracking pixels/logos-in-signatures for read receipts - Read receipts aren't boolean "someone read this!" but instead track when, how many times you opened it. - IP to location is used to understand location and route the lead/opportunity to the appropriate sales rep. - Email User-Agent fingerprinting is done to track device type - Most have automation, that allow you to automatically re-mail or even phone dial someone who has just opened an email after certain conditions are met. This is fairly basic technology, glued to together, creating powerful platforms for marketing and direct sales. On a site like HN, how could any of this come as a surprise?
- sbr464 7y agoFrom a design standpoint, It would be nice if email clients had an option to hide image placeholders if images are also blocked from loading.
- gopher2 7y agoI think what gets me is the juxtaposition of the brand name and this functionality. Superhuman sounds like it should be all about making the email sender more productive. And not about tracking time-stamped geotags of my actions as the receiver.
- whiddershins 7y agoStreak has been doing this forever, why is this new news?
- iandanforth 7y agoIf you're concerned about this behavior (and you should be, it's creepy as f) you might be interested in this EFF article: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/01/stop-tracking-my-emails https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/01/stop-tracking-my-email...
- NoblePublius 7y agoNow do Tout. Or Yesware. Or Salesforce. Or every CRM ever invented. Or LinkedIn posts by Premium users. Also hilarious you think that Superhuman competes with Outlook.
- bartkappenburg 7y agoNot trying to be too much of a conspiracy thinker but 227 points in 1 hour should give the first spot on HN (it was though) but now it's on #12. Are the investors pulling some strings?
- steveklabnik 7y agoYou don't know how many people have flagged the article or not. There was a very sudden drop, so something happened, but it's impossible to give the actual root cause unless you're on the inside of HN itself. I'd assume flags over any sort of conspiracy here.
- sh1ps 7y agoI saw the drop and wondered if there was something afoot, then talked myself off that ledge and assumed this was probably some kind of normal flag like ring detection triggered, etc. Interesting additional note, though, the title has (relatively recently) changed to "Superhuman embeds tracking pixels in user emails" versus the actual article title of "Superhuman is Spying on You"
- alexpetralia 7y agoYes, this post fell down unusually fast. May not be HN specifically but perhaps a large, motivated SF cohort.
- Exuma 7y agoIMO who cares. People can do this anyway with dozens of different email tracking services. What difference does it make if it came from a 3rd party service or the email client they send it with. I think you should just expect tracking in email, just like you would expect 90% of websites to track you if you have adblock off.
- metalchianti 7y agoI know nothing about the capabilities of Superhuman but with other clients (e.g. Outlook) I can circumvent (most?) tracking by disabling automatic downloading external content.
- ameister14 7y agoI think the difference is you expect it from a marketing email, but you don't expect it from a personal email.
- joshe 7y agoMixmax has an accidentally helpful guide to the only way to block tracking: block images. (They also mention how aggressively they try to get around email blockers.) There's an inverse relationship between email importance and production value, seeing a bunch of blank boxes is a great hack to signal that. https://success.mixmax.com/article/57-track-opens https://success.mixmax.com/article/57-track-opens "...An open won't be recorded if: The recipient opens the email on a legacy email client that blocks all images from being viewed. This also means that images in signatures and other media won't carry through to the recipient, so in practice this is quite rare. The recipient has software to block email tracking. This is also quite rare, and Mixmax actually circumvents most email tracking blockers."
- tregoning 7y agoIf I understand this correctly: (Gmail’s API lockdown will kill some third-party app access, starting July 15) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20300008 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20300008 I think their startup will stop working soon, given that they only support GMail.
- numair 7y ago> One absolute doozy of a requirement kicks in if the app stores user data on a third-party server. Google will now require those apps to pass a third-party security audit, which the app developer must pay for. According to the company, the cost "may range from $15,000 to $75,000 (or more) depending on the size and complexity of the application." The message here seems to be "Don't store Google user data on your server." They've surely paid for this. And, ironically, this is the sort of app that Google supposedly set up this gatekeeper process to keep off their platform, as this was meant to "safeguard user privacy."
- nathan_f77 7y agoI do want to be an ethical company, and I agree about all these decisions adding up over time. This article convinced me to deleted all of my MailTrack accounts and uninstall the extension. I was using MailTrack for a while, and it's been a very valuable tool, but I can do without it. I was also talking to some lawyers about GDPR, and they said that this kind of tracking is actually illegal for recipients in Europe, unless I explicitly ask for their permission to include a tracking pixel. So I was already planning to get rid of this, and I'm glad that my emails are now GDPR compliant (even for people in the US.) [1] http://mailtrack.io http://mailtrack.io
- Nextgrid 7y agoCan you tell me more about how they violate the GDPR or quote the relevant parts of the regulation? I've got an inbox full of otherwise legitimate emails but every single link is a disgusting stalking link thanks to their ~spamming~ marketing platform (also the links are always HTTP even if the original link was HTTPS, so they also decrease security) so I'd love to put an end to that.
- gnicholas 7y agoMy guess is it's because you're collecting PII on someone (location data and email address) without their consent. And it doesn't sound like there are procedures for an EU resident to request that all such data be scrubbed, which I believe is also required.
