6 ms·
Microsoft is a big company and Windows is a big product. Is fully remaking the Control Panel really such a monumental task? The Control Panel isn't that deep.
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
Microsoft is a big company and Windows is a big product. Is fully remaking the Control Panel really such a monumental task?
The Control Panel isn't that deep. It's not as though Microsoft needs to create a UI for every advanced Group Policy setting.
The new Settings app was introduced with Windows 8 in 2013. That means Microsoft has had six years to complete the transition.
- oblio 7y agoYes, it's monumental. Third parties could add their own pages and hook into existing pages. Read the OldNewThing blog for the insanity that is the Windows ISV ecosystem. Windows is space age tech compared to the garbage these companies pull off.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOh, I can understand leaving a Control Panel framework in place for opening legacy menus made by third parties. What I find problematic is the Microsoft-supplied functionality. Duplicate menus for the same thing adds an extra mental burden.
- will4274 7y ago> Duplicate menus for the same thing adds an extra mental burden. I think you'd see that Microsoft gets this. Win8 was all dupes. Initial Win10 release removed most of the dupes and they've removed more with each Win10 release. The strategy is pretty clear - incremental rewrite based on what people use.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThey've been removing things? The last change I noticed was the addition of a new duplicate control panel for sound.
- pas 7y agoThis means the old one is deprecated and will be eventually removed. The problem is, for some reason the presentation is tightly coupled/tied to the data model of the settings. Otherwise there would be no need to have 2 versions of it. Which is OOP no-no 101. Shrug. Corporate IT.
- will4274 7y agoThe TPM menu - if the legacy UX is still around, I can't find it on the latest Win10. Looking through the deprecation notes, it looks like some language settings were de-duped in a 10 update https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/deployment/planning/windows-10-1803-removed-features https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/deployment/planning.... It's slow work. Microsoft has gotten more aggressive about change compared to ten years ago, but they are still very conservative. Users don't like it when the UX changes.
- zbentley 7y ago> The Control Panel isn't that deep. It really, really is.
- Litmus2336 7y agoThis week in "HN looks at software that took thousands of devs 30 years to write and says 'eh I could've done that in a day!'"
- maccard 7y agoThey could rewrite it using electron?
- toyg 7y agoDon't give them ideas!
- pas 7y agoThe fancy Win 10 settings uses a WebView basically.
- trulyrandom 7y agoThat's interesting. Where did you learn about this? One would think they'd just make it a UWP app.
- Dylan16807 7y ago
- opportune 7y agoA lot of the windows UI code is ancient by software standards, some of it written before desktop GUI frameworks even existed. And much of that code is still being used across versions. Rewriting in a way that is 100% backwards compatible (any less compatible is unacceptable) would be a massive endeavor and very hard to justify given the cost.
- sterlind 7y agoI'm a weirdo but I kinda like the archaeological deep dive-type feelings I get, seeing two decades of OS history rewind as I'm reaching further into the guts of the beast. My only gripe with the old school is accessibility (scaling in particular, ugh), but even that's not so bad. (Disclaimer: I work for MS, but not on Windows)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]