3 ms·
> In other words, inflation is a policy choice to combat sticky wages, which (if you think that's a problem), the solution is to, apparently, screw labor by dev
by nabla9 7y ago
> In other words, inflation is a policy choice to combat sticky wages, which (if you think that's a problem), the solution is to, apparently, screw labor by devaluing their wages from under them.
This is complete misunderstanding of how this works. Inflation does not increase the real return from stock markets. Inflation erodes also capital. Capital must work just to stay still.
Inflation or not, the wages reach equilibrium. You can't improve the aggregate sum of wages by deceasing inflation. If nominal wages are too high the equilibrium is found trough periods of unemployment. Small inflation keeps unemployment and friction in job markets in check.
Small inflation keeps income inequality in check.
https://www.cepweb.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/CEP_WP_Inflation_and_Income_Inequality.pdf https://www.cepweb.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/CEP_WP_Inf...
>Inflation and Income Inequality in Developed Economies
>We find a U-shaped link between long-run inflation and income inequality. Low inflation rates are associated with higher income inequality. As inflation goes up, inequality decreases, reaches a minimum with an inflation rate of about 13%, and then starts rising again
- roenxi 7y ago> Inflation does not increase the real return from stock markets. Inflation erodes also capital. Capital must work just to stay still. Actually, it is not so. What we call 'real return' in the stock market is stock prices as a percentage less consumer price inflation as a percentage. If inflation causes stocks prices to inflate more quickly than wages, then it will appear to boost real returns in the stock market because we aren't very good at measuring such things. To state the same thing in a different way, there is no special reason why consumer price inflation and asset price inflation should be the same thing. Modern methods of money creation (ie, post what has been happening post 1970) focus on money creation by lending people money to buy assets. It seems quite unlikely that the inflation indexes in common use are the right adjustments to make to the stock market, house prices, etc, etc. Look at the price of gold for example - according to the BLS [0] $165 dollars of gold in 1975 should be worth about $811 today. It is actually worth double that. Gold is a pet rock with no prospect of a real return, and also out of fashion as an asset. It is certainly not the sort of thing people borrow money to purchase - and that makes it a great indicator that asset prices are inflating much faster than the official inflation statistics, because even with those headwinds it is acting as though owning a pet rock is a productive long-term decision. It is quite likely that inflation is reallocating resources from workers to owners of assets. [0] https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm [1] https://goldprice.org/gold-price-history.html https://goldprice.org/gold-price-history.html
- imtringued 7y ago>This is complete misunderstanding of how this works. Inflation does not increase the real return from stock markets. Inflation erodes also capital. Capital must work just to stay still. I think you made a basic mistake there. The assumption you're making is that the inflation is spread over every single citizen. In reality there is no reason for that to happen. It is equally possible for all inflation to happen in the stock or housing market which is inaccessible to the average low income worker. Therefore the one who is staying still is the low income worker.
- dredmorbius 7y agoAsset price inflation != currency devaluation. There are structural incentives to inflate asset prices (free wealth to the holders), though those aren't ironclad (bubbles burst). Bernhard J. Stein's work (1930s - 50s) is interesting here. Commodity price inflation tends to have different mechanisms, as does wage erosion. There are other classes of economic goods, including public goods, taxes, interest and (in some cases distinguished from assets) capital goods. For all that Adam Smith discussed these (the better parts of books 1, 2, and 5 of Wealth of Nations), they are, IMO, poorly considered in most modern economics. Marginal analysis only explains part of their dynamics. I'm also increasingly convinced inflation is a symptom rather than a fundamental problem.