- sergiomattei 7y agoA good alternative to Superhuman is KanbanMail[1]. I've been using it for quite a while now and it works wonders. It's pretty productive and the creator is pretty responsive. Disclaimer: guy who made it is a cool friend. [1] https://KanbanMail.app https://KanbanMail.app
- LinuxBender 7y agoPeople will do what people can do. Test your email client for leakage and then plug the leaks. There is some discussion and links on stackexchange [1] If your client can't plug the leaks on its own, please file a bug with the mail client developers. Please consider asking them politely to make those settings default. [1] - https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/23718/is-my-email-client-violating-my-privacy https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/23718/is-my-ema...
- ChuckMcM 7y agoI resonated very strongly with this well written piece. The description of how early decisions become part of your company's "genome" is spot on. This comment in particular; "When faced with making a product decision that is even mildly uncomfortable, employees often first look towards expressed company principles like “Always put the customer first”, but the next thing they look for is precedent." It is reminiscent of the "two wolves" Cherokee story of two wolves inside a person one evil, one good. The one that wins out and determines your character is the one you feed. These sort of company decisions, individually small but repeated over time, are food for the ethical wolf and the unethical wolf that lives in the soul of a company. One way to know that you probably don't want to continue at a startup is when you notice they are feeding the unethical wolf more than the ethical one.
- Sebguer 7y agoA really good article speaking to this is: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/01/what-was-volkswagen-thinking/419127/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/01/what-wa... Though, honestly, I find the use of Johnson & Johnson in that article to be more problematic by the day considering they clearly have done a lot of evil at this point.
- hawaiian 7y agoWhatever happened to hosting your signature as an image at cutepersonalizedname[.]com and logging the IPs yourself? It probably wouldn't take much work to use Automator.app to periodically uniquify the src URL in your sig and map Sent Item => unique hash into a sqlite database, later asynchronously updating it with IPs seen from an nginx server hosting your image. Presto, you're a "superhuman".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- asdf21 7y agoWow, what is your new business worth now? Such unique technology
- human20190310 7y agoIf Superhuman announced they were going to remove the tracking pixels instead of doubling down on defending them, they might have turned all this negative publicity into a benefit. They may have already missed the window for doing that though.
- asdf21 7y agoLiterally anyone can add an email sig with an image from their own server and do this exact same thing. It's extremely well-documented and imo not even controversial. In fact, it's so uncontroversial, I suspect this entire thread of being some sort of "manufactured controversy viral marketing" promotion for superhuman.
- hawaiian 7y ago>I suspect this entire thread of being some sort of "manufactured controversy viral marketing" promotion for superhuman. I thought so too.
- notsosuperhuman 7y agoI'm a friend of the superhuman CEO and have been following this company over the time it's been around, both by talking to him and from interactions with the official channels. Here is my $0.02. SH started out like any other startup, with the best of intentions and a cool idea but it just didn't take. The issue is that they're on the line to deliver and they haven't had the traction they'd like so I've seen it slide, slowly, over an extended period, into a desperate place that leaves them doing ugly things. You should read Rahul's blog on finding product fit, it tells you much. Personally, I now think they're in a position where they are trying to mooch everything they can off of users in order to try and build a better product coupled with finding ways to be "unique" that will make them money/attractive. This means they end up in sketchy territory i.e. the pixels, forcing people to reveal how they use gmail in order to sign up, tracking every-single-aspect of how users are using their site, hyped up bullshit etc. I don't know if they're harvesting actual user data. The fact is, they're between a rock and a hard place. They aren't profitable, and there's no real exit. Whatever features make them unique can be copied in months, if not weeks by any other provider. Why would Google buy them? Also, the feature set, as good as it is, only appeals to a tiny subset of users of email. Other aspects like corporate email not being allowed to be accessed by third party clients etc makes a difference too. I wish them all well, but by God I would not want to be a part of this thing. It stinks.
- newmac 7y agoWith friends like that, Rahul hardly needs any enemies!
- graeme 7y agoThis doesn't read as accurate at all. Nobody has copied Superhuman's features. I'm sure you can't name another app that has. It's substantially faster to use than other email apps. I have strong doubts you're who you claim to be.
- pmart123 7y agoWhile I don’t know about the company traction, or sales tactics, I think it is fair to assume the feature set on email can be fairly easily replicated by the big players if they want to. Gmail added a lot of the Boomerang features as well as suggested autocomplete, etc. pretty quickly IMO.
- mikl 7y agoI can't imagine why people would want to entrust their e-mail to a company that's known for disrespecting people's privacy. cough Gmail cough
- nojvek 7y agoWe need a very simple law. “1. You cannot track a user or send marketing spam without their explicit consent. 2. The user can take away the consent at anytime and you gotta stop the peepin. 3. The user can ask for what you’ve tracked and you gotta give it to them. 4. The user can ask you to delete their data and you gotta respect that.” I know this is what GDPR is but we need a saner US version of it. We can’t be technology leaders and still pretend it’s the Wild West.
