3 ms·
> - Many people have a relatively short commute, so limited range EVs like Nissan Leaf or e-Golf do just fine. Doesn’t this negate a lot of the benefits of de-
by Scoundreller 7y ago
> - Many people have a relatively short commute, so limited range EVs like Nissan Leaf or e-Golf do just fine.
Doesn’t this negate a lot of the benefits of de-ICEing vehicles?
Why doesn’t the government use gas tax increases as a tool instead of up-front discounts?
Getting the 100km/day driver to change from ICE to electric would have 10x the impact as the 10km/day driver.
- adrianN 7y agoICE cars pollute especially strongly on short trips in cold temperatures as all exhaust treatment systems need to get up to temperature before they work.
- gambiting 7y agoYep. Especially modern diesels are just a nightmare of incredibly complex systems all existing purely to keep the engine somewhat clean when it's cold - once it warms up(which can be as much as 10-20km in really cold climates, more than the commute for many people) it's fine, but keeping it efficient while cold is a huge challenge.
- rdruxn 7y ago>Doesn’t this negate a lot of the benefits of de-ICEing vehicles? Sure some of the benefits, but the context is in the discussion of incentives and the attractiveness for the average buyer. 10km/day drivers have their needs sufficiently met with cheaper, shorter-range EVs.
- waterpowder 7y agoMost 10km/day drivers would have their needs met with a bicycle
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoIn Norway in winter? Not so much!
- phtrivier 7y ago> Why doesn’t the government use gas tax increases as a tool instead of up-front discounts? Given the huge corpus of two datapoints (Norway and France), it seems that: - if you offer discounts on EVs, people who own gas-powered cars will progressively replace them with EVs ; - if you increases gas taxes, people who own gas-powered cars will spend their saturday afternoons demanding your head on a spike, and stop voting for you until you roll-back on the gas tax increases. (At which point, they will mostly keep not voting for you, but that's an unrelated debate.) I suspect not every government has the benefit of choosing between both options - Norway might be an outlier here. (And most government will probably choose the "wise" third path of doing nothing.) My underlying theory (that must have been tested by Cialdinni, Khaneman or Ophra) is that rebates feel good, and taxes feel bad. But I don't have a double-blind placebo-controlled experiment to cite.
- flurdy 7y agoNorway is already about $2 USD per litre of petrol. In the US it's $0.79. According to https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/gasoline_prices/ https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/gasoline_prices/ (Or $7.5 per US Gallon in Norway)
- Gibbon1 7y ago> - if you increases gas taxes, people who own gas-powered cars will spend their saturday afternoons demanding your head on a spike This is exactly why gas taxes are bad. > is that rebates feel good, and taxes feel bad You can also like some California air quality districts are doing buy back low income peoples junkers and provide them down payment assistance for hybrid and electric cars. There is a lot less political blow back from those sorts of programs.
- phtrivier 7y agoBut, again, you have to be in a position where you can afford such policies. I'm perfectly ready to hear that Norway and California can afford it, and France can not.
- lb1lf 7y ago> Getting the 100km/day driver to change from ICE to electric would have 10x the impact as the 10km/day driver. -Not if there are 20 times as many 10km/day drivers as 100km/day ones. Put another way - if the bulk of commutes are fairly short, the advantages of having these becoming electric is larger than that of electrifying the comparatively few long commutes - doubly so as an ICE is a much worse polluter when cold than at proper running temperature.
- stetrain 7y agoGas taxes affect those who already have a gas car and may not have the budget to replace it. Point-of-purchase taxes affect the choice of which vehicle to buy at the point where you were already deciding which vehicle to buy.
- gambiting 7y agoPoint of purchases taxes are also poor in that they fail to reflect the damage that particular car will do. For example - a Lamborghini will have outrageous taxes due to high emissions, but a Lamborghini is usually only driven 10-20k miles in its lifetime, nearly never for commute, and usually only filled up with best fuels and well maintained. Then in comparison a Fiat Panda will have tiny emissions taxes if any, even though compared to that Lamborghini it will pollute far more through its lifetime. No, I think fuel taxes are the right way to do this - the more fuel you use the more you drive = the more you pollute.
- Gibbon1 7y agoYou can certainly estimate the damage a particular car model will do and impose an appropriate excise tax. While the damage to the environment from people driving Lamborghini's is a rounding error. So would a carbon excise tax. If you charged $100/ton of CO2 that would be about $15k on top of a $400k price tag.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoYou are missing the energy used to make the car! Driving a vehicle on 10-20k is shocking from an environmental perspective once you include manufacturing.
- Gibbon1 7y agoExactly!!! I keep harping on that. Consider a 10 year old Toyota Camry. Soon as it was built we were committed to another 60 tons of CO2 emissions. Raising the gas tax doesn't undo that decision. And people don't junk cars because the price of gas. They junk cars because of maintenance and repair costs. Raising gas taxes is totally weak sauce and invites political blow back. Better to just pay people to take marginal cars off the road. And discourage people from buying new ICE powered cars. Especially low MPG ICE cars.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoICE fuel is very highly taxed already. The first few km are the most polluting especially for NOx. Part of the push for electric is about NOx emissions rather than CO2.
- Gibbon1 7y agoJust chime in and say that hybrid vehicles have a fifth to a tenth the NOx emissions of regular cars. Currently there are a lot more hybrid cars available than EV's.
- magicalhippo 7y agoIn addition to what the others have mentioned, this assumes those 100km/day drivers realistically can switch to an EV. Most of those live in more remote areas of the country, which have lower population density and as such get charging station coverage later.