9 ms·
I just booted up a windows 10 machine earlier today for the first time in many months. It absolutely bewilders me how terribad the UI is. You have this fancy U
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I just booted up a windows 10 machine earlier today for the first time in many months.
It absolutely bewilders me how terribad the UI is. You have this fancy UI but if you ever click one or two options deep you end up getting these alternately styled legacy interfaces. It's so incoherent.
It really makes windows 10 feel like a skin on top of windows xp.
So when the article says Microsoft wants to push users into windows 10 all I can think of is that it's for the good of Microsoft. But they had to add a little window dressing to make the users happy.
- wrs 7y agoIt’s a skin on a skin on a skin on a skin. Its always been this way. By clicking on “advanced” buttons you can easily end up with four different eras of UI on the screen, including different system fonts and different font rendering algorithms! I can tell you first-hand from trying to get some of that fixed years ago, there’s just so much STUFF in Windows that is hardly ever seen, or should only be seen by “IT professionals” who supposedly don’t care, that there will never be enough resources or time to fix it all.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThat sounds like it was the intent. But I got into old menus simply by trying to change the clock time. Definitely not an IT professionals who don't care kind of action.
- derefr 7y agoSure it is. What home user even realizes they can change the clock time any more? Consider: can you change the clock time on your phone? I've never even considered doing so, personally. Seems like it'd screw up the GPS, if it was possible. Anyone whose first computer was a smartphone isn't going to think of changing their computer's clock time. To them, the time is a network feature, not a local feature.
- Taniwha 7y agoGPS satellite signals include their own time
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gbear605 7y agoI do it on my smartphone occasionally.
- reaperducer 7y agoConsider: can you change the clock time on your phone? On an iPhone: Settings > General > Date & Time
- Causality1 7y agoA feature that's partially broken on Windows 10 considering I have never once had the "set time zone automatically" option work properly.
- maccard 7y agoIt screws up SSL certs, that's for sure.
- alister 7y ago> What home user even realizes they can change the clock time any more? Indeed. Even if you have the temerity to go and change the clock, the iPhone is secretly maintaining the true time internally and can use it or revert to it at will. I'm making a bold claim, so here are the steps to reproduce: - Go to Settings -> General -> Date & Time -> Set Automatically -> disable - set an incorrect time - Go to Settings -> {Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Cellular} -> Off - Go to Settings -> Airplane Mode -> enable - go someplace without any wifi or change the wifi password on your access point or disconnect/power-off your access point - remove the SIM card from the iPhone - Now go back to Settings -> General -> Date & Time -> Set Automatically -> enable - Surprise surprise! The date and time revert back to the correct value even though you have no possible network connection. How did it know the correct time? Implementation thoughts: If the true time is 6:00pm and you change it to 9:00pm, the iPhone could calculate the offset as 3 hours and 0 minutes, and show you the time as 6:00pm + 3h = 9:00pm, but knows that the true time is really 6:00pm. The same effect could also be achieved by having two internal real time clocks (aka time of day clocks), one for the true time and one for the time you set. My theory is that they'd prefer users not messing with the clock, but they provide a UI for setting your own time (such as for people who like setting their clocks 5 minutes ahead to never be late for meetings). However, they keep the true time for other purposes (perhaps for logging, syncing, or something else?).
- birdman3131 7y agoI would not mind the newer interface if it did not screw with half the settings I need.
- Baeocystin 7y agoI actually like the newer interface... when it isn't trying to take over my entire 32" screen to show me information that would have fit in a 2" square window, or doesn't bother exposing more than a quarter of the functionality you get with the older UIs.
- gmueckl 7y agoHow many parts of Settings do you actually like then? I think that almost every part falls into one of these categories for me.
- Baeocystin 7y ago...exactly. :)
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoMicrosoft is a big company and Windows is a big product. Is fully remaking the Control Panel really such a monumental task? The Control Panel isn't that deep. It's not as though Microsoft needs to create a UI for every advanced Group Policy setting. The new Settings app was introduced with Windows 8 in 2013. That means Microsoft has had six years to complete the transition.