- Nextgrid 7y agoGDPR is also BS. Not only is it not enforced (why are Google and Facebook still around considering their entire business is to basically violate the GDPR?), but there are plenty of exemptions that can be abused to argue that nasty behavior falls under "legitimate interest". Making a complaint is also super difficult. The ICO (UK's privacy regulator) for example insists that you have to first contact the offending company and give them 3 months to reply which is an insane amount of effort and not always possible (what if there's no way to contact the company, or you have to login/create an account first). There should be just a simple form where you send the URL of the offending page and they take it from there.
- mike-cardwell 7y agohttps://www.emailprivacytester.com https://www.emailprivacytester.com will let you know if your email client is leaking information about you, by sending you an automated email with various tests embedded (e.g tracking pixels). If you're scared about giving your address to this tool, I wrote it. You've no reason to trust me, but you can scan the about/privacy pages for information, and it's also available to download and self-host.
- cj 7y agoWhat bothered me the most about tracking pixels in emails (when using Apple Mail) was false positives: I would occasionally have someone ask me why I opened their email 20+ times before responding (I didn't). After a while, I realized that when using the "arrow down" key to scroll through your inbox in Apple Mail (with split view enabled), Apple Mail will open and render every email in the split view when attempting to open an email further down in the inbox. This would result in every tracking pixel being loaded/rendered dozens of times, even when the email was open on the screen for < 200ms. After a few times hearing people ask why I opened their email dozens of times but haven't responded (when really hadn't read their email at all), I ended up disabling images from loading in emails entirely. Does anyone know if this is still an issue with Apple Mail? Or if this also happens with Gmail configured in split view?
- AlexandrB 7y ago> Does anyone know if this is still an issue with Apple Mail? What issue? This is marketing wonks and creepy SV companies abusing image loading in email to implement "read receipts". The fact that some clients load images differently is their problem, not Apple's.
- snowwrestler 7y agoOutlook does this too if the reading pane is turned on, and it often is in big corporate audiences. It’s a well-known issue with image-based open tracking. IMO the people harassing you about how many times you opened their email are idiots. Image-based open tracking is notoriously unreliable and is best used to track engagement trends within a given audience, not as a microscope on one person. This seems like a classic example of people taking some marketing feature at face value and not spending any effort to understand the actual technology under the metrics they see in a dashboard.
- kmarc 7y ago> With Superhuman, it is not. If I send you an email using Superhuman (no matter what email client you use) Dunno, I open mails with (neo)mutt, so none of this works.
- rasse 7y agoIf this is a problem, why is with Superhuman and not the client at the receiving end? How tracking pixels are handled is a client issue. If anyone's violating your privacy, it's your email client and not the sender of the email or the sender's email client/provider. I think it's analogous with EU's "cookie consent". Cookies too are a client issue. Instead of annoying mandatory popups on every site, browsers should handle cookies better by default.
- harryh 7y agoIt's both. If someone breaks into my house because my door lock is broken then I should definitely fix the lock. But the criminal shouldn't have broken in anyways.
- rasse 7y agoIn this case the lock would be shipped broken from the factory with the users and lock manufacturer's knowledge and consent (with regards to email clients' and web browsers' default settings and the user's ability to change these).
- dingaling 7y agoCookie popups aren't mandatory unless the site has decided to use additional cookies which aren't necessary for the basic site functions. There's no real way a browser could know the difference, hence the law.
- rasse 7y agoThanks for the clarification!
- troydavis 7y agoI was on Superhuman's waiting list in 2018 – until, on 2 occasions, Superhuman puts its own growth above customers' needs. 1 involved privacy: when a Superhuman user emailed an address on the waiting list, Superhuman told the sender. I didn't and don't trust them with my email. I know Rahul and told him then that I thought they had an organizational blind spot in over-emphasizing growth hacking. I don't think it led to any changes. (If anyone is looking: I've been a FastMail customers for years and still trust their staff, ethics, and decision process/priorities completely. Bonus that their webmail doesn’t load remote images: https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/remotecontent.html https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/remotecontent.html)
- hedora 7y agoI guess I’m mostly surprised people have auto load images turned on in their mail clients. This does make me want to find a mail client that automatically finds these tracking images, uploads them to a pool of tracking URLs, and then loads a few hundred members of the pool at random (preferably with randomized cookies, etc). I’d pay for something that does this to the top 100 tracking firms, especially if it worked with web browsers.
- DocTomoe 7y agoThis is why my private address deletes everything that does not have a text-only part containing at least 80% of the HTML mail´s user-readable content. EMail is supposed to be text infomation, not a glorified leaflet.
- dotsarefun 7y ago> Before we continue, ask yourself if you expect this information to be collected on you and relayed back to your parent, your child, your spouse, your co-worker, a salesperson, an ex, a random stranger, or a stalker every time you read an email. Yes. I expect analytics to be captured from HTML emails which I open.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shultays 7y agoWhy mail seevices doesnt load the images the moment it receives an email? And cache them?
- ilyaeck 7y agoHow hard is can it be for an email client, e.g. Gmail, to specifically detect tracking images (literally 1x1 pixels or other similarly small/inconspicuous images) and to block them by default? Sounds pretty trivial to me...