3 ms·
If the rare earths produced from the Chinese mines and refiners were of lesser quality, then you would have a point. If the refining process requires them to po
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
If the rare earths produced from the Chinese mines and refiners were of lesser quality, then you would have a point. If the refining process requires them to poop in their own backyard, then you might not even be aware of that until many years later, let alone have a free market interest in preventing them from doing that.
> So the failure comes back to people not actually caring about the environment in China.
Some people, many people in China do care about the environment, they just have lacked the power to do much about it. But yes, again, short term interests win out when the long term consequences are far away in space or time. And then it’s just a classic prisoners dilemma: you can think long term, but your competitors will just put you out of business short term so it isn’t a workable solution.
- bluGill 7y agoMy company is very careful that our suppliers don't use slave labor. We have mapped out supply chain down 6 levels in some cases to ensure this. Slave labor is cheaper, but we won't use it even indirectly.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoAnd so what? Slave labor has long been known to be not profitable, it is easy agency useful to avoid. Also, your consumers will reward you for that.
- bluGill 7y agoThe last point: do consumers reward me for not picking the cheapest?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNot really. They reward you for not getting caught using slave labor.
- bluGill 7y agoRewards for not getting caught for cheating is a fundamental problem that no system can solve. There are systems that get closer than others. We tend to use words like fascist to describe them for good reason: the downsides are often worse than the problems. This isn't to say we shouldn't work on the problem, we just need to be careful that our ends are not worse.