- oblio 7y agoYes, it's monumental. Third parties could add their own pages and hook into existing pages. Read the OldNewThing blog for the insanity that is the Windows ISV ecosystem. Windows is space age tech compared to the garbage these companies pull off.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOh, I can understand leaving a Control Panel framework in place for opening legacy menus made by third parties. What I find problematic is the Microsoft-supplied functionality. Duplicate menus for the same thing adds an extra mental burden.
- will4274 7y ago> Duplicate menus for the same thing adds an extra mental burden. I think you'd see that Microsoft gets this. Win8 was all dupes. Initial Win10 release removed most of the dupes and they've removed more with each Win10 release. The strategy is pretty clear - incremental rewrite based on what people use.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThey've been removing things? The last change I noticed was the addition of a new duplicate control panel for sound.
- pas 7y agoThis means the old one is deprecated and will be eventually removed. The problem is, for some reason the presentation is tightly coupled/tied to the data model of the settings. Otherwise there would be no need to have 2 versions of it. Which is OOP no-no 101. Shrug. Corporate IT.
- gemjam 7y agoOne super useful hidden feature but terrible ui is you can start typing as soon as Win 10 start menu is open... example 'notepad'... I used to install classic shell just to get the [run] input box
- jorvi 7y agoHow is that terrible UI? It's basically what Spotlight does for Macs. Cmd+space and it overlays a text box from which you can find and open any file, application, event etc. or even do stuff like calculations and unit conversions.
- autoexec 7y agobecause there is no indication to the user that they can or should enter text. One my favorite things to type in the old "run" box was "." and that doesn't work anymore in 10. I can still open a command prompt and type "start ." at least.
- ygra 7y agoWin+R still gives you that dialog.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> One my favorite things to type in the old "run" box was "." and that doesn't work anymore in 10 It absolutely does still work in the Run app. The Run app is no longer conveniently docked at the bottom of the old Start menu near where the search box now opens when you start typing in the new Windows menu, though.
- jve 7y agoOh, wow, thanks for tip. I always though why they don't include %USERPROFILE% to quick links :/ Btw, as others mentioned - Win+R gives you Run dialog. Or Win+X gives you admin tools and a Run button approximately where it used to be. Or just right click on start button...
- bscphil 7y agoYou're right. I think the two completely separate "settings" programs are the most user-facing of the problems with these interfaces. It probably doesn't help incentivize updating that the new one is so terrible. [1] It looks like a really bad version of KDE's Plasma theme (Breeze). [1] https://www.windowscentral.com/sites/wpcentral.com/files/styles/larger/public/field/image/2016/07/settings-app-windows-10-au.jpg?itok=9aH9JfjF https://www.windowscentral.com/sites/wpcentral.com/files/sty...
- barrkel 7y agoThe settings screens dating from the iconic control panel era can't easily be dumped because third party drivers add tabs and extend the dialogs. That's a big part of the problem.
- anticensor 7y agoThey could have made a partial machine translator to convert to the modern control panel and an API wrapper for runtime compatibility in the interim.
- gmueckl 7y agoHow would you automatically translate hand-layouted dialogs (originally even manually adjusted for localizations where required) into a completely different layout and design language? Never mind the few dialogs that do custom controls and custom rendering (joystick test and joystick calibration, for example). In plain Win32, that stuff is often part of the window repaint event handler and not encapsulated in a way that allows it to be repositioned reliably. It is a huge mess.
- cookingrobot 7y agoThey could render it off-screen, and use neural network style transfer to make it look fresh..
- arpa 7y agoOh the wonderful AI hallucinations we would see! And nobody would be able to debug them as a bonus. I like the idea.
- anticensor 7y agoTranslator would search for all non-draw calls (like a JVM coverage tester) and place them accordingly in the translated control flow. Layout would be translated by capturing draw calls using an off-screen rendering.
- nogridbag 7y agoI just booted up my Surface Book for the first time in months. It attempted to download and install Windows 10 update 1903. The update failed with a large dialog telling me my system isn't ready to install update 1903. I'm going to sound like the naive end user now, but isn't it the job of the update manager to only download and install updates that are ready to be installed? It did eventually install 1903 after about 2 restarts. But failed updates are always scary to an end user.
- jjwhitaker 7y agoIn my case there is a glitch in the 1903 install where having external drives attached forces a fail as the installer can't determine which is the Windows drive or something (per an error/forum I read at the time). I had coped the ISO from a USB so removing the USB drive resolved the error. I think it's picky to prevent issues similar to 1809 install. That was a mess and I'm sure MSFT would rather have an error before upgrading than a user missing all their data or something worse.
- blattimwind 7y ago> In my case there is a glitch in the 1903 install where having external drives attached forces a fail as the installer can't determine which is the Windows drive or something (per an error/forum I read at the time). All things old become new again. In the Vista and 7 era there were a bunch of updates that you just could not install if you booted Windows by chainloading its bootloader. You had to boot Windows straight from BIOS, otherwise they'd fail to install, because some obscure component in Windows couldn't figure out what C:\ was otherwise.
- makomk 7y agoThe data loss issue in 1809 was the result of Microsoft intentionally writing and deploying code with the specific purpose of deleting people's documents directories and everything contained within them. The way to avoid this was not to program Windows updates to delete people's documents. (For anyone who doesn't know the context: Windows has the ability to redirect the various documents, music, etc directories away from their default locations. Some genius at Microsoft decided that any data left in the original location after such a move was junk and got a Windows 10 update to delete it. Unfortunately, Microsoft's own OneDrive software, which was bundled with and heavily promoted by Windows 10, intentionally redirected some of these folders without moving the contents in older versions and also often failed part-way through leaving some files behind in newer versions which promised to move the existing documents too. So a whole bunch of people who'd clicked Yes when Windows 10 pestered them to put their documents in OneDrive found that not only did it fail to do that, they got all their non-cloud-backed-up documents deleted a few Windows updates down the line. Making matters worse, some of the members of their crowdsourced beta-testing program had apparently hit this problem and warned them that the update was deleting people's documents, and Microsoft just ignored it and went ahead with the update anyway.)
- partiallypro 7y agoOSX does the same thing across apps and tools, with different menu styles that don't match etc.
- robbyt 7y agoDo you have any examples?
- Eric_WVGG 7y agoJohn Siracusa used to write about this in his old OS X reviews… Apple would do weird things like make a dark title bar for Garage Band, then a title bar with vertical "traffic" lights in iTunes that wasn't used anywhere else, then a normal looking title bar that was just a few-pixels off in margin from the stock title bar… It's all kind of weird and silly, but nothing at all like Windows where you can suddenly jump into the Windows 2000 UI at any turn.
- saagarjha 7y agoUnlike Windows, though, these were conscious decisions where applications decided to ditch platform controls and roll their own. Windows just has a dozen different UI frameworks that each do their own thing.
- DonHopkins 7y agoI like to configure the Windows desktop to look like Windows 2000. It makes me feel 19 years younger!
- Razengan 7y agoIt's not a matter of "it must either be a desert or either a rainforest." Neither OS is faultlessly perfect in any area, but the macOS side of the UI consistency fence is definitely, objectively, much greener.
- hitpointdrew 7y ago> you end up getting these alternately styled legacy interfaces. Yeah but you can actually DO what you want to in those legacy interfaces, in the new interfaces it is "dumbed down".
- CivBase 7y ago> It absolutely bewilders me how terribad the UI is. You have this fancy UI but if you ever click one or two options deep you end up getting these alternately styled legacy interfaces. It's so incoherent. It's definitely inconsistent, but I'd disagree with it being incoherent. IMO, Windows has done a fantastic job at making complex functionality accessible through reasonable GUIs. My biggest issue is not that the interface is incoherent (and the consistency is a minor gripe to me). I struggle much more with _navigating_ the interface than interacting with any given dialog. That said, I've never used Linux distro or macOS iteration that came anywhere close to making features accessible to users via graphic interfaces. GUIs may not always be the _best_ interface (that's another discussion), but you gotta hand it to Microsoft for how much work they've put in to get where they are when it comes to GUIs. I do not envy anyone tasked with "reskinning" it